About us Login Get email updates
Research
Print

Reporting on efforts to woo Clinton voters, LA Times, CNN quoted McCain flack praising Clinton -- but not his prior smears

June 11, 2008 8:08 pm ET

SUMMARY: Los Angeles Times blogger Andrew Malcolm and CNN.com's Rebecca Sinderbrand quoted statements in a blog post by McCain deputy communications director Michael Goldfarb, in which Goldfarb wrote that "there is a genuine affection for her here at McCain HQ" and that Clinton is an "impressive candidate" who "inspired a generation of women." But neither noted that before joining the McCain campaign, in his prior capacity as online editor of The Weekly Standard, Goldfarb regularly engaged in the kind of personal smears that McCain has denounced.

12 Comments

In recent Web posts, Los Angeles Times blogger Andrew Malcolm and CNN.com's Rebecca Sinderbrand reported that Sen. John McCain's campaign is reaching out to Sen. Hillary Clinton's supporters, quoting McCain deputy communications director Michael Goldfarb's statements in a blog post that "there is a genuine affection for her here at McCain HQ" and that Clinton is an "impressive candidate" who "inspired a generation of women." But neither writer noted that before joining the McCain campaign, Goldfarb regularly engaged in the kind of personal smears that McCain has denounced. In his prior capacity as online editor of The Weekly Standard, from which he is on leave, Goldfarb described Clinton as a "shameless panderer" who "lie[s]" "more than most" politicians, mustered "faux outrage" that came off as "pathetic whining" about her treatment from the media, and said of Clinton's "3 a.m." ad about the economy: "[D]oes anyone think Clinton wouldn't bite off the heads of at least three staffers if her much needed beauty sleep was disturbed by a middle of the night phone call about the economy?"

Nor did either outlet mention McCain's own history of distorting Clinton's record on issues such as health care, taxes, the environment, and housing, and of making personal attacks against Clinton and her family.

Before joining the McCain campaign:

  • Goldfarb wrote in an April 21 post that Pennsylvania Gov. Ed "Rendell has always been a shameless panderer, as is the candidate he has endorsed in the Democratic primary [Clinton]." He later added that Sen. Barack "Obama is to be held to a higher standard because unlike Hillary, Obama is not a shameless panderer."
  • Writing about Clinton's 3 a.m. ad on the economy on April 2, Goldfarb asked: "[D]oes anyone think Clinton wouldn't bite off the heads of at least three staffers if her much needed beauty sleep was disturbed by a middle of the night phone call about the economy?"
  • Goldfarb responded on March 7 to former Obama adviser Samantha Power's statement that Clinton "is a monster" by asserting: "First off, tell us something we don't know."
  • In a February 27 post about the February 26 Democratic debate, Goldfarb wrote of Clinton's reference to a February 23 Saturday Night Live sketch: "The faux outrage she mustered over what she and [SNL host and former head writer] Tina Fey perceive as unfair treatment came off as pathetic whining."
  • On March 31, Goldfarb linked to a "must-read" column that day by Slate.com's Christopher Hitchens, which asserted that "[t]he punishment visited on Sen. Hillary Clinton for her flagrant, hysterical, repetitive, pathological lying about her visit to Bosnia should be much heavier than it has yet been and should be exacted for much more than just the lying itself. ... [S]he has rivaled, if not indeed surpassed, the disbarred and perjured hack who is her husband and tutor." Goldfarb wrote in response to Hitchens' "must-read" column: "Hitchens is outraged, and eloquently so as always -- it's definitely worth reading through. Still, I'm surprised that anyone can be surprised by the Clinton's lies anymore. Frankly, I find them rather comforting in comparison to Obama's new kind of politics, which best I can tell seems to be the same old politics in a new self-righteous package. All politicians lie, and the Clintons more than most. I can't imagine that voters haven't already internalized this reality -- which is why I tend to think the explanation for Hillary's plummeting poll numbers must lie elsewhere. [Weekly Standard contributor] Samantha [Sault] says it's the whining, which is as good an explanation as any."
  • In a March 29 post titled "On Hillary Clinton and Sandwiches," Goldfarb wrote that the "front page story on Hillary Clinton in today's [Wall Street] Journal includes this gem: 'Heather Arnet, a Clinton supporter who runs a Pittsburgh organization that lobbies for more women on public commissions and corporate boards, recently surveyed the Internet and found more than 50 anti-Hillary Clinton sites on Facebook. One of them, entitled 'Hillary Clinton Stop Running for President and Make Me a Sandwich,' had more than 38,000 members.' " Goldfarb wrote that "it looks to me (just clicking through a few pages) like 40 percent or more of the group is female -- it's certainly not all 'guys.' And most of the members [of the group], male and female, are probably Obama supporters. After all, Republicans want Hillary to keep running ... and make us a sandwich."

