About us Login Get email updates
County Fair
Print

Confirmed: Breitbart called Sherrod a racist without having the full tape

July 20, 2010 2:55 pm ET by Matt Gertz

This afternoon in a Hot Air blog post, Ed Morrissey wrote:

[Former USDA official Shirley] Sherrod and others can complain about Fox News and the editing of the tape, but two points should be remembered. First, Andrew Breitbart made it clear to me last night that this was the entirety of the speech he had in his possession. He also wants to find the whole speech and is trying to get it. 

Are you kidding me?

In his post yesterday -- headlined "Video Proof: The NAACP Awards Racism - 2010" -- Breitbart claimed to have "video evidence of racism" on Sherrod's part. He said it showed her describing "how she racially discriminates against a white farmer," and referred to it as her "racist tale." The piece was illustrated with a literal "race card."

According to Breitbart:

In the first video, Sherrod describes how she racially discriminates against a white farmer. She describes how she is torn over how much she will choose to help him. And, she admits that she doesn't do everything she can for him, because he is white. Eventually, her basic humanity informs that this white man is poor and needs help. But she decides that he should get help from "one of his own kind". She refers him to a white lawyer.

It soon became evident that there was something fishy about the heavily edited video - even conservative bloggers questioned its sudden ending and wondered what the full context might reveal, while nonetheless saying that they trusted Breitbart.

Throughout the day, the story has unraveled. In an interview with the Atlanta Journal-Constitution published this morning, Sherrod said that the clip had been ripped from context, leaving out "the breadth of the story about how she eventually worked with the man over a two-year period to help ward off foreclosure of his farm, and how she eventually became friends with him and his wife." Sherrod reiterated her statements on CNN's American Morning.

Later in the day, the farmer's wife called in to CNN, calling Sherrod a "friend" and praising her for having "helped us save our farm."

Meanwhile, we pointed out that Breitbart's suggestion that Sherrod was discussing actions that she recently took as an Obama administration official was flatly false.

All day, we've been asking when Breitbart was planning to release the full tapes. Now, it looks like he may never have had one. If what Morrissey says is true, Breitbart tried to destroy the life of a largely unknown Obama administration official and called her a racist, and he didn't have the full context to back it up. As Erick Erickson just tweeted, "I'm hoping there is more to the video of Shirley Sherrod, because otherwise it seems like the right just got the scalp of a penitent lady"

The sad kicker: The first sentence of Breitbart's smear of Sherrod was "Context is everything." But he never bothered to get context of Sherrod's comments. He simply didn't care. He wanted a scalp, got one, and took a curtain call.

It should go without saying, but if this is true, it really should end for all time the media's willingness to play along with Breitbart's fact-free witch-hunts.

UPDATE: In an interview with TPMmuckraker, Breitbart confirms that he doesn't have the full video:

"I don't have it," Breitbart told TPMmuckraker in an interview. Breitbart said his source sent him just the edited clips at first, but is in the process of sending the full video.

Breitbart said he'll post the full video, if he can get permission from the video production company who filmed it for a local NAACP chapter. He also maintained that he didn't edit the clip and that it was sent to him already edited.

Ok. So an anonymous source sent Breitbart these heavily edited clips, and without bothering to question whether those clips had been taken out of context, Breitbart posted them on his website and claimed that they proved that she was a racist. And now, after she has been smeared in public and forced to resign, he's looking for the full video.

But don't worry, according to Breitbart, the full video doesn't matter - it "speaks for itself," and her comments are "conveying a present tense racism in my opinion."

I repeat, the first sentence of Breitbart's first post was "Context is everything."

Behold conservative journalism.

Expand All Expand 1st Level Collapse All Add Comment
    • Author by progressivevoicedaily (July 20, 2010 2:59 pm ET)
      7 1
      Now if only the lame stream(Palin's right)media calls fox and brietfart and everyone else out for perpetuating this character assassination based crap it would be a better day in America.
      Report Abuse
      • Author by The Lonewacko Blog (July 20, 2010 6:27 pm ET)
          3
        I'm not expecting much from someone who writes like a deranged person, but "character assassination based crap" is what MMFA specializes in. Every day, a team of low-level interns comb hours and hours of audio and video looking for gaffes, macaca moments, and the like. Breitbart did exactly what MMFA does.

        That's not to excuse either one of them; I've tweeted several critical tweets to Breitbart and at the same time I have a category showing <a href="http://24ahead.com/s/media-matters-america">how Media Matters gets things wrong</a>.

        The solution isn't to play tit for tat or to excuse one side over the other. It's to suggest discussing actual policy instead of smearing. I've tried to get Breitbart and Boehlert to do that, now it's your turn to help.
        Report Abuse
        • Author by The Lonewacko Blog (July 20, 2010 6:28 pm ET)
            3
          Better link: how Media Matters gets things wrong.
          Report Abuse
        • Author by highlyunlikely (July 20, 2010 7:22 pm ET)
          2  
          hate to tell you but you're not 'lone. BC and 2-lies-in-1-name are a constant presence here as well.
          Report Abuse
        • Author by kidLightning (July 20, 2010 7:51 pm ET)
             
