About us Login Get email updates
County Fair
Print

Three months after humiliating retraction, Fox gay-baiter Maxim Lott has a new smear

December 14, 2009 8:06 pm ET by Jeremy Schulman

Three months ago, Fox News was forced to issue a humiliating retraction of the false allegations it had leveled against Department of Education official Kevin Jennings. Now, Maxim Lott, the FoxNews.com reporter at the center of those falsehoods, has re-emerged with more smears of Jennings.

This time, in an article headlined "Obama's Safe Schools Czar Tied to Lewd Readings for 7th Graders," Lott reported that Jennings "is under fresh attack after it was revealed that the pro-gay group he formerly headed recommends books his critics say are pornographic." In the article, Lott grossly distorts the contents of books recommended by GLSEN for grades 7-12 and waits until the 13th paragraph to disclose that the list of books included the disclaimer that they "contain mature themes" and the recommendation that "adults selecting books for youth review content for suitability."

And just who are the "critics" who apparently inspired Lott's article? In short: anti-gay bigots.

There's Peter Sprigg of the Family Research Council, who last year announced his desire "to export homosexuals from the United States" -- a comment for which he later apologized (sort of). FRC's website states: "Family Research Council believes that homosexual conduct is harmful to the persons who engage in it and to society at large, and can never be affirmed.  It is by definition unnatural, and as such is associated with negative physical and psychological health effects."

Lott also quoted Peter LaBarbera of American for Truth about Homosexuality. LaBarbera has explained that his attacks on Jennings are "all about homosexuality and the 'gay' activist agenda whose singular goal is to normalize homosexuality as a 'civil right.' "

The fact that Fox continues to allow Lott to report on Jennings is some of the strongest evidence yet that the network isn't a news outlet at all but is actually a right-wing political organization whose mission is to concoct dishonest, bigoted attacks with which to damage progressives and the Obama administration.

Let's revisit some of Lott's past work on the Jennings beat.

On September 30, Lott reported as fact that more 21 years ago, as a young teacher in Massachusetts, Jennings "didn't report that a 15-year-old boy told him that he was having sex with an older man."

At the time, there was substantial evidence available that Lott's claim was false. As Media Matters pointed out, a publicly available 2004 letter from Jennings' lawyer stated that the student was actually 16 years old when the conversation took place. The Massachusetts age of consent is -- and was at the time -- 16; Jennings was under no obligation to report anything. (The student later said that he "had no sexual contact with anybody at the time.")

On October 1, after reporting as fact that the student was "15," Lott apparently decided to check whether this claim was true. As Media Matters exclusively revealed, Lott sent a Facebook message to the student, asking if the "rumor" that he was 15 at the time was "accurate."

Normally, this is the sort of thing journalists ask before leveling allegations at public servants. But Lott and Fox News are apparently so obsessed with gay-baiting that accuracy has become a secondary matter that can wait until after they've run with their charges.

On October 2, two days after Lott's story ran, Media Matters published a statement from the student and a copy of his driver's license, definitively proving that he was 16 at the time of his conversation with Jennings. That same day, the student wrote to Lott and demanded a correction. Eventually, Fox added the following editor's note to the top of Lott's article: "Since this story was originally published, the former student referred to as 'Brewster' has stepped forward to reveal that he was 16 years old, not 15, at the time of the incident described in this report."

Three months later, Lott's back. And he's got a new smear.

Expand All Expand 1st Level Collapse All Add Comment
    • Author by cmj14300 (December 15, 2009 1:15 am ET)
        1
      I feel badly that Media Matters has to constantly defend Kevin Jennings. It’s becoming your main business over there! Then again if people like Kevin Jennings didn’t keep doing stupid stuff in order for it to be so easy to “smear” him then you guys wouldn’t have a job.

      What it comes down to is if it looks like a rat, smells like a rat, sounds like a rat, and acts like a rat, it’s a rat. The book was a bad idea point blank; the gloves a terrible idea no doubt (if you’re encouraging dental dams then just give them dental dams).

      The fact that he’s gay is just a card being pulled like the race card. Gay, straight, alien, I don’t care, some of the decisions he has made have been poor. That’s all it comes down to. Let’s not try to fog the facts by yelling, “Oh you’re just saying that because he’s gay”. Mr. Jennings is being “smeared” because of his poor decisions; nothing more and nothing less.
      Report Abuse
    • Author by DellDolly (December 15, 2009 2:24 am ET)
      2  
      The fact that Fox continues to allow Lott to report on Jennings is some of the strongest evidence yet that the network isn't a news outlet at all but is actually a right-wing political organization whose mission is to concoct dishonest, bigoted attacks with which to damage progressives and the Obama administration.