From Malcolm's June 11 Los Angeles Times post:

And then a week ago this morning it became clear the Democratic party was forcing Clinton to end her bid. Saturday Obama went golfing. Clinton and her family dressed as if for a funeral and went to thank their supporters with a grateful speech and on paper a hearty, full endorsement of Obama.

But something was missing. Not one word in the speech about the Republican nominee that Obama must now confront for the White House.

As she was speaking, the McCain campaign's new website blog, The McCain Report, posted a special tribute to the losing Democratic candidate, familiarly headlined "Hillary Out," something the Obama campaign didn't fully match for two days.

"Sen. Clinton has really grown on us," McCain blogger Michael Goldfarb wrote. "She ran an impressive campaign ... an impressive candidate ... inspired a generation of women ... Sen. Clinton also didn't mention John McCain once during her speech. This came as something of a surprise over here, and a pleasant one at that. But it's clear that John McCain and Hillary Clinton respect each other -- and there is a genuine affection for her here at McCain HQ."

The blog post included a photo of McCain and Clinton together on a ship in the Arctic during one of their several journeys as members of the Senate Armed Services Committee. These things do not happen on official campaign websites spontaneously or by accident. Nor does the enemy get accidentally omitted from a major speech.

So The Ticket called a bunch of people who know both McCain and Clinton. It's true, they confirmed, there is a special friendship between them. And it apparently started in January of 2001, when Clinton became the first former first lady elected to public office and walked into the U.S. Senate.

It has always been a gentlemen's club, if not always populated by gentlemen. And the warmth toward Clinton was missing. Until McCain walked up and heartily welcomed the newcomer and showed her around. "They really hit it off," said one friend.

From Sinderbrand's June 9 CNN.com story:

The numbers haven't gone unnoticed at McCain campaign headquarters in Arlington, Virginia. In the days since Obama effectively claimed the Democratic nomination, the senator from Arizona's campaign has aggressively reached out to Clinton supporters -- women and blue-collar voters who were the strongest supporters of her presidential bid.

A few hours after her speech -- which was free of attacks on Obama's fall opponent -- McCain aide Michael Goldfarb wrote on the campaign's official blog that "there is a genuine affection for her here at McCain HQ. During her speech there was no small amount of pleading with the TV: 'Don't do it, you can still win!' "

"Sen. Clinton has really grown on us over here in Crystal City over the past few months," wrote Goldfarb, calling her an "impressive candidate" who "inspired a generation of women" but "fell victim to a vast left-wing conspiracy that resented her generally centrist foreign policy views."

And one of the first posts on the newly launched blog was a video of Abba's "Take a Chance on Me" under the headline, "Take a Chance on McCain." Wrote Goldfarb: "Attention disaffected Hillary supporters, John McCain is a huge Abba fan. Seriously.''

McCain's maverick reputation has always translated into significant support from independent voters, but the diminished appeal of the GOP brand this year may translate into a weaker showing. Despite emotions still raw from the bruising Democratic primary, an appeal to Clinton voters could be a tough sell for the Republican.

But McCain and his campaign have made bold moves in recent weeks to distance the senator from President Bush and the Republican Party, and redirect the focus to his independent image -- essential in his effort to reach disaffected Clinton voters.

[...]

In his election night address, McCain had taken a swipe at the press -- directly echoing continuing complaints from some of Clinton's strongest supporters that she had received unfair treatment from the press during her White House run. "Sen. Clinton has earned great respect for her tenacity and courage," he said. "The media often overlooked how compassionately she spoke to the concