About us Login Get email updates
County Fair
Print

"Say goodbye" to common sense: RedState compares health care reform to attack on Pearl Harbor

November 25, 2009 4:02 pm ET by Brooke Obie

In the latest bit of right-wing lunacy on health care reform, RedState.com writer "hogan" brazenly compares health care reform bills to Japan's attack on Pearl Harbor in 1941--inanely adding that if health care reform passes, you can "say goodbye to freedom." Indeed, a brutal sneak attack that obliterated or wounded at least 3,500 Americans on an early Sunday morning is certainly comparable to legislation that will decrease the deficit over 10 years, provide coverage for 94% of uninsured Americans, and prohibit insurance companies from dropping the insured due to pre-existing conditions.

Yet, with Fox News' Glenn Beck comparing health care reform to the attacks on 9/11 and former Bush press secretary Dana Perino obliviously declaring: "we did not have a terrorist attack on our country during President Bush's term," one can only wonder if-like the words socialism, Marxism, fascism and freedom-maybe the right-wing media simply doesn't know what the word terrorism means.  

Here's the RedState post in all its glorious folly:

Saving Freedom This Thanksgiving

Posted by hogan (Profile)

Wednesday, November 25th at 12:41PM EST

2 Comments

68 years ago, Americans around the nation settled into a peaceful Thanksgiving weekend and celebrated with their loved ones. A week later, the nation was viciously attacked by Japan - an attack that sparked our involvement in perhaps the greatest of all wars.

This Thanksgiving holiday is different from that weekend. While we should likewise celebrate and give thanks for our innumerable blessings, this time, the American people are staring at an attack on our nation and can stop it. This attack is coming from within. The Obama/Reid/Pelosi healthcare bill - in its various forms - is an assault on the American way of life and an affront to all the generations before us who fought to preserve and protect our cherished freedoms.

Why? Because the bill will eliminate your God-given ability to care for your family according to YOUR wishes and YOUR conscience. It will insert Washington D.C., and the incompetent bureaucrats who live there, into your hospital room, your doctor's office, your insurance company, your home and ultimately, into your personal health decisions. As analyzed here, the bill is loaded with active-government terms like "shall," "tax," and "require." And, even a cursory review of the text will show how much power this bill gives Washington to interfere with your healthcare (you know, the town that brought you the TARP bailout, Katrina-relief and over $12 Trillion in debt and counting...). Qualifications, panels, reports, studies, mandatory insurance whether you want it or not, penalties, taxes, fees, mandates on coverage but restrictions on prices... and 2079 pages of non-stop assaults on your right to live free and care for your family as you see fit.

Say hello to lines, waiting rooms, priority lists and more expensive, less effective healthcare. Say goodbye to freedom.

That is, unless you act now. It is your job - indeed, it is your duty - to talk to your friends and family this weekend and in the coming weeks. Call them to action. Other than our fine men and women in uniform fighting around the world, there is nothing more important that you can be doing right now to preserve our children's birthright - heirs to the greatest nation the world has ever known.

Read over the bill. Read summaries. Whatever you need to do. Try the Heritage Foundation's website, http://fixhealthcarepolicy.com/. Then... pause the football games and take a break from the turkey and cranberry sauce. Talk to friends and family this weekend. Explain it to them.

Then... next week, when the Senate come back in session - call your Senator. Email more friends. Email more family. Then... Call your Senator AGAIN. Don't stop. Repeat. Then... call Senators on the fence. And, feel free to start with Senators Ben Nelson (R-NE), Blanche Lincoln (D-AR), and Mary Landrieu (D- LA). They represent solidly red states - and need to have their feat [sic] held to the fire. The list of Senate office phone numbers can be found here. Shut their phones down. Flood their offices. Visit their offices.

The American people can win this, but only if you take action to stop it. There is one thing that elected representatives fear - and that is YOU, the American people. Celebrate Thanksgiving this year in the American way - by fighting for freedom and working hard to preserve this, the last best earthly hope for mankind.

