Garrett echoed Republican claim that Judge Owen is first top-rated judge to be blocked; she's not

››› ››› NICOLE CASTA

Fox News general assignment correspondent Major Garrett quoted Republicans who asserted that Texas Supreme Court justice Priscilla Owen, nominated by President Bush to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit, is the first judicial nominee to be filibustered who received a unanimous well-qualifiedPDF file ("WQ") rating from the American Bar Association (ABA). But Garrett failed to note that blocking WQ-rated judicial nominees is hardly new. Republicans blocked 10 of President Clinton's appeals court nominees who received unanimous WQs. Denied even hearings before the Senate Judiciary Committee, these nominations* never left the committee for full Senate consideration.

Clinton nominees with highest ABA ratings denied Senate Judiciary Committee hearings

106th Congress

H. Alston JohnsonPDF file (5th Circuit)

James DuffyPDF file (9th Circuit)

Kathleen McCree-LewisPDF file (6th Circuit)

Enrique MorenoPDF file (5th Circuit)

James LyonsPDF file (10th Circuit)

Robert CindrichPDF file (3rd Circuit)

Stephen OrlofskyPDF file (3rd Circuit)

Andre DavisPDF file (4th Circuit)

J. Rich LeonardPDF file (4th Circuit)

105th Congress

James BeatyPDF file (4th Circuit)

In addition, Allen Snyder (District of Columbia Circuit), another Clinton nominee who receivedPDF file a unanimous "well-qualified" by the ABA, received a committee hearing but was granted neither a committee vote nor full Senate consideration.

Garrett stated on the May 6 edition of Fox News' Special Report with Brit Hume:

[T]he American Bar Association voted unanimously to give Owen its highest rating, "well-qualified." Republicans say she is the first nominee so rated ever blocked by a judicial filibuster.

*To view the status of these nominees on the Library of Congress' Thomas website, check the civilian box, select 105 or 106 Congress and enter the name in the box under "Word/Phrase/Name," and then click the "search" button to the right.

Posted In
Government, Nominations & Appointments, The Judiciary
We've changed our commenting system to Disqus.
Instructions for signing up and claiming your comment history are located here.
Updated rules for commenting are here.