About us Login Get email updates
County Fair
Print

John Yoo is a lousy columnist, too.

May 12, 2009 5:09 pm ET by Jamison Foser

Given that, as a government official, John Yoo was an architect of the Bush administration's torture policies and tried to secure for George W. Bush near-dictatorial powers, it probably goes without saying that he isn't much of a columnist.

Let's say it anyway.

Right out of the gate, in the first column in which Yoo is identified as a Philadelphia Inquirer columnist, Yoo displays naked partisan hypocrisy, blasting President Obama for citing empathy as a quality a Supreme Court justice should possess after Yoo himself had praised Clarence Thomas for displaying that very quality.

Yoo then claims Obama is shifting his stance on empathy: "Obama's call for emotive judges contradicts his moderate campaign positions."

Shifting your position with the political winds, as Yoo has done, is one thing.  Following such a shift with an attack on someone else for doing exactly what you have just done is taking partisan hackery to another level.

But that's not all!  This is John Yoo we're talking about -- one of the villains behind the Bush administration's use of torture and its shameless power-grabs.  You think he's going to stop at some hypocritical nonsense about "empathy"?  No way.

Yoo went on to argue that Obama should not appoint an "activist" judge, thus mindlessly repeating the stupid talking point every Republican has used to attack every Democratic judicial nominee (actual or potential) since the dawn of time. 

But in Yoo's case, the attack is particularly silly.  See, right there at the end of Yoo's column, his bio line notes "He has served as a law clerk to Justice Clarence Thomas."  And Yoo has lavished praise upon his former boss.  And Clarence Thomas is, by one measure, the single most activist member of the Supreme Court.

No, John Yoo probably can't do as much harm to America as a Phildelphia Inquirer columnist as he did as a government official.  But that won't stop him from trying.

UPDATE: More from Yoo's column: "Obama could make a pick based solely on race or sex - though it's not clear why the most empathetic judges are minorities or women - to please parts of his coalition."  Nobody wants Obama to make a pick "based solely on race or sex."  Nobody.  If Obama picked, for example, Yoo's unindicted co-conspirator Alberto Gonzales, for example, he'd have a bunch of unhappy liberals on his hands.  It is, of course, too much to expect a man who argues in favor of torture and unchecked executive power to bother with niceties like accurately describing the positions of the people he is arguing with, but the slur that women and minorities don't care about qualifications shouldn't go unrebutted. 

And more Yoo:

If Obama shoots for empathy ... he will give Senate Republicans yet another opportunity to rally around a unifying issue where they better represent the majority of Americans.

He's kidding, right?  John Yoo doesn't even represent himself when it comes to whether judges should possess empathy.  He thinks he's going to rally the majority of Americans to oppose empathy?  Come on.

Expand All Expand 1st Level Collapse All Add Comment
    • Author by Dem02020 (May 12, 2009 5:21 pm ET)
         

      It looks like this little Bush Cheney jerk is going to be propelled into a Republican hack media darling, and among those we can thank for it, are the same people who gave us "General Betrayus."
      Report Abuse
      • Author by seeryer (May 12, 2009 5:29 pm ET)
           
        I don't understand the last part of your sentence? Are oyu saying Patreus is part of the problem? I don't think so. My opinion is he is a DEM but right wingers always assumed he was a Republican.
        Report Abuse
        • Author by Dem02020 (May 12, 2009 5:50 pm ET)
             

          Who are the people who gave us "General Betrayus", or should I say "General Betray Us", and gave us that term by way of a New York Times ad?

          These people, who represent perhaps the worst and most destructive element to the Democratic party, are at present pushing this idiotic "torture memo" crap to an extreme (and they're alienating a lot of good Democrats in the process).

          The political instincts these people are demonstrating on this "torture memo" crap, are about as good as the political instincts they demonstrated with the "General Betray Us" ad.
          Report Abuse
          • Author by magnolialover (May 12, 2009 6:01 pm ET)
               
            So torturing people under our "care" is crap? Really? OK... If you think so.

            The Betray Us ad went into a lot of detail about how Patraeus' testimony was allegedly ramped up by the White House. That being said, I think Patraeus is probably the smartest, and most adept military leader that we have today in our country, and I think him a great American. If we had followed his advice when we first went into Iraq, it wouldn't nearly be the mess that it is today.
            Report Abuse
    • Author by Parth (May 13, 2009 1:48 am ET)
         
      How is this Yoo guy even EMPLOYED, much less also a columnist for a major paper?

      In most industries, "Um, yeah, apparently you're *this* close to being indicted for breaking international law, and your legal opinions are, how can I delicately put this…morally repugnant. Sorry, John, we're gonna have to let you go," would be the course of action.
      Report Abuse
    • Author by Recluse (May 13, 2009 8:03 am ET)
         
      I wonder how many republicons had to look up empathy in the dictionary. Most had probably never come across it before. None have ever felt it.
      I won't read the whole thing but the quotes are enough to know it's a lousy column by a lousy columnist. So I looked up louse and it's Yoo - a contemptible person.
      JC
      Report Abuse

my.MediaMatters.org

Login  Sign Up

About the Blog

Feed Icon
  • County Fair is a media blog featuring links to progressive media criticism from around the Web as well as original commentary, breaking news and rapid response updates to major media events from Media Matters senior fellows and other staff.

Weekly Columns

Feed Icon