About us Login Get email updates
County Fair
Print

PolitiFact:  Beck's claim about health care bill "offering insurance for dogs" is "Pants on Fire" wrong

November 16, 2009 12:20 pm ET by Media Matters staff

From PolitiFact.com:

Like so many claims in the health care debate, Beck has taken a kernel of something in the bill and spun it to an absurd conclusion.

Included in the House bill is the creation of a Public Health Workforce Corps to address shortages in the public health workforce. The program would provide scholarships and education loan repayment assistance for public health professionals serving in areas of need. Veterinarians are included among those public health professionals.

"The rationale is that with mad cow disease, swine flu and other animal-borne diseases and issues, there is logic in helping to create more and better trained individuals to treat animal health," said Vincent Morris, spokesman for the House Rules Committee, which is chaired by Rep. Louise Slaughter, D-N.Y.

But the inclusion of veterinarians in the health bill didn't sit well with Rep. Cliff Stearns, R-Fla., who noted on the House floor on Nov. 7, 2009, that the loan repayment program will cost $283 million over five years.

"So the real question I have for you folks (Democrats): Why are veterinarians part of this health care bill?" Stearns asked.

Rep. Slaughter responded: "Have you ever heard of swine flu? Have you ever heard about food safety? Have you ever heard that 70 percent of all of the antibiotics produced in the United States are given to cattle and poultry even though they are not ill? But swine flu should make you worry a little bit, don't you think?"

The bill also would provide funding for fellowships to support public health training, and again, veterinary medicine is included in the mix. Lastly, the bill would create an advisory committee to assess the health workforce and to make recommendations to ensure that workforce is meeting the nation's needs. The bill says that would include public health professions "including veterinarians engaged in public health practice." In other words, not the local vet who gives your dog heartworm pills.

Two other things about the scholarships and loan assistance programs. In order to qualify, the bill says applicants must "have demonstrated expertise in public health" and as quid pro quo must serve for a period equal to their scholarship in a public health program assigned by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Again, not your pet vet down the street.

"Veterinarians are a part of the public health workforce, especially those that deal with disease outbreak," said Brian Cook, press secretary for Pete Stark, D-Calif., chair of the Ways and Means Health Subcommittee. "We have a shortage of veterinarians right now who are trained to deal with disease outbreak."

Still, scholarships, loan assistance and fellowships to veterinarians is one thing. Providing government health insurance to dogs is quite another.

"We are not offering insurance for dogs," Morris said.

We pored over the bill and came to the same conclusion. There is no health insurance of any kind for dogs -- no public option for Rex, no death panels for Fido.

So we've got to put Beck in the doghouse for this one -- Pants on Fire!

Expand All Expand 1st Level Collapse All Add Comment
    • Author by rwmacdonald2091 (November 16, 2009 12:37 pm ET)
      1  
      So we've got to put Beck in the doghouse for this one -- Pants on Fire!

      When did he get out of the doghouse from the last "pants on fire" lie?
      Report Abuse
    • Author by Diosnomeama (November 16, 2009 12:45 pm ET)
         
      If Beck's pants really are on fire, that would explain a lot of his behavior.
      Report Abuse
    • Author by DellDolly (November 16, 2009 12:53 pm ET)
      2 1
      If you look at Politifact.org, you'll see that almost all of the lies and Pants on Fire lies come from the right. This group leans to the right, and still they find many, many more offensive things from the right and their supporters.

      20 out of 20 of the most recent Pants on Fire lies are from the right.

      In the second 20, they list the comment by Barack Obama about how many Muslims are in the USA, and how we'd be one of the largest Muslim countries if you looked at our population. How is THAT a Pants on Fire lie? But that's the closest they can come to one from our side! Or they list Joe Biden's hyperbole about how germs are spread on airplanes. Sure, it's true that air circulation and exchange on jets has improved, but it's still true that you'd be hard-pressed to find a more restrictive environment for germ-exchange in our everyday environment than in an enclosed jet. That's not worth a Pants on Fire declaration either.

      37 out of 40 of the most recent Pants on Fire lies they've found were from the right.

      Report Abuse
    • Author by Prup (aka Jim Benton) (November 16, 2009 1:10 pm ET)
         
      Okay, maybe I am biased -- I say as my cats aim deadly glares at my direction and force me to write this, though I'd write it anyway -- but given the fact that many studies have shown that having pets is a major aid to sick people, that seeing eye dogs are considered a medical necessity, as well as the other exampes mentioned in the post, paying for vet training strikes me as more than sensible, medically.

      [Btw, can anyone say how many posts are considered 'enough' so that mine can get out of moderation? I have never -- and can't imagine myself -- violating these terms of service, and after four years of commenting on various blogs, I don't think I've ever posted one which would have been questioned here.]
      Report Abuse
      • Author by DellDolly (November 16, 2009 11:57 pm ET)
           
        It can take weeks, if you post infrequently, to get out of moderation. It took me close to a week of posting fairly frequently to get out of moderation. They don't moderate over the weekend.
        Report Abuse
    • Author by John Paradox (November 16, 2009 2:55 pm ET)
         
      Google: Pet Insurance

      Just sayin'
      Report Abuse
    • Author by shaggles (November 16, 2009 3:09 pm ET)
         
      I wish there were pet health insurance in the bill. But then there'd be a big outcry about forced sterilizations. I can hear Becky now.
      Report Abuse

my.MediaMatters.org

Login  Sign Up

About the Blog

Feed Icon
  • County Fair is a media blog featuring links to progressive media criticism from around the Web as well as original commentary, breaking news and rapid response updates to major media events from Media Matters senior fellows and other staff.