Former Bush speechwriter Peter Wehner says "the role Glenn Beck is playing is harmful in its totality"
September 21, 2009 10:04 pm ET by Media Matters staff
From a September 21 blog post by Peter Wehner on the Commentary magazine blog Contentions:
Only recently have I watched portions of [Glenn Beck's] television program, as well as interviews with him, and heard parts of his radio program. And what I’ve seen should worry the conservative movement.
I say that because he seems to be more of a populist and libertarian than a conservative, more of a Perotista than a Reaganite. His interest in conspiracy theories is disquieting, as is his admiration for Ron Paul and his charges of American “imperialism.” (He is now talking about pulling troops out of Afghanistan, South Korea, Germany, and elsewhere.) Some of Beck’s statements -- for example, that President Obama has a “deep-seated hatred for white people” -- are quite unfair and not good for the country. His argument that there is very little difference between the two parties is silly, and his contempt for parties in general is anti-Burkean (Burke himself was a great champion of political parties). And then there is his sometimes bizarre behavior, from tearing up to screaming at his callers. Beck seems to be a roiling mix of fear, resentment, and anger -- the antithesis of Ronald Reagan.
I understand that a political movement is a mansion with many rooms; the people who occupy them are involved in intellectual and policy work, in politics, and in polemics. Different people take on different roles. And certainly some of the things Beck has done on his program are fine and appropriate. But the role Glenn Beck is playing is harmful in its totality. My hunch is that he is a comet blazing across the media sky right now -- and will soon flame out. Whether he does or not, he isn’t the face or disposition that should represent modern-day conservatism. At a time when we should aim for intellectual depth, for tough-minded and reasoned arguments, for good cheer and calm purpose, rather than erratic behavior, he is not the kind of figure conservatives should embrace or cheer on.

















...this guy (Beck) is going to crash and burn, and that is not wishing him bad, its just the way these things always play out.
The Glenn Beck saga has all the makings of ending badly.
I would not want to be within 1000 feet of this guy when he finally snaps
Beck may have the same issue, but he doesn't matter. He's not the president of the United States. He's also not the one dismantling everything that made this a great country for over 200 years. His policies are making us mediocre AT BEST. I guess immigration will subside b/c no one will want to come to a country when it looks just like the one they want to leave. I wonder when golf (or anything else) will be seen as bourgeoisie in the US.
And Beck lives in the room with padded walls... Beck is a certifiable nut case.
I don't have a problem with Beck saying the President "hates white people" or Savage saying "I hope you get AIDS and die". Their Arbitron numbers rock.
Neither Beck nor Savage represent conservative ideology. They simply represent hatred.
BTW, you are aware that Michael "Savage" Weiner is a bigger liar than Beck and that's saying a LOT.
I'll have to disagree with you there. They're more like some disgruntled kitchen employee peeing in the soup.
There, I fixed all 13 errors for you. I'm glad to see that you're such a big fan of being educated.
Yet, I'm a little concerned that you just recently came out of your cocoon to weigh in on this comet sighting...but better late than never.
Perotista? I concur.
Antithesis of Pres.Reagan...again I concur.
Preying on the fears and emotions of people may generate TV and radio ratings...but in the end...real leaders have always surfaced because they had solutions.
After all...who is Glen Beck...really, who is Glen Beck?
I'll tell you who he is...a former disk jockey that has found it profitable to prey on the fears and distrust of some people. Charlatans have always managed to find a prominent place in the public arena...until they were exposed as empty vessels.
Is Beck an empty vessel? Time will tell...but right now I lean towards the character Lonesome Rhodes in the movie "A Face in the Crowd".
Many of the problems we are having now in this country came about because of Reagan's policies.
Nah, seriously, I wish the guys trying to separate the Republican Party from their wackier fringe nutcases all the best. They're fleas riding on an elephant, but I wish them all the best.
You guys are so proud of the Beck ad boycott, it is starting to crack. You cheer when Olbermann puts people on his silly worst person list, that is not much better than Orielly's pin heads or patriots. Oh well, time to go read the daily Kos and see who and what they are moaning about now. I forget that the silent majority is out there and it is left, or is it, has left?
Progressive will help the right change its skin just in time by acting like these "critics" are genuinely troubled.
Look at Boner and Cantor saying they worry about the image Bachmann gives them. The SOBs never stood up and said anything all the time she has been saying these nutty things but now the "party" sees their cult like insanity as a drag on 2010. The polls must be ringing. So Cantor and Boner contact Politico and have them do their dirty work of remaking their image.
Any progressive site that does not point out what fraud this is, is helping them. IMO!