      Boy, ain't it the truth!
      Report Abuse
    • Author by G.P (December 15, 2009 8:56 am ET)
         
      Every individual human being matters.I am glad to see i am not alone.Maybe i will be persecuted in U.S as i was back in Kosovo,but just so people know until i will be able to have the same freedom as Heterosexuals do doesn't matter rather i am in U.S or were the EARTH is my Country and i deserve my rights back.I lost enaff.What a Human would it call PEACE by seeing,enjoying,trying to change something from GOD something like me ME and lot of my Brothers and Sisters go through TORTURE.My biggest wish when i was a child was to be like my Heterosexual friend there was NO SUCCESS.I never ever would wish to Lose one of the most precious Human i had my MOM???
      But some people can CONTINUING by seeing dreams with OPEN EYES.
      Because people like me never going to give up until i feel my full freedom.
      I was Persecuted back home in Kosovo-former Yougoslavia 2 years ago.I lost so much in my life my family,my everything i had. Is been almost 7 years and i never heard a word from my family and i know how much it hurts and i don't want to see People going thorough the same thing and even worst for what GOD give it to me my Freedom my Life.
      Persecution is a very strong word, why someone such as me has to hope still for my freedom It's a much stronger word than 'discrimination.' It's when somebodies life or liberty is in great jeopardy by the government, or forces that the government can't or will not control, for a protected reason, like sexual orientation.
      Report Abuse
    • Author by G.P (December 15, 2009 10:00 am ET)
         
      Every individual human being matters.I am glad to see i am not alone.Maybe i will be persecuted in U.S as i was back in Kosovo,but just so people know until i will be able to have the same freedom as Heterosexuals do doesn't matter rather i am in U.S or were the EARTH is my Country and i deserve my rights back.I lost enaff.What a Human would it call PEACE by seeing,enjoying,trying to change something from GOD something like me ME and lot of my Brothers and Sisters go through TORTURE.My biggest wish when i was a child was to be like my Heterosexual friend there was NO SUCCESS.I never ever would wish to Lose one of the most precious Human i had my MOM???
      But some people can CONTINUING by seeing dreams with OPEN EYES.
      Because people like me never going to give up until i feel my full freedom.
      I was Persecuted back home in Kosovo-former Yougoslavia 2 years ago.I lost so much in my life my family,my everything i had. Is been almost 7 years and i never heard a word from my family and i know how much it hurts and i don't want to see People going thorough the same thing and even worst for what GOD give it to me my Freedom my Life.
      Persecution is a very strong word, why someone such as me has to hope still for my freedom It's a much stronger word than 'discrimination.' It's when somebodies life or liberty is in great jeopardy by the government, or forces that the government can't or will not control, for a protected reason, like sexual orientation
      Report Abuse
    • Author by angels4light (December 15, 2009 10:27 am ET)
         
      If homosexuality was truly "unnatural", would it exist outside the human animal? Personally, not being homosexual, it would be unnatural for me to have sexual relations with someone of my gender. Likewise, however, for those who are homosexual, it is unnatural for them to have sexual relations with a person not of their gender. My wonderful wife was married before, her ex-husband was, it turned out, homosexual. The relationship was poisonous to her, because not matter how much she tried to be the perfect wife he was not, and could not, be satisfied - and it showed in how he treated her. Eventually, he could not maintain the deception and he left her, for a man - something she found out after the marriage ended. This is the first holiday season (beginning with Thanksgiving) that she has not been morose... Her first marriage ended in the 80s.
      Report Abuse
    • Author by wzwriter (December 16, 2009 1:03 pm ET)
         
      FRC's website states: "Family Research Council believes that homosexual conduct is harmful to the persons who engage in it and to society at large, and can never be affirmed. It is by definition unnatural, and as such is associated with negative physical and psychological health effects."


      Wzwriter believes that the Family Research Council is harmful to the persons who listen to it and to society at large, and can never be affirmed. It is by definition unnatural, and as such is associated with negative physical and psychological health effects.
      Report Abuse