Expand All Expand 1st Level Collapse All Add Comment
    • Author by shaggles (November 25, 2009 4:06 pm ET)
      2 1
      When did RedState ever have common sense?
      Report Abuse
      • Author by rtejon (November 26, 2009 7:16 pm ET)
           
        At the beginning of the primary season, Erick wrote a column about the GOP field and said, "they all suck." It was just about the last sensible thing he ever wrote.
        Report Abuse
    • Author by vaberinger (November 25, 2009 4:38 pm ET)
      3 1
      I am so sick of the right wing loonies perverting health care reform (along with everything else that good caring decent people might want to do for one another.) They are immune to facts, spewing their "scary" list of generalities, "say goodbye to freedom." What does that mean? The freedom to have coverage denied to you when you are sick? The freedom to go bankrupt because your insurance refuses to cover treatment? The freedom to die because you just can't afford to get health care and feed and house your family? What is wrong with you people on the right??
      Report Abuse
    • Author by Limit Corp. Ownership (November 25, 2009 4:52 pm ET)
      2 1
      Some times you just have to sit back in awe at how stupid some conservatives are.
      Report Abuse
    • Author by New Frontier (November 25, 2009 5:03 pm ET)
      2  
      pause the football games [...] talk to friends and family this weekend. Explain it to them.

      Yeah, I'm sure they'll appreciate that. I suggest waiting until it's a tie game, first and goal, to be sure you have their attention.
      Report Abuse
    • Author by takeadeepbreath (November 25, 2009 5:21 pm ET)
      1 2
      This article makes some sense. The question I propose is that Redstate, Media Maters and Daily Cos along with Democrats, Republicans and Independents set back have a wonderful Thanksgiving and quite all this bickering. Then come back sit at the round table and think of ways to make this the Great Nation it should be for all people in the USA. Our nation has a two party system, let our elected congressmen(women) set down together to hammer out ways to make healthcare, climate change, foreign policy, national defense, reduce the deficit, etc, let's not be partisan, but bipartisan and not a divided nation as we are now!!
      Every one have a wonderful Thanksgiving.
      God bless.
      Report Abuse
    • Author by Onyxcat (November 26, 2009 8:08 am ET)
         
      Wait a minute, I thought the insurance people tell you how to care for your family, not you.

      "Because the bill will eliminate your God-given ability to care for your family according to YOUR wishes and YOUR conscience"
      Report Abuse
    • Author by GreenLantern (November 27, 2009 12:36 am ET)
         
      As a "practicing" Christian, I cannot understand how any true Christian in their hearts can be a republican. I am neither party. I like MMFA because they find media lies and call them out and I think our media is getting dangerous. That being said, this war on Health Care Reform is about the most un Christian act I can think of besides supporting a war of aggression against a country that didn't even attack us, killing hundreds of thousands of innocent children, toddlers, babies, women and men. Now they think killing almost 50,000 people a year so that some heartless greedy corporation can give a few people that run it more money then they could spend in their lifetime every year? They use monopolistic practices to deny coverage, lie so they can raise their rates to insane levels and collude to completely disadvantage their customer? That is not "free market", free market only works on a small or local level. (Just look at wall street, credit card companies etc, to see that huge industries with just a few players, always screw the customer because the cannot go somewhere else to get service!) I had to bankrupt. I almost lost my house, but luckily had a really good job with insurance but was still $80,000 in debt in less then a year because of their unfair rules and business practices, to keep my wonderful, loving wife alive. She is alive today, only because we were able to change insurance companies after we reached the "Death Limit" of coverage from UHC! We actually become a much more Christian nation by being a little socialist. That is not a bad thing! Sorry, winners of the genetic lottery, some of your riches should go to help the poor and build infrastructure and help children get health care they need as that is what will keep this country great. Hoarding your money while children die because they cannot even get the most simple of health care because of greed is unconscionable! (Sorry for the long post, I get going sometimes)
      Report Abuse

my.MediaMatters.org

Login  Sign Up

About the Blog

Feed Icon
  • County Fair is a media blog featuring links to progressive media criticism from around the Web as well as original commentary, breaking news and rapid response updates to major media events from Media Matters senior fellows and other staff.