          "Their overall goal is to stifle debate through the usual "liberal" practice of calling people 'racist" and the like."
          Just by posting that you show your true cards.
          No, MMFA is not about stifling debate at all; quite the contrary, it is about holding those who frame the debate in the media responsible for what they say and do.
          And as anybody with an ounce of political awareness knows, the far-right have taken over the biggest, farthest reaching "news outlets",
          talk radio and Fox News not to mention the hundreds of Breitbart-esque blogs.
          What is your suggestion, that no one police the media for accuracy?
          Report Abuse
        • Author by mari2jj (July 20, 2010 11:37 pm ET)
          1  
          No, Breitbart is the one who lied. And, the solution is to just be aware that our fellow party member is the world's number one liar. He posts stuff whether he can verify if it as factual or not. Is anyone actually so stupid to think that some goof just innocently edited a video in such a way that it totally destroys the truth amd then sends it off to Breitbart and he was so stupid not to verify what was on the tape? Editing films to lie is obviously Breitbarts specialty and Republicans need to call him out on his lies. He ruins our party's credibility! Further, this is not Breitbatr's first foray into total distortions on film. He is just a first class liar and a huckster and if he has been caught in these sorts of messes, he simply can never again be trusted. He is a liar by default cutting out the facts on this tape, or he is wildly stupid to not check this out when it smells so fishy from the get-go!
          Report Abuse
      • Author by mari2jj (July 20, 2010 10:58 pm ET)
        1  
        Breitbart seems to hae NO moral rudder. This is the second tape he has doctored. He is never to be trusted again by any right wing whacko or they are totally culpable in his racist rhetoric. Fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice, Breitbart and you are a liar! and you cannot ever be trusted again. You have besmirched the Republican name and it will take years for our party to recover. You may fool yourself into believing that all is fair in anti-Democratic Party rhetoric. But you have made fools out of OReilley, Hannity, Beck, and on and on. You are a common liar and not fit to be believed ever again. You have lied far worse than any politician I have ever heard and your nanme shall henceforth be called Breitbart, the Liar!
        Report Abuse
    • Author by FGFM (July 20, 2010 3:07 pm ET)
      6  
      Funny how Breitbart once claimed that calling someone a racist was the worst thing one could do!
      Report Abuse
    • Author by NoSpinner (July 20, 2010 3:13 pm ET)
      6  
      First off, I don't believe Andrew Briebart's claim that that's all the video he's got. If he's been truly duped, he should expose his source.
      Secondly, TPM reports that there IS A FULL VERSION of the speech that should shortly become public. From TPM:

      The Douglas, Ga., company which filmed the banquet for the local NAACP has refused to release it to TPMmuckraker. The owner of the video company, Johnny Wilkerson, says he is sending the full video to the national NAACP, and hopes to post it in full once he gets permission.

      Wilkerson also told us that the full speech is exactly as Sherrod described, and that she goes on to explain learning the error of her initial impression and helping the farmer keep his farm.
      Report Abuse
    • Author by grrson (July 20, 2010 3:40 pm ET)
      2  
      You can't take a frothing right-wing operative like Breitbart seriously. All his video "scandals" fizzle out eventually despite his onslaught of reverse racism accusations.
      Report Abuse
      • Author by SharonC (July 20, 2010 3:48 pm ET)
        2  
        Quite frankly, the Administration's handling of this situation is troubling. Sherrod's point in publicizing her experience with the farmer is quite clear--even if one does not have the benefit of viewing the entire tape. An immediate apology to Sherrod and correction is in order. Again, I am both appalled and disappointed in both the news reporting and the Whitehouse's reaction to this event.
        Report Abuse
        • Author by bintx (July 20, 2010 4:48 pm ET)
          2  
          Sherrod claimed she got three phone calls from "the White House," but she got calls from Cheryl Cook's office, the Under Secretary for Rural Development. She said that Cook was the one who "forced" her to resign. According to reports, the USDA has strict "no tolerance" rules regarding racism. Apparently, just the fact that she publicly admitted to using racist guidelines in the past was enough for her to have been fired.

          I don't know. I think, though, with all of the other things going on in this country, this is the LAST thing that should be big news today.

          Unemployment benefits were extended today for 2.5 million people. That's what we should be talking about . . . the good things.
          Report Abuse
          • Author by LightningJoe (July 21, 2010 6:10 pm ET)
               
            bintx:

            THIS IS the issue today. We ignore race-baiting at our peril, and must respond when this sort of lie surfaces. If that detracts from the other issues, there is always tomorrow.
            Report Abuse
    • Author by MickD (July 20, 2010 4:02 pm ET)
      4 1
      The strategy for the Heritage Foundation types and their minions until midterms is to throw stupid, tabloid-ish news stories into the cycle, so everyone can ignore the real evil, Angle, Bachmann, etc., and they can spew without notice.
      Report Abuse
    • Author by refuse2lose (July 20, 2010 6:04 pm ET)
         
      Oh my gosh!!!! Liberals are upset that a black woman was called a racist without all the facts!!! Of course liberals NEVER do this,and they never turn their backs on black conservatives either.
      Report Abuse
    • Author by Ronaldrayguns (July 20, 2010 6:34 pm ET)
         
      File a lawsuit................A person who just got out of Law School could file a libel and slander case against Fox news and win...........This is so cut and dried it's ridculous....She will make millions........File a law suit today............
      Report Abuse
    • Author by Janniel (July 21, 2010 8:53 am ET)
         
      Media wants money. More controversy and sensational coverage = more attention = more money.
      Report Abuse

my.MediaMatters.org

Login  Sign Up

About the Blog

Feed Icon
  • County Fair is a media blog featuring links to progressive media criticism from around the Web as well as original commentary, breaking news and rapid response updates to major media events from Media Matters senior fellows and other staff.