About us Login Get email updates
Research
Print

ABC's Ross gave misleading account of Obama statements in order to assert inconsistency

January 11, 2008 9:45 pm ET
image

SUMMARY: On Good Morning America, ABC's Brian Ross gave a misleading account of Sen. Barack Obama's comments regarding a real estate transaction to assert that Obama has "given a series of various explanations about the deal."

9 Comments

In a January 10 report about a real estate transaction involving Sen. Barack Obama (D-IL) and Tony Rezko, ABC's Brian Ross gave a misleading account of Obama's comments about the transaction in order to portray Obama as having "given a series of various explanations about the deal."

Ross reported, "For his part, Obama has given a series of various explanations about the deal. First, he told the Chicago Tribune that he didn't recall what his conversations were with Rezko. Four days later, he told the Chicago Sun-Times that he did recall telling Rezko about the property."

In fact, the accounts in the Tribune and the Sun-Times are similar. And in both papers, he was quoted indicating that he did not clearly recall what happened.

The Tribune reported that "Obama raised the possibility that he was the first to bring the lot to Rezko's attention" and quoted Obama as saying, "I may have mentioned to him the name of [a developer and] he may at that point have contacted that person. I'm not clear about that."

The Sun-Times quoted Obama as saying, "To the best of my recollection, I told him about the property, and he developed an interest, knowing both the location and, as I recall, the developer who had previously purchased it."

From the January 10 edition of ABC's Good Morning America:

ROSS: For his part, Obama has given a series of various explanations about the deal. First, he told the Chicago Tribune that he didn't recall what his conversations were with Rezko. Four days later, he told the Chicago Sun-Times that he did recall telling Rezko about the property.

From the November 1, 2006, Chicago Tribune:

Obama said his family's real estate broker brought the house to his wife's attention. He said he discussed the house with Rezko but isn't sure how Rezko began pursuing the adjacent lot. But Obama raised the possibility that he was the first to bring the lot to Rezko's attention.

"I don't recall exactly what our conversations were or where I first learned, and I am not clear what the circumstances were where he made a decision that he was interested in the property," Obama said.

"I may have mentioned to him the name of [a developer and] he may at that point have contacted that person. I'm not clear about that," Obama said.

From the November 5, 2006, Chicago Sun-Times:

Q: Did you approach Rezko or his wife about the property, or did they approach you?

A: To the best of my recollection, I told him about the property, and he developed an interest, knowing both the location and, as I recall, the developer who had previously purchased it.

Expand All Expand 1st Level Collapse All Add Comment
    • Author by captfoster2 (January 11, 2008 10:54 pm ET)
         

      Great..... another right-wing created WhiteWater non-controversy.......

      The corporate run media is beyond deplorable and all these slimy 'media' figures will make mountains out of mole-hills to anyone that might threaten their 'profit' margins!

      I have said this before and now again: "The vast majority of the media have decided that their million dollar contracts are more important to keep than the truth is!"

      This is so beyond sad that it hurts just thinking about it!

      Report Abuse
      • Author by pete592 (January 12, 2008 6:02 am ET)
           
        Once profit enters the equation and corrupts something that is vital to the general welfare and our democracy itself, such as a fair and impartial press, you get the sloppy, one-sided, sensationalist garbage we're plagued with today.
        Report Abuse
    • Author by jim6132 (January 12, 2008 12:49 pm ET)
         
      It is our job as citizens of this great union to make ABC and any other media outlet know that we are tired of misleading segments. I hope that everyone reading this comment have written ABC to address these misleading statements by Mr. Ross.  You know I am a one of those types of individuals who sadly voted for Bush the last few terms because of my concern for national security. It was what I was hearing from my International friends about their disgust for America.  Now, my international friends are changing their perception about American after Obama won in Iowa and I made a daring decision to support him because I feel that this is the way to go for us at this time. What I know is that most want to attack us because of their hatred for our policies and arrogances from their perspective.  They see us as a people who want to just blow them up instead of working out differences.  We are breeding hatred at our current status quo and increasing enemies over the globe.  At this time in American, we need a healer!! It may sound unsophiscated but it’s the truth. We need someone who can bring together a powerful majority in this country to make necessary changes for our survival. As I see it, everyone will suffer if there is a divider in the Whitehouse at this time in our great country. Red States vs. Blue States should never exist in this democracy. This is the reason why other countries are fighting each other e.g. tribal difference (red, Blue) and if we breed this into our children, I am afraid of what could occur long-term. Do you think this great union is immune from civil unrest and possible internal wars? I am going to be very honest: Having a Black face in Whitehouse scares the heck out of us because of what many of us believe about most African Americans deep down and don’t judge me--most feel the same way and won’t be honest and this true as the nose on my face. Do you know what took the fear out of me about Obama, he was raised primarily by his mother and grandparents and they all were White.  He has all of the experiences of being Black and has both blood racing thru his vein. This makes him the perfect healer for America because he truly loves both side and it part of him even though his skin is dark. People never stop to think why so many working class White people vote Republican especially in the South. They think that the social programs are for African Americans and if they don’t keep voting republican they will take our jobs and drain us in taxes. This is truly the reason for the great divided in this country or at least why the powerful want many working class whites to believe. I know because my family still lives in the South and all they talk about Blacks this, Blacks that….Whew, it’s what they believe. I prayed about this very hard and was scare but God gave me peace in my mind and heart about Obama. I know that I am doing the right thing. My family is having a fit and deep down think that I am crazy. But here is the twist, they always tell their friends that I make great decisions and don’t look back. They are very perplexed now because they believe in me and I am supporting Obama. They have strong feelings against people who look just like him. I love them so much and ashamed to admit how they feel, but it is true. 

