About us Login Get email updates
Eric Hananoki
Print

Media Matters: Fox Business: Low on ratings, high on Fox-patented GOP boosterism and falsehoods

June 11, 2010 9:31 pm ET

When News Corp. Chairman Rupert Murdoch introduced the Fox Business Network in 2007, he made no attempt to hide the fact that the financial channel would reflect his own conservative philosophy. The financial media, in his view, should be in the business of "celebrat[ing]" free-market capitalism.

As Murdoch saw it, the existing media were too quick to ''leap on every scandal" and "are not as friendly to corporations and profits as they should be." In contrast to purportedly anti-business CNBC, Fox Business would be ''more business friendly" and "celebrate the freedom and sense of optimism that free markets have given Americans." America, according to Australian-born Murdoch, has the best "corruption-free companies in the world. Our companies are beacons of success that the rest of the world looks to, not that you'd know that through much of the business coverage we see every day."

As he did with Fox News, executive Roger Ailes has imported Murdoch's conservative philosophy to FBN, where the network's coverage and most visible personalities are unabashedly conservative and dismissive of progressives. The head of FBN's news division is senior vice president, host, and tea-party booster Neil Cavuto, who donated to President Bush, bashed the "awful" Democratic health care bill, and sports a record of misinforming viewers about economic issues.

Morning anchor Stuart Varney is a British expat whose shtick involves complaining that "socialist" Democrats are pushing America in the direction of his former country. Varney is described by Fox Business as a "business journalist" and news "anchor." Yet he admits that he's "very partisan," "very clearly partisan" and can't resist bashing Democrats while propping up Republicans. Varney also -- stop the presses -- misinforms viewers about economic issues,

David Asman, another "journalist," hosts the prime-time show America's Nightly Scoreboard. Asman, lover of Milton Friedman, makes it a habit to assail Social Security, Democrats, and "hypocrite" environmentalists who dare get in the way of activities like more oil drilling. Asman is one of the channel's biggest proponents of the tea parties, once telling viewers they "need to go" to a tea party merchandise site. Asman also -- hold the phone -- misinforms viewers about economic issues.

John Stossel, host of his own weekly "libertarian" show, has argued that the public accommodations section of the Civil Rights Act should be repealed to restore the right to discriminate and that the "free market" would have likely resolved the issue of racial discrimination by businesses -- a claim that civil rights expert Andrew Grant-Thomas called "ahistorical" and "unempirical." Stossel recently keynoted a fundraising luncheon for a "research" organization with heavy ties to the energy industry. When Stossel joined Fox, Fox News Sunday host Chris Wallace said he'd be "very natural fit" because "he's conservative." Stossel also has a history of -- call grandma -- misinforming viewers.

Fox, which defends itself by claiming that its "fair and balanced" reporters just report the news, employs FBN "reporter" Tracy Byrnes, who said Democrats voting yes on health care "make me sick," and "senior correspondent" Charles Gasparino, who said he wouldn't vote for the Democrats' health care bill ("Who would?").

FBN also recently announced promotions for Eric Bolling and Andrew Napolitano. Bolling, previously of the canceled afternoon show Happy Hour, will get a weekday prime-time show, his apparent reward for shilling for Republican candidates, and -- start the Drudge siren -- misinforming viewers about economic issues.

Napolitano, meanwhile, will bring his previously online-only show Freedom Watch to FBN on a weekly basis. Napolitano is an unabashed libertarian, meaning that while he disagrees with some of his Fox colleagues on certain social and national security issues, he'll fit right in on economic matters. In its online iterations, Freedom Watch frequently gave a platform to fringe guests like 9-11 conspiracy leaders Alex Jones and Jesse Ventura; Thomas E. Woods Jr., who has been a member of the League of the South, which the Southern Poverty Law Center has called a "racist" hate group; and "libertarian anarchist" Lew Rockwell, who excoriates Abraham Lincoln and openly pushes for secession. Napolitano has used his Fox perch to push inane conspiracy theories and -- insert any remaining idiom here -- misinform viewers.

