About us Login Get email updates
Research
Print

Ignoring his reversal, media mention McCain's immigration bill in context of his attempt to gain Hispanic support

May 27, 2008 4:52 pm ET

SUMMARY: In reporting on Sen. John McCain's efforts to woo Hispanic voters, the Los Angeles Times, The Washington Post, the Politico, and Reuters mentioned McCain's previous support for comprehensive immigration reform but did not note that he has since said he would no longer support a comprehensive reform measure he co-sponsored.

7 Comments

In reports on Sen. John McCain's recent campaign stop in New Mexico and his attempt to woo Hispanic voters, the Los Angeles Times, The Washington Post, the Politico, and Reuters mentioned McCain's previous support for comprehensive immigration reform without noting that McCain has since reversed himself on that issue. Indeed, at a January 30 Republican presidential debate, McCain said that he would no longer support the comprehensive reform bill he co-sponsored with Sen. Edward Kennedy (D-MA) if it came up for a vote in the Senate. McCain now says that "we've got to secure the borders first" -- a position at odds with his prior assertion that border security could not be disaggregated from other aspects of comprehensive immigration reform without being rendered ineffective.

Media Matters for America has previously documented other instances in which the Times, the Post, the Politico, and Reuters have each similarly ignored McCain's immigration reversal.

From a May 27 Los Angeles Times article:

Republicans nonetheless enter the battle for the West with distinct advantages.

As a native son and war hero who has a record of pushing immigration overhaul, McCain has an entree with Latino voters, who many strategists believe will be critical again this election.

On Monday, his campaign released a Web ad targeting Latino veterans. And McCain will continue to focus on those voters in the months ahead, his strategist Charles Black said.

Obama, in contrast, has struggled to win support among Latinos throughout the primary season.

Speaking to reporters Monday in Las Cruces, he acknowledged the challenge. "We're going to have to work hard to get known by the voters in this region," he said. "But I think the message of changing Washington, delivering on universal healthcare, having an energy policy that is actually coherent, I think that is all critically important to the people here."

From a May 27 Washington Post article:

"These are going to be important battleground states," Obama said. "I think we can win in the West. I think that Governor Richardson has offered a model in New Mexico that is applicable in Nevada, is applicable to Colorado."

McCain's history of promoting immigration reform is expected to serve him well in states with significant Latino populations, though the Arizonan may suffer from the hard-line stand many in his party have taken toward illegal immigrants.

McCain released a Web ad aimed at Hispanic veterans on Monday in which the senator says that Latinos fought in Vietnam and are fighting in Iraq and Afghanistan, and that some "love this country so much that they're willing to risk their lives in its service in order to accelerate their path to citizenship."

From a May 26 Reuters blog post:

U.S. Hispanics support for the Republican Party, small but growing steadily over the past decade, has ebbed in the past year, following a bruising battle over illegal immigration.

Republican lawmakers last June sank a comprehensive immigration bill -- co-sponsored by McCain -- that would have created a path to citizenship for many of the 12 million mostly Hispanic undocumented immigrants in the United States.

A report by the Pew Hispanic Center in December, before McCain emerged as the Republican front-runner, found that just 23 percent of Hispanic registered voters called themselves Republicans -- 5 percentage points fewer than in 2006.

Both McCain and Democrat rival Senator Barack Obama made campaign stops on Monday in New Mexico, one of several swing states with significant Latino populations that may prove key in the November election.

From a May 27 Politico article, which reported that McCain "took a lead until last year on comprehensive immigration reform," but did not mention that beyond simply ceasing to "lead" on the issue, McCain has reversed himself on his own legislation:

Demographics, political trendlines and economic conditions help explain why Democratic strategists see the region as favorable terrain this year. After a vigorous attempt by Bush to appeal to Hispanics, who backed him with 40 percent of their vote in 2004, the anti-immigration bills pushed by Republican congressional leaders since then have alienated many in this voting bloc. Colorado has been trending Democratic, Nevada has been hit hard by the housing foreclosure crisis and New Mexico has swung between the parties in the last two presidential elections.

