November 30, 2007 9:39 pm ET
Media Matters for America has previously documented several media figures who have highlighted controversial comments on progressive websites. Media Matters asks: Will the media report that while discussing breaking news of hostages being taken at Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton's (D-NY) presidential campaign office in Rochester, New Hampshire, numerous commenters on the right-wing website Free Republic posted hateful comments about the situation?
Examples of Free Republic comments on the situation include:
















Poster "Beatthedrum" wrote: "You can
bet your bottom dollar the MSM wants this guy to blow his brains out, as long as
he doesn't hurt anyone else. Great dramatic ending, that would give the story
more legs.. Also if there's anyway this guy can be tied to a Clinton campaign worker
(maybe urging him on for the publicity), it will shut him up if he's dead.
Probably when the dust settles, dead or alive, this will be some nutcase who saw
this as his chance at fame."
Poster "sulu" replied to a comment
he quoted as "I wouldn't be surprised if some rabid Clinton supporter pushed
some whack job to do this" by writing: "I think you're right. My friends and are
at work are saying that if it's a plant, they most likely threatened him to
release photos or some such, and promised him he'd be okay. In real life, I
think this guy will have to end up having his brains blown out. You watch. He
won't be allowed to live. Mark my words. They couldn't leave him alive to talk.
He will be dead soon."
Poster "chemicalman" wrote: "I may
be a little late at saying this, but don't want to look through 1500 posts to
see if it's there. First the Hillary campaign plants questions...now they're
planting bombs."
Media Matters has previously documented media figures highlighting controversial comments on progressive blogs. For instance:
Washington Post media critic Howard Kurtz's March 1 column highlighted offensive comments posted on the Huffington Post blog "after a suicide bomber blew himself up at Afghanistan's Bagram Air Force Base, while [Vice President Dick] Cheney was there." Right-wing pundit Michelle Malkin had posted the comments on her website, and Kurtz reprinted a sample of the remarks in his column. Kurtz wrote: "I would agree that it's absurd to view these assassination fantasies as anything other than the rantings of the fringe, and that they shouldn't be used to tar an entire ideology. All I'm saying is that it's really sad that some loons feel this way, and that the Internet culture, however briefly, gives them a megaphone."
On the June 29, 2006, edition of Fox News' Big Story, host John Gibson discussed a Supreme Court decision issued that morning that prohibited the use of military commissions for the trial of detainees at Guantánamo Bay, and cited reader comments posted to the Daily Kos blog which discussed the decision. Gibson stated: "One of the comments on the far-left Daily Kos, which is a blog, in which writers purported to analyze the Supreme Court decision -- fair and balanced, of course -- one writer actually said, per today's decision, the administration appears to have been engaged in war crimes which are subject to the death penalty. Wow! They're excited over there on the far left."
In an August 21 column, Washington Times columnist Nat Hentoff cited an August 8 Wall Street Journal op-ed by Lanny J. Davis, former special counsel to President Clinton, that quoted from comments by blog readers that Davis characterized as "extremis[t], bigot[ed] and intoleran[t]." Hentoff wrote: "Connecticut Sen. Joe Lieberman -- now an insistently independent Democrat -- was pilloried during his losing primary contest with Ned Lamont, not only for his stand on the Iraq war but also because he is a Jew. Being one myself for many years, I was not surprised by the centuries-old persistence of this hatred among several of the fiercely anti-Bush bloggers during the campaign."
&mdash J.M.
Copyright © 2009 Media Matters for America. All rights reserved.