      I am not telling you who to vote for, but keep in mind that we need a healer.

      Report Abuse
    • Author by atheist (January 12, 2008 3:41 pm ET)
         

      Just so you all know some facts about this story:

       In June 2005, Obama and Rezko purchased adjoining parcels in Kenwood. The state's junior senator paid $1.65 million for a Georgian revival mansion, while Rezko paid $625,000 for the adjacent, undeveloped lot. Both closed on their properties on the same day.

      Last January [2005], aiming to increase the size of his sideyard, Obama paid Rezko $104,500 for a strip of his land.

      The transaction occurred at a time when it was widely known Tony Rezko was under investigation by U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald and as other Illinois politicians befriended by Rezko distanced themselves from him.

      In the Sun-Times interview, Obama acknowledged approaching Rezko about the two properties being up for sale and that Rezko developed an immediate interest. Obama did not explain why he reached out to Rezko given the developer's growing problems.

       

       

       

       

      Report Abuse
      • Author by atheist (January 12, 2008 3:55 pm ET)
           
        I cannot believe that someone as smart as Obama, who decided to take on another buyer as a partner and purchase $2.2 million worth of property, would not recall why he approached that particular person.

        I would like to add here that if Hillary Clinton had been involved in this same situation, she would have been *crucified*.
        Report Abuse
      • Author by Clevenative (January 12, 2008 4:43 pm ET)
           
        In the Sun-Times interview, Obama acknowledged approaching Rezko about the two properties being up for sale and that Rezko developed an immediate interest. Obama did not explain why he reached out to Rezko given the developer's growing problems.

        Uhmmm, maybe because he wanted to buy the adjoining property and Rezko was the guy who owned it?

        I know people like to make these "guilt by association" accusations - but you can't choose your neighbors.

        Somebody please explain to me what the "scandal" is here?
        Report Abuse
        • Author by atheist (January 12, 2008 5:40 pm ET)
             
          No, Tony Rezko was not the owner of the property.

          Rezko was however charged with fraud and will be on trial in federal court next month.

          How is he connected with Obama ?

          - Obama claims that Rezko and Rezko's business partner called him "out of the blue" to ask Obama if he wanted to participate in some real estate developing. Obama said he told them no. Obama's explanation is that he had just become the head of the Harvard Law Review, so he had become well-known.

          - Rezko and his friends have donated more than $100k to Obama's state senate campaign and US senate campaign. Rezko was one of his first donors. Rezko also hosted a fundraiser for Obama.

          - Obama wrote letters to Chicago and Illinois officials supporting Rezko's bid to get more than $1.4 of taxpayer money to develop apartments for the elderly. "The deal included $855,000 in development fees for Rezko and his partner, Allison S. Davis, Obama's former boss" Prior to this discovery by the media, Obama had claimed that he'd never done Rezko any favors.

          - Obama and Rezko purchased the side-by-side properties, closing on the same day. Obama hid his purchase behind a trust. Obama later purchased a slice of Rezko's property, but instead of paying the assessed fair value of $40k, he paid Rezko $100k.

          - The son of one of Rezko's business partners gained an internship with Obama upon Rezko's request. That business partner donated more then $10k to Obama's state senate campaign, and he is also accused of federal fraud though he has not been indicted himself, mentioned in other indictments.

          I am not saying that Obama is necessarily guilty of impropriety. But I don't think MMFA should just blow off this story as ridiculous MSM attacks. Expect to hear more about the story when Rezko goes to trial.

          Imagine how Hillary would be treated if she were in this situation.
          Report Abuse
    • Author by dide (January 14, 2008 3:41 am ET)
         
      All of this over a $104k land deal?
      Report Abuse