How many people not getting paychecks from Media Matters will actually watch those shows, though, remains a question. While Fox News has undoubtedly achieved ratings success, Fox Business, in its third year, continues to post "feeble" ratings. While CNBC is available in more than 90 million households, FBN is available in just 50 million. Vanity Fair's Matt Pressman wrote last November that "it's fairly safe to assume" that "most of its shows fall short of attracting 35,000 viewers," or roughly one-tenth of CNBC's audience and a hundredth of SpongeBob SquarePants'.

The most high-profile show on FBN -- a dubious honor -- isn't even a business-oriented show. Last October, FBN began simulcasting Don Imus, best known for helping pioneer shock jock radio decades ago and smearing female basketball players. Imus, as he has self-deprecatingly acknowledged, has no expertise in business news, which is why FBN incorporates several business updates on his show.

Fox hopes to grow its fledgling business channel by cross-promoting it on Fox News, which also struggled with early ratings. Fox News has begun using hosts like apparent financial wizards Bill O'Reilly and Glenn Beck to tout FBN as "no-spin talk you can trust" and the network that "wants you to succeed." Varney, Bolling, Byrnes, and others regularly appear on FNC, where they're touted as financial experts -- facts to the contrary -- while Cavuto incessantly uses his afternoon FNC show to implore viewers to "demand" FBN from their cable providers.

In a new ad for the network, Fox states that Fox Business and Fox News offer "two networks, twice the power." Indeed, from its inception to its recent hiring decisions, Fox Business has made it clear that like its sister channel, "fair and balanced" is merely a wink and a nod to viewers looking for a reaffirmation of conservative myths and blatant GOP boosterism.

"Don't tease the panther": Glenn Beck continues his public embarrassment tour

If a week goes by without Media Matters documenting something embarrassing or pathetic from Glenn Beck, it's probably because he's on vacation.

Case in point, the self-described "rodeo clown," last seen making fun of an 11-year-old girl, refused to apologize for promoting the work of pro-Nazi, anti-Semitic, racist Elizabeth Dilling. As Beck tells it, he sat down with the book The Red Network one night and found it so inspiring that he had to share it the very next day. Yet The Red Network contains passages rife with racism ("colored men" are dancing with white women!), anti-Semitism (let's be fair to Nazi Germany's anti-Jewish activities), and religious bigotry (Hinduism and Islam are "debasing and degrading"; Judaism and Hinduism spread "propaganda").

On the topic of books, Beck will soon release his brand new "thriller" The Overton Window, which he promises will "drive the left insane." Beck's right: Media Matters obtained a copy of the book before its Tuesday release, and as Media Matters' Simon Maloy and Ben Dimiero note, the "awful" novel contains "plot holes, ridiculous narrative devices, and long-winded limited-government sermonizing passed off as dialogue." Beck's Overton Window includes the phrase soon to engulf college campuses and future Gossip Girl episodes: "Don't tease the panther."

Beck also began touting his 8-28 rally -- the same day as Martin Luther King's 1963 March on Washington -- as one that will "reclaim the civil rights movement" and "be remembered as the moment America turned the corner." Beck, who informed readers may know is not a civil rights hero, has compared himself to civil rights heroes Martin Luther King Jr., Rosa Parks, Gandhi, and African-Americans who had "dogs and fire hoses" released on them. Beck's even gone so far as to claim that he's advancing "the plan that [God] would have me articulate, I think" against "darkness."

In an interview with The New York Times last year, multimillionaire rodeo clown Beck said that if people take what he says "as gospel, you're an idiot" -- food for thought for the Beck followers buying 8-28 rally plane tickets or Overton Window books.

Fox News hates Boxer, loves former colleague Fiorina

Fox doesn't like Sen. Barbara Boxer (D-CA).

According to those on the channel's payroll, Boxer is an embarrassing, condescending, big-spending, anti-military liberal "dope" who "stands for everything that is wrong with Washington."

While that hyperpartisan venting sounds like something from Fox News' "opinion" side, "reporter" William La Jeunesse has been one of Boxer's most frequent smearers. Not only did La Jeunesse state, in his own words, that Boxer "stands for everything that is wrong with Washington," he also forwarded the ridiculously false attack by opponent Carly Fiorina (R) that Boxer "is more interested in protecting climate change and the weather than actually the public."

