About us Login Get email updates
County Fair
Print

Right-wing group smears NBC producer as anti-Semite; won't produce hard evidence

September 30, 2009 1:59 pm ET by Eric Boehlert

Michael Calderone at Politico has been tracking this stunning case of conservative press-bashing, which seems to break new ground with its reckless execution.

The short version is that Americans for Limited Government has sent out three press releases claiming that a producer at NBC News, Jane Stone, after receiving an ALG email alert, returned the email to a ALG staffer with the anti-Semitic note,  “Bite me Jew Boy!”  NBC News chief Steve Capus immediately, and adamantly, denied the claim and announced that a complete IT email analysis by NBC proved the email the producer sent to ALG  never included the hateful "Bite me Jew Boy!" phrase. (Instead, it simply read “Take me off this list!”)

Since late last week, ALG has refused to produce any sort of hard evidence back up its vicious smear, such as the email headers that came attached to the supposed anti-Semitic message.

And today, Calderone notes:

Communications director Carter Clews told me that ALG does not plan to release email “headers”—as NewsBusters was told Saturday—or a taped phone conversation with Stone, where she allegedly first claimed to have not sent any email to the organization. Clews mentioned the taped phone call on New Majority. Also, ALG declined my request to visit the group's Fairfax office to look at their evidence firsthand.

Calderone correctly concludes, "NBC firmly stands behind Stone, and I feel the burden of proof is now on ALG to produce something that clearly ties her to this allegation."

And so far, it's crickets from ALG.

UPDATED: In his denunciation of ALG, NBC's Capus mentioned he was "shocked" by the group's irresponsible behavior. I guess my question is, Why? I suppose Capus was shocked because NBC was the unfortunate target this time. But honestly, the right-wing is addicted to this kind of hateful, anti-press garbage, and the sooner mainstream news outlets admit that and start reporting on it, the better off we'd all be.

Expand All Expand 1st Level Collapse All Add Comment
    • Author by mustardman (September 30, 2009 2:12 pm ET)
      1  
      These people are not very good with facts and logic. The two things necessary to be competent at technology matters such as how email works and how to disprove email LIES!
      Report Abuse
    • Author by mk3872 (September 30, 2009 2:33 pm ET)
      1  
      When will the DoJ step in and take this on?
      Report Abuse
    • Author by sanity-irrelevant (September 30, 2009 2:56 pm ET)
         
      ALG says it got a nasty anti-semetic email.
      NBC says that's not true, it was just a request to be taken off a mailing list.

      In it's initial press release, ALG doesn't do the obvious thing, which is to post the full headers of the email.

      NBC's response doesn't include the full headers either.

      ALG in a later press release takes a lot of ad hominem swipes at NBC and says that it wants a joint investigation with NBC.

      And that's where it looks like it is going to stay.

      But ALG is cheating. They've made the allegation and so the burden is on them to prove that it is true, whether or not NBC wants to cooperate. Spend a few bucks and hire an independent expert to go through your logs and records and report what's there.
      Report Abuse
      • Author by mustardman (September 30, 2009 3:09 pm ET)
           
        yawwwn......just more lies DAMN lies from the reich. How many more times must they cry wolf before people start ignoring them!
        Report Abuse
        • Author by quantpro (September 30, 2009 3:35 pm ET)
             
          Whats the other cry from the wolf you are thinking of, Acorn scandals? No charges should be made without evidence to support them, period!
          Report Abuse
    • Author by kfraz43 (September 30, 2009 3:09 pm ET)
         
      This is the way it works, boys and girls - building a house one card at a time. The underlying intent, I suppose, is to push forward the idea that liberals are anti-semetic, despite the fact that they can't prove that someone is either. It fits nicely with the case they are building in the Israel-Palestine peace talks - that Obama and his administration are anti-semitic because they actually have the gall to consider the Palestinians in their discussions.

      I think it goes like this:

      Jane Stone = liberal, anti-semite
      NBC = shill for Obama
      Jane Stone = NBC
      Therefore...
      NBC = liberal, anti-semite shill for Obama.
      Report Abuse
      • Author by Conchobhar (September 30, 2009 6:10 pm ET)
           
        That's wingnut "logic", all right. Even if the starting premise were proven, the syllogism has holes you could drive a truck through.
        Report Abuse
    • Author by Meremark (September 30, 2009 7:12 pm ET)
         
      At this, Eric, "... the right-wing is addicted to this kind of hateful, anti-press garbage, and the sooner mainstream news outlets admit that and start reporting ...,"

      the distinction separating "the right-wing" from the "mainstream news outlets" which you clearly see (or imagine), I don't see (since I stopped imagining it, circa FLORIDA 2000).

      In my mind:

      the mainstream news outlets = the right-wing

      It's the news's m.o. If it bleeds, and is fearsome, it leads.


      And vice-versa:

      the right-wing = the mainstream news outlets

      It's the only facilities, and propertied territory, the right-wing governs.





      So I pshaw! balderdash! all the talk I read about "incompetent" news media, "stupid, playing dumb" news media, "CYA" news media -- all that talk only serves the speaker's compulsion insisting to see a distinction and separate autonomy (sovereignty?) where NONE EXISTS between fascist politics and massmedia mentality (programming). That is, Murdoch is a right-wing mainstay, NBC/GE is a right-wing mainstay, Disney/ABC is a right-wing mainstay, Schulzberger / Ochs / Graham / Safire / Will / Broder / == Allen Dulles IS a right-wing mainstay. The 'mainstream news media' IS the 'right-wing.'

      So, now, WHEN are 'they' going to start reporting about 'them'? And make things overall better off for all of us?

      'They' ain't. If by "we"/'us' you mean actual factual traditional principled Journalism practitioners, in news media, then the more 'better off' we/us would be, the less (polity) influential are they right-wing Big Lie-ers, pretender in news media -- news better reported =IS= right-wing more upbraided, upstaged, more downcast, more removed.

      When established media do a good news job they are out of a job.

      Report Abuse

my.MediaMatters.org

Login  Sign Up

About the Blog

Feed Icon
  • County Fair is a media blog featuring links to progressive media criticism from around the Web as well as original commentary, breaking news and rapid response updates to major media events from Media Matters senior fellows and other staff.

Weekly Columns

Feed Icon