Obama will face a challenge from Sen. John McCain, who has represented Arizona for more than 20 years and took a lead until last year on comprehensive immigration reform, which won him a following among Hispanic voters.

Both candidates campaigned Monday in New Mexico, where both claimed strength in the region.

"I believe as a Western senator I understand the issues, the challenges of the future for these ... states, whether it be land, water, Native American issues, preservation, environmental issues," McCain said in an interview with The Associated Press.

He said his positions on a number of issues -- "pro-life, pro-military, pro-small business" and immigration -- "will allow me to receive the consideration of the Hispanic voter."

Expand All Expand 1st Level Collapse All Add Comment
    • Author by DorisRussell (May 27, 2008 5:08 pm ET)
         
      McCain reminds me of the a slick insurance salesperson who is trying to put one over on everyone.  The media is still playing into this niceguy act, How nice will it be when he sends more American youth over to Iraq to die.
      Report Abuse
    • Author by wesley (May 28, 2008 8:27 am ET)
         

      Judging from the lack of responses to this thread...it appears that mmfa's clumsy and monotonous droning that McCain wouldn't support his own immigration bill if it came up again for a vote has run out of steam.

      Of course he denied that he wouldn't vote for it if it came up again...because it won't come up again....McCain knows that and so does mmfa.

      McCain supports amnesty and if he is elected president...with a democrat majority in congress...he will quickly cave and support amnesty legislation. 

      Report Abuse
      • Author by BottleBlonde (May 28, 2008 9:29 am ET)
           

        Do you really still not understand what Media Matters does? They cover instances of conservative misinformation in the media. They cover news stories and commentary that forwards the conservative agenda.

        The fact that not many people comment on any particular thread doesn't mean that Media Matters articles have been clumsy or droning. Do you really not understand that every time a media outlet talks about McCain's support for his immigration proposal without noting his pullback from that support, that missing info forwards the conservative agenda because it doesn't paint McCain to be the flip-flopper he is? Do you still not know that the frequency of articles here has little to do with how much Media Matters wants to push a story and much more to do with how many inaccurate media presentations have been made?

        Report Abuse
        • Author by wesley (May 28, 2008 12:36 pm ET)
             

          I understand fully the mission of mmfa...just as I understand fully their methods and agendas.

          mmfa has proved nothing...despite their repeated attempts...to disprove McCain's support of amnesty. McCain has cleverly hidden his support for amnesty by stating that he would not vote for his "own bill" if it came up again.

          It will not come up again...McCain and mmfa both know that to be a fact. Yet, they both play politics with the issue...a discredit to both.

          It was a dishonest effort by McCain...and a dishonest effort by mmfa...to paint this in any other way.   

          Report Abuse
          • Author by BottleBlonde (May 28, 2008 1:27 pm ET)
               

            There is no discredit due to Media Matters.

            There is discredit due to McCain and to the media that does not accurately portray his varying stances.

            I never said that McCain would not flip back - he's already flip-flopped on immigration.

            If you somehow think that him saying that he would not vote for his own bill is not a flip-flop, then there's no hope for you.

            Report Abuse
    • Author by foghornleghorn (May 28, 2008 9:19 am ET)
         

      has run out of steam...

      Not really - just shows that the Republicans on this site have accepted his immigration flip-flop as a fact

      Report Abuse
    • Author by foghornleghorn (May 28, 2008 9:19 am ET)
         

      has run out of steam...

      Not really - just shows that the Republicans on this site have accepted his immigration flip-flop as a fact

      and
      Report Abuse

my.MediaMatters.org

Login  Sign Up

Push Back

Phone calls, emails and letters from the public do make a difference. Remember that to be effective you must be polite, and professional. Express your specific concerns regarding that particular news report or commentary, and indicate what you would like the media outlet to do differently in the future.