About us Login Get email updates
County Fair
Print

Is the "fabled conservative media echo chamber" too successful?

June 08, 2009 1:53 pm ET by Karl Frisch

Well, The Nation's Ari Melber argues that it is. He picks up on something we've been noting here on CF and at Media Matters in general for some time -- that the rudderless conservative movement is being led by folks like Rush Limbaugh.

Writes Melber:

For years, independent experts and strategists in both parties all agreed that conservative media was a crucial part of the Republican Party's resurgence. Talk radio mobilized the base, with Rush Limbaugh wielding influence that rivaled most GOP senators. Fox News framed national debates and turned party talking points into conventional wisdom. It worked so well, Democrats pined for their own echo chamber, plowing money into think tanks and political media efforts to imitate the GOP model. The message machine that helped put Republicans in power, however, now looks like an albatross for the opposition party.

Let's take a step back. There has not been a single hearing on Sotomayor's nomination, but Senate Republicans are already playing defense over the party's response to the nomination. But who speaks for the Republican Party? As every politico knows, the GOP's Supreme Court vision was hijacked by Limbaugh and Gingrich, two of the most visible pundits atop the conservative media machine. While the Republicans who wield actual power in this process - U.S. Senators and especially judiciary committee members – have to angle for a single TV appearance, Gingrich holds court with his paid platform on Fox. (Rush also dropped by there Wednesday). Gingrich amplifies his views with an online regiment that is downright millennial in its scope -- including "Second Life." His instantly infamous "Latina woman racist" tweet dominated several news cycles, and his blog post recanting it topped all online political news Wednesday, (according to the news aggregator Memeorandum). And now Limbaugh is backtracking as only he can, volunteering that he might support Sotomayor after all -- but he still thinks she is a racist. Apparently racism is not a disqualifying judicial quality for him.

Expand All Expand 1st Level Collapse All Add Comment
    • Author by all your eyes (June 08, 2009 3:08 pm ET)
      1  
      it's funny, where i work i'm surrounded by vocal "conservatives" who have drunk the kool aid, which i imagine to be something like what they made indiana jones drink in the temple of doom, but i digress....
      i am known around here for my "liberal" beliefs and command of the news, so they come up to me every day, independently of one another, asking the same questions: why did obama say the US is the biggest muslim country? why is obama apologizing for america? why is obama socializing medicine? and on and on...
      the funny thing is, none of them seems to be aware of the concept of the echo chamber, and none will admit to taking their talking points from drudge, fox news, limbaugh, etc. yet somehow, they invariably have the same talking points, none of which make any sense. and confronted with this lunacy, they tend to shrink away and avoid politics for the rest of the day, until they come back tomorrow with the next day's talking points for rebutting.
      i think they like the rebuttal honestly, i think they enjoy it for some reason. my hunch is they know how insane the talking points are, and they hunger to hear them rebuked; i hope it slowly wears away at the ideological house of mirrors they live in.. probably not.. but i still hope, they're nice people when they're not spouting hateful lies, believing it to be truth.
      Report Abuse
    • Author by all your eyes (June 08, 2009 3:08 pm ET)
         
      it's funny, where i work i'm surrounded by vocal "conservatives" who have drunk the kool aid, which i imagine to be something like what they made indiana jones drink in the temple of doom, but i digress....
      i am known around here for my "liberal" beliefs and command of the news, so they come up to me every day, independently of one another, asking the same questions: why did obama say the US is the biggest muslim country? why is obama apologizing for america? why is obama socializing medicine? and on and on...
      the funny thing is, none of them seems to be aware of the concept of the echo chamber, and none will admit to taking their talking points from drudge, fox news, limbaugh, etc. yet somehow, they invariably have the same talking points, none of which make any sense. and confronted with this lunacy, they tend to shrink away and avoid politics for the rest of the day, until they come back tomorrow with the next day's talking points for rebutting.
      i think they like the rebuttal honestly, i think they enjoy it for some reason. my hunch is they know how insane the talking points are, and they hunger to hear them rebuked; i hope it slowly wears away at the ideological house of mirrors they live in.. probably not.. but i still hope, they're nice people when they're not spouting hateful lies, believing it to be truth.
      Report Abuse
      • Author by newzhound (June 08, 2009 3:11 pm ET)
           
        Talk about an echo...echo...
        Report Abuse
        • Author by all your eyes (June 08, 2009 3:43 pm ET)
             
          blame the techies at media matters. it appeared that the post didn't take, until the second time. i've seen this around on the comments, it's not just me..
          Report Abuse
          • Author by eweston8542983 (June 08, 2009 5:39 pm ET)
               
            Yep, it was extremely slow doing anything on site yesterday.
            Report Abuse
          • Author by robyn20094113 (June 09, 2009 3:02 am ET)
               
            I too have had this problem with double posts that I did not post also it will post when I hit review so the posts do not have spelling corrections...

            I get sick of hearing conservatives say that you will never hear the truth from main stream media, then admit that they no longer read the news papers, listen to talk radio for hours & hours a day & the only tv they watch is Fox News & maybe Colbert Report adding he is a genius (I do agree he's a genius) They are totally brainwashed. They do not listen to an objective point of view because they are afraid of the truth. They do not want to have to question anything their heroes Hannity, Limbaugh, Beck, Savage etc. have to say. Those heroes never have to answer for their lies.
            Report Abuse