At the time of President Bill Clinton's November 2000
visit to Vietnam -- the
first by a U.S. president
since the end of the Vietnam War -- numerous media reports noted Clinton's lack of service during the conflict, in
many cases specifically referring to his having "avoided service"
and noting that it was Clinton's
first visit to the country. In contrast, network and cable news coverage of
President Bush's recent visit to Vietnam as part of his trip to Southeast
Asia has largely failed
to note that Bush had never been to Vietnam, and no reports have thus far
mentioned that during the Vietnam War, Bush was instead in the Texas division of the Air
National Guard and requested transfer to Alabama so he could work on a Senate
campaign. Both Clinton's and Bush's trips occurred late in their
presidencies, and the merits of their military service were issues in the 1992
and 2004 presidential campaigns, respectively.
A few media outlets have juxtaposed Bush's current trip
to Vietnam
with his choice to serve in the National Guard during the Vietnam War. For example:
- On the November 17 edition of
NPR's Morning Edition, NPR
White House correspondent Don
Gonyea reported: "This is President Bush's first ever trip to Vietnam.
As a young man, he secured a spot in the Texas Air National Guard, thus
avoiding service in the war in Southeast Asia.
Now he arrives here as president
of the United States
at a time of another unpopular war."
- A November 17 Los
Angeles Times article noted that
Bush's arrival in Vietnam
"was shadowed by an issue that was politically difficult for him when he
first ran for president, just as it was for Clinton: the question of military service
during the Vietnam War." The article added that "there was new
attention to an issue that is politically painful for him in 2006: whether the Iraq war is turning into a new generation's
equivalent of the torturous Vietnam
conflict."
- A November 17 Washington
Post article
noted that "as a young man," Bush "joined the Texas Air
National Guard rather than serve in Vietnam."
- Also on November 17, The New York Times noted: "There is little
question that by signing up to be a pilot in the Texas Air National Guard, the
risk was low that he [Bush] would end up in Vietnam as a 23-year-old."
As a July 28, 1999, Washington
Post article reported,
in May 1968, "at the height of the Vietnam War" and "12 days
away from losing his student deferment from the draft," "Bush
stepped into the offices of the Texas Air National Guard at Ellington Field
outside Houston and announced that he wanted to sign up for pilot
training." The Post article
also noted that the National Guard "was seen as an escape route from Vietnam
by many men his age." According to the Post,
the Guard "usually had a long waiting list" and Bush "scored
only 25 percent on a 'pilot aptitude' test, the lowest acceptable
grade" but, noting that "his father was then a congressman from Houston," the
article added that Bush "was sworn in as an airman the same day he
applied." Further,
Media Matters for America has noted that there is substantial and
uncontested evidence to suggest that Bush did not meet his Guard obligations.
By contrast with the
print media outlets and NPR, television outlets have ignored Bush's record during the Vietnam War. In their November 16
prime-time reporting on
Bush's Vietnam
visit, MSNBC and CNN ignored Bush's military service, while Fox News
presented no reports on Bush's trip. While ABC, NBC, and CBS did not report on Bush's trip
in their November 16 evening news broadcasts, their respective morning news shows
did, but those also failed to mention the controversies surrounding Bush's
military service. In addition, a Media
Matters review of all three cable networks' coverage on November 17 up to 2 p.m.
ET found no mention of Bush's past military service in
their reporting on Bush's trip
to Southeast Asia.
In contrast, numerous reports on President Bill
Clinton's November 2000 visit to Vietnam pointed out that he had
"avoided service" during the conflict:
- A November 15, 2000, AP
report by Walter Mears noted, "Clinton's exercise of [American economic and military] power, while having avoided military service in Vietnam, prompts some veterans to look
askance at his visit. [Former Army infantryman Tom] Corey, vice president of
the 50,000-member Vietnam Veterans of America, says he has exchanged letters with Clinton. His feeling from the exchange,
Corey said, is that 'he probably feels the guilt and pain of not doing
that, not serving.' "
- On the November 16, 2000, broadcast of ABC's World News Tonight, anchor Peter Jennings
noted, "The president has just arrived [in Vietnam] and he'll have a full day
of activities tomorrow." He added, "Bill Clinton opposed the war on principle and avoided service for himself."
- In a November 17, 2000, USA Today article, State Department
reporter Bill Nichols wrote, "President Clinton began his historic visit to Vietnam
on Thursday with a quiet arrival ceremony and a motorcade into town that was greeted by tens of thousands of Vietnamese. Clinton is the first U.S.
president to visit Vietnam
since Richard Nixon in 1969 and the first to visit a
unified Vietnam. As a young man, Clinton protested against the war in Vietnam and avoided being drafted for service."
- In a November 17, 2000, Chicago Tribune article, foreign
correspondent Michael Lev wrote, "The painful
legacy of the war for America has meant a slow healing process that only now
has created the opportunity for a U.S. president to talk about the war while in
Vietnam. The fact that Clinton opposed the war and avoided military service makes it much more
sensitive."
- On the November 20, 2000, edition of CNN Sunday Morning, during a report by senior
White House correspondent John King about
the end of Clinton's visit that included an interview with the president,
anchor Miles O'Brien asked King, "John, in the
course of that interview, did the president
share with you any of his personal thoughts? This had to be an interesting
pilgrimage for him given the fact that he avoided service in
the military during the Vietnam era and yet here he is, the first president to visit post-war."
&mdash B.A. & R.M.
Copyright © 2009 Media Matters for America. All rights reserved.