Fiorina is a former member of the Fox News family, having been hired in October 2007 as a Fox Business Network contributor. Fiorina's financial disclosure statement states that she received nearly $58,000 for her employment with the "Fox Broadcasting Company."

Unsurprisingly, Fiorina has received glowing coverage and interviews on the network and netted endorsements from Fox Newsers Sarah Palin, Rick Santorum, and Dick Morris. But she stumbled this week when an open mic caught her appearing to disparage Fox News host Sean Hannity. Perhaps realizing Fox's role in the GOP apparatus, Fiorina directly apologized to Hannity.

In the midst of embarrassments like Glenn Beck, the Fox Business Network, and its Fiorina coverage, Fox News is pushing to get Helen Thomas' front-row seat in the White House briefing room. Media Matters' Jeremy Holden wrote that the White House Correspondents Association should resist any efforts to give Fox the seat, given its history. Appearing on Imus, Wallace said that Fox getting the seat would be "poetic justice" since Thomas is considered liberal. After prodding from Imus, Wallace quickly backtracked by claiming he meant Fox News is "fair and balanced," then added that maybe he should "stop digging."

This weekly wrap-up was compiled by Eric Hananoki, a research fellow at Media Matters for America.

Expand All Expand 1st Level Collapse All Add Comment
    • Author by robert234 (June 12, 2010 10:31 am ET)
      4 12
      Even though I concur with your column, it, like many other such rational writing, means virtually nothing. As long as ALL governments are allowed to kill innocent human beings, and then cover it up under Orwellian semanticide---Just War and collateral damage---it's the very genesis of EVIL. This evil includes, not only governments, but also most religions: Islam's killing of children and women, and the Pope's cover up of the Catholic Church's thousands of years of child rape and sexual assualt. Until ALL media devotes ALL its efforts to fighting such EVIL, it's words signify nothing!
      Report Abuse
      • Author by DellDolly (June 12, 2010 1:08 pm ET)
        9 5
        So, in addition to being totally off topic, you're saying that unless the media devotes 100% of their attention to the elimination of every problematic human behavior immediately and completely, then we should just curl up into a little ball and die? Really? REALLY?
        Report Abuse
        • Author by robert234 (June 12, 2010 1:24 pm ET)
          6 10
          It's quite clear that your brain is tightly curled, if not almost dead.
          Report Abuse
          • Author by usp (June 13, 2010 10:02 am ET)
              4
            hi robert- i read your original post- off topic but i think it's also nothing new- this has been happening since the dawn of time.
            Report Abuse
            • Author by robert234 (June 13, 2010 8:46 pm ET)
              2 9
              Sorry,but I can't for the life of me find anything more on-topic than life and death. As Socrates pointed out, "What do you mean by those abstract words with which you so easily settle the problems of life and death?" And it's precisely because it's been happening since the dawn of time, that it's always on-topic!
              It's very hard for me to fret about the noise emanating out of Congress or scribbling off media's pens when childrens screams are pouring from the suffering of U.S. drones run amok! As the words on the license plate cry out---"It shouldn't hurt to be a child."
              Report Abuse
              • Author by MiniTru (June 14, 2010 8:30 am ET)
                5 2
                Sorry,but I can't for the life of me find anything more on-topic than life and death.
                Even when the article you're responding to has nothing to do with the Catholic Church and the Pope?

                It isn't "always on topic." Only to a zealot, or a troll.
                Report Abuse
                • Author by robert234 (June 14, 2010 10:03 am ET)
                  1 7
                  You make a great defense for infanticide and pedophilia.
                  Report Abuse
                  • Author by CoolSlaw (June 14, 2010 12:42 pm ET)
                    6 2
                    Whoa....put down the bong robert234.

                    Ok, we understand that war is hell, and that churches often act in their own self interest and to the detriment of their followers and society. Cancer and AIDS suck bigtime, poverty never seems to go away for millions of human beings, and natural disasters kill and displace many people every year.

                    Now take a deeeeep breath, and let's discuss a thoughtful article about the Fox news ultra right wing philosophy seems to be working well on cable news, and failing on a financial network.

                    I think it's pretty clear why the ratings are so low. Most of the regular Fox news viewers are the key demographic Murdoch loves to appeal to: angry, white low to middle income bracket folks who hate change.

