About us Login Get email updates
County Fair
Print

Concocting a "hasty" gotcha story

May 21, 2009 8:55 am ET by Eric Boehlert

David Paul Kuhn at RealClearPolitics wrote up a report about Gibb's Q&A at the WH press briefing yesterday. Kuhn reported that Gibb had claimed that closing the detention center at Guantánamo Bay, Cuba, had been a “hasty decision.” But that's not what Gibbs said.

Asked by a reporter to clarify that comment, Gibbs quickly explained that he meant the decision made by the previous Republican administration to set up the detention center had been "hasty," and that he was in no way suggesting the Obama WH had made a "hasty decision" to try to close it.  

Said Gibbs:

"No, no, no, I'm sorry...Thank you for letting me clarify that before I go see the boss later this afternoon."

So how did RealClearPolitics report it? RCP suggested it wasn't clear what Gibbs had really meant by his "hasty" comment: 

So either the White House spokesman misspoke or said too much. That’s for the public to decide. To some critics, Gibbs comment might evoke Michael Kinsley's famous political adage. Kinsley defined a gaffe in Washington as a moment when someone tells the truth.  

Choosing not to believe Gibbs who clarified his comment and detailed exactly what he meant by the remark, RCP opted to play dumb in order to concoct a story.   

Nice touch: RCP provides a video of Gibbs' "hasty decision" quote, but does not show the video of him clarifying his remark.

UPDATE: Here's Gibbs' initial response in full, to a question about whether the Obama WH had made a mistake in trying to close the Cuba detention center. In his response, Gibbs turned the question around the stressed that it was wrong to create that specific center in the first place:

It was a mistake to set up something what became a rallying cry for enemies around the world and to hope for so long that we could simply continue to perpetuate the theory of keeping detainees there while the courts ruled otherwise.

I don't doubt that the President -- and I think he'll say this tomorrow -- that we've made some hasty decisions that are now going to take some time to unwind. And closing Guantanamo Bay obviously is one of those decisions.

The second half of the answer did become a bit confusing because when Gibbs used "we" he was referring to the U.S. government, not the Obama administration.

That's why when given a chance Gibbs clarified his comments. But RCP pretends it can't decide what Gibbs really meant.

UPDATE: Of course, the right-wing blogs are picking up on RCP's dreadful reporting and crowing about how Gibbs admitted closing the center at Guantánamo Bay had been a "hasty decision."

Expand All Expand 1st Level Collapse All Add Comment
    • Author by mattcable250650 (May 21, 2009 9:17 am ET)
      1  
      I certainly agree with the quote about truth and Washington DC. I think the classic one was where Ronald Reagan talked about the successes of his administration and repeated the line "Facts are stubborn things." At one point, he forgot and said "Facts are stupid things." We progressives always considered that a moment when Reagan slipped up and told us all his real attitude about facts.
      But does the quote/idea have anything whatsoever to do with this situation? Nah, it's quite clear that it doesn't as Obama spoke about Gitmo on the campaign trail and as his Administration has been publicly wrestling with the issue for awhile.
      Report Abuse
      • Author by solon (May 21, 2009 1:59 pm ET)
        1  
        The one that really got to me was when Raygun made up this Wellfare Queen from Chicago story and the press looked into it. There was of course no such person as he described. The media pressed an administration official to cough up the evidence such a person existed and they admitted they didnt. So when asked directly if the story was a lie the guy said IT MADE THE POINT DIDNT IT? Except no it didnt. If you have to LIE to make a point then you didnt HAVE one. Washington seems not to have learned that lesson yet. Reagan was bad for this country in many ways but the two worst things he did was convince the American people that complex problems all had simple answers and showed the right that there was simply NO downside to them lying.
        Report Abuse
    • Author by mk3872 (May 21, 2009 9:58 am ET)
      1  
      The WH press corps is not at all interested in serious stories with depth. They are like little jouvenile brats just looking for conflict and gotchas at all times. They are really pathetic.
      Report Abuse
      • Author by papajohn (May 21, 2009 10:30 am ET)
        3  
        he WH press corps is not at all interested in serious stories with depth. They are like little jouvenile brats just looking for conflict and gotchas at all times. They are really pathetic.
        ========
        Not under Bush they didn't. Under Clinton and now again under Obama. Their purpose in life is to support Republicans and their lies - period.
        How do you change that? Democrats won't. They are constantly trying to outmaneuver the press and their lies instead of taking them head on.
        The most mind boggling thing I see is allowing the networks to hide the Republican filibusters instead of being on message when they are on the networks. "The Democrats are in charge and there is nothing Republicans can do about it". How many times have you heard that. Rachael Maddow is the only TV person who has explained to the public how Republicans have abused the filibuster. That is why Republicans have no problem going on national tv and being hypocrites. No challenge from the media OR the Democrats. The dumbest thing Democrats say on national tv is "The American people are smarter than that"? Who writes this stuff for them?
        Report Abuse

my.MediaMatters.org

Login  Sign Up

About the Blog

Feed Icon
  • County Fair is a media blog featuring links to progressive media criticism from around the Web as well as original commentary, breaking news and rapid response updates to major media events from Media Matters senior fellows and other staff.