About us Login Get email updates
Research
Print

Wash. Times advanced false suggestion that Pelosi got "campaign cash" from Del Monte

January 18, 2007 12:11 pm ET

Trouble viewing clip? Download: QT | WMV

9 Comments

In his January 17 "Inside Politics" column for The Washington Times, Greg Pierce quoted a posting on the website of nationally syndicated radio host Neal Boortz that falsely suggested Del Monte Foods was "loading" House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) "with campaign cash." The posting asserted that this was a factor in the Democrats' exemption of American Samoa from the recent House proposal to increase the minimum wage. In fact, as reported by CNN and noted by Washington Post congressional reporter Jonathan Weisman, Pelosi did not receive any donations from the company:

  • On the January 12 edition of CNN's Lou Dobbs Tonight, CNN correspondent Lisa Sylvester reported that "Del Monte has not contributed to Pelosi's campaign and, in fact, has given more to Republicans."
  • On the January 12 edition of CNN's The Situation Room, CNN correspondent Brian Todd reported: "A Pelosi aide denies she's been lobbied by Del Monte. Company officials say the same. Records show Del Monte's employees contributed very little to Democrats over the past two years. A Pelosi aide even says she had nothing to do with this part of the legislation."
  • In the January 12 edition of washingtonpost.com's Post Politics Hour online discussion, Weisman noted that "Del Monte executives have given to Republicans almost exclusively and have given nothing to Pelosi or the major Democratic committees."

The posting on Boortz's website followed accusations by Republicans that American Samoa was left off the recent bill increasing the minimum wage because a Del Monte subsidiary, StarKist, is one of the territory's largest employers, and Del Monte is headquartered in Pelosi's San Francisco district. Although the Republican allegations were covered by CNN and the Associated Press, The Washington Times claimed that the story was the subject of a "[m]edia blackout."

From The Washington Times' January 17 "Inside Politics" column:

Media blackout

"So what happened to the story about Nancy Pelosi exempting American Samoa from the minimum wage because it benefits companies in her district?" radio talk-show host Neal Boortz asks at his blog site, boortz.com/nuze.

"Here we have a juicy little story affecting the Speaker of the House, and the media has chosen to look the other way. Imagine if this had been Newt Gingrich or Dennis Hastert. Would the press be so kind? Nope ... but hey, this is a Democrat ... the big cheese, the head honcho. She gets a pass. Maybe it's because Dems plan to revise the bill to include American Samoa and cover the speaker's behind," Mr. Boortz said.

"Never mind the hypocrisy of it all. Democrats stand up there and tell us that you can't raise a family on $5.15 an hour, that it needs to be raised to $7.25. Evidently you can raise a family on $7.25 an hour, even if it is phased in over two years. But when it comes to American Samoa, that's different. And as long as the Del Monte Corporation, through its Star Kist subsidiary, is loading you up with campaign cash ... then well ... maybe you can raise a family on $5.15 an hour. At least if you live in American Samoa.

"So the story will wither on the vine, thanks to media bias. Can you imagine if Tom DeLay were doing this? It would still be front-page news. But Nancy Pelosi is a Democrat, and Democrats are protected by the media. You should know that by now."

From the January 12 edition of CNN's Lou Dobbs Tonight:

SYLVESTER: Now, the average wage in American Samoa is $3.50 an hour. The House Education and Labor Committee will review the wages being paid there and investigate why they have been historically lower than in other U.S. territories. By the way, Lou [Dobbs, host], Del Monte has not contributed to Pelosi's campaign and, in fact, has given more to Republicans -- Lou.

From the January 12 edition of CNN's The Situation Room at 4 p.m. ET:

TODD: Hold the hypocrisy talk, say top Democrats. Their aides tell CNN American Samoa's always been held to a different wage standard, including when Republicans were in power, because it's so difficult for the island's tuna canneries to compete with plants in Pacific Rim countries that pay their workers next to nothing.

A Pelosi aide denies she's been lobbied by Del Monte. Company officials say the same.

Records show Del Monte's employees contributed very little to Democrats over the past two years. A Pelosi aide even says she had nothing to do with this part of the legislation. But today, the political storm forced her to backtrack.

From the January 12 edition of washingtonpost.com's Post Politics Hour:

Jonathan Weisman: I looked at Del Monte, which is San Francisco-based, but Del Monte executives have given to Republicans almost exclusively and have given nothing to Pelosi or the major Democratic committees. If they had, we would have printed it, but our standards are a little higher than the guilt-by-association standards of our competitor.

Expand All Expand 1st Level Collapse All Add Comment
    • Author by tommy (January 18, 2007 12:23 pm ET)
         

      Now this is real meat and potatoes misinformation stuff put out there falsely, apparently, by Boortz and the Wash Times.

      Good for MMFA for posting this topic thread. And good for CNN and the Wash Post for correcting this error, and I assume they are accurate.