                    The business channel will probably be left on in the offices and lobbies of the small true target audience, but most of those wealthy investment and executive class people get their information from actual experts or inside sources that average Americans don't have access to. These people most likely know that what the Fox brand reports may or may not have any relation to reality, but it creates an alternate world justification and cover for running the sort of financial shell games that rob taxpayers at first, and then rob us again when it's time to bail them out.
                    Report Abuse
                    • Author by robert234 (June 14, 2010 1:21 pm ET)
                      1 6
                      Mind confusion is yours not mine. TRY and remember this: I fully agree with virtually ALL of the criticism about FOX and its lame brain commentators. HOWEVER, it pales in importance and attention given when compared to war, pedophilia, infanticide, genocide, aids, poverty,drug war et al. SO! I still say the MEDIA has an attention deficit disorder when it disseminates its coverage---Still have to say it, "When covering matters of LIFE and DEATH!
                      Report Abuse
                      • Author by Handsome Pete (June 14, 2010 2:33 pm ET)
                        4 1
                        I'm just going to crib from your first post, and tell you your writings mean virtually nothing. Nobody is going to pay your writings here any heed, because you are are being a self-righteous sanctimonious prick, and keep derailing the topic. Quit wasting your time and our time, if you can't discuss anything else, and go somewhere else where yours is the primary or at least mildly related subject of discussion.
                        Report Abuse
                        • Author by robert234 (June 14, 2010 3:00 pm ET)
                          2 5
                          You make a great case in defense of CENSORSHIP, and fear of Free Speech. How about discussing the CONSTITUTIONAL right to speak and write to whom I please, and then THEY(not you) can decide what to heed, what the topic shall be, and whose time is being wasted.
                          Report Abuse
              • Author by txthinker (June 14, 2010 10:59 am ET)
                2 1
                Sorry,but I can't for the life of me find anything more on-topic than life and death.
                Maybe you should be posting on www.lifeanddeath.com ......
                Report Abuse
                • Author by robert234 (June 14, 2010 12:55 pm ET)
                    6
                  Wow! Do you need remedial help----There's virtually nothing more about death and life than INFANTICIDE. And since the Native American Indians, enslaved African Blacks, Vietnamese and Cambodian Children, and now Iraqi and Aphgan Children, there is no one better than the U.S. Government at it.
                  Report Abuse
          • Author by DellDolly (June 13, 2010 3:06 pm ET)
            6 2
            It's quite clear that when the flaws in your post are pointed out, and you can't refute them, you'll make a baseless personal attack! That's what's quite clear here.
            Report Abuse
      • Author by union (June 12, 2010 10:03 pm ET)
        6 1
        Wheee! Non sequitur alert! :)
        Report Abuse
    • Author by razorsharpwit9925 (June 12, 2010 2:13 pm ET)
      5 2
      'the "awful" novel contains "plot holes, ridiculous narrative devices, and long-winded limited-government sermonizing passed off as dialogue."'

      Sound like it's targeted to appeal to fans of Ayn Rand's writing...
      Report Abuse
      • Author by Invent a Scandal (June 12, 2010 9:32 pm ET)
        3 1
        The Rodeo Clown turns to writing?

        Okay.

        Maybe next he can get a tryout with a professional baseball team, or be a "celebrity guest" on a WWF card.
        Report Abuse
    • Author by FGFM (June 13, 2010 9:51 am ET)
      4 3
      Hardly anyone in the business watches FBN, it's a total joke. Stuart Varney, in particular, is a complete moron. You really need to watch CNBC, in spite of garbage like Cramer, since they tend to break the news and have real players on there, unlike Fox with Tila Tequila and the like.
      Report Abuse
      • Author by latichever (June 13, 2010 12:55 pm ET)
        2 2
        Yes, CNBC is a hotbed of Marxist-Leninism-Maoist economics. How else are to we explain that its analyst, Rick Santinelli, gave rise to the Tea Parties?
        Report Abuse
      • Author by CoolSlaw (June 14, 2010 12:48 pm ET)
        5 2
        I agree. I think Murdoch doesn't care if his financial channel does well or not, so long as he can have a network of paid propagandists to justify the motives and actions of the investment class, provide cover for the scams, and create an even more far-right skewed field of debate.
        Report Abuse