      Report Abuse
    • Author by nerzog (January 18, 2007 12:37 pm ET)
         

      I hope that the existence of MMFA will allow us to see the Right Wing Lie Machine in action as it manufactures its lies. They've basically been making up crap like this since the early 90s, but now the spotlight is on their slimey operation, thanks to the growth of the Liberal blogosphere. With any luck, they won't get away with it this time.

      Report Abuse
    • Author by buyavowel (January 18, 2007 12:47 pm ET)
         

      Allegedly guilty - allegedly not guilty - what's the difference? To Boortz, apparently nothing. At the bottom of his front page it says (quoting) "Don't believe anything you read on this page" (paraphrasing) without first doing your homework. Thanks for the advice, Neal, I'll take it.

      Report Abuse
    • Author by open_mind (January 18, 2007 12:51 pm ET)
         

      I read this on drudge the other day, so I expected it to make its way into the regular media pretty quickly.

      It was flimsy when I read it then. Nice to see how quickly the story is falling apart under its own inadequacies.

      Of course, to some conservatives, it will only reinforce their view that the "liberal media" aren't telling us what we should know.

      Right now, there is no story.

      Report Abuse
      • Author by LarryE (January 18, 2007 2:45 pm ET)
           

        Right now, there is no story.

        While the Del Monte connection may be no story, I do think there is a story here: Why was American Samoa exempted from the minimum wage bill?

        Perhaps there were good and sound reasons, but I have no idea what they were - and lacking that knowledge, it becomes too easy for people to smell "protecting your friends" in this. Just because an accusation is made against by a right winger doesn't guarantee there's nothing to it.

        So I really wish someone would/could explain the exemption.

        Report Abuse
        • Author by open_mind (January 18, 2007 3:36 pm ET)
             

          I should have mentioned it in my post. I would like to know why they were exempt.

          This is something that should be looked into to be sure.

          1. Has American Samoa been exempted before. If so. Why? 2. Is there a legitimate reason it is exempted now? 3.How many other territories were/are exempted before and after this bill? 4.which representatives are directly interested in this exemption?

          These are some legitimate questions that should definitely be answered rather than blindly smearing Pelosi on no real evidence at all.

          I doubt we will ever find out who exempted AS in the bill. The current system allows for way too much anonymity. The way bills are created and ammended needs some simple reform so that anyone who authors or ammends any part of a bill has their name associated with it for absolute transparency.

          It is a complete shame that this simple system has not been put in place already in order for transparency and accountability to be a bigger part of the legislative process.

          Report Abuse
    • Author by princeofwheels (January 18, 2007 1:36 pm ET)
         

      Remember how the HEINZ company donated to the Kerry campaign...never happened. It was a big story for Limbaugh but that same day, when talk of boycotts arose, the local media went to HEINZ to discover that no money was given to the campaign but 5,000 went to the Bush campaign. Jobs could have been affected by these outrights falsehoods (lies). The following day, not one peep from the often foolish right-wing Rove repeaters. Now it is Del Monte's turn which by the way purchased part of HEINZ and has a presence in SF and Pittsburgh. Could it be the same old trash coming out? When will the boycott cry emanate from these trash-talkers? How can these people be soooo stupid??? P.S. I believe that Del Monte may have purchased the Tuna business....

      Report Abuse
      • Author by conleytgwinn (January 18, 2007 2:59 pm ET)
           

        "how can these people be soooo stupid" (not an actual quote, but as close as I can remember . . .

        Report Abuse
    • Author by mercado (January 18, 2007 3:07 pm ET)
         

      Boortz is like a little puppy, always around, nipping at your heels! He's never had a original thought in his life,not even his Faux Fair Tax Scam is his idea! Say's he graduated from some college in Texas,but which one,anyone know? Said he was a attorney,what kind of law did he practice, and where he practice? What states is he licensed to practice in? I've tune into his me,me, gabfest daily, and roughly 45 minutes of a 60 minute hour is dedicated to himself,what he owns,his plane and of all things ,a Hot-Air Ballon,where he's been, and his G.D. book! I have two questions for Boortz ;Don't you ever get tired of patting yourself on the back? 2nd Do you get your info to talk about ,on-air(when not backslapping yourself) from the National Inquirer? Because all you do is repeat what someone else has already said,never bothering to check out whether or not, it's true or false! Do you know what a fact-checker is,Boortz? Maybe you uses Hannity's and Rush's',fact-checkers,Now that would be a oxymoron wouldn't it ,a "Boortz Factchecker"! Come on Boortz,quit hiding under your producer's desk and answer my questions!

      Report Abuse

my.MediaMatters.org

Login  Sign Up

Push Back

Phone calls, emails and letters from the public do make a difference. Remember that to be effective you must be polite, and professional. Express your specific concerns regarding that particular news report or commentary, and indicate what you would like the media outlet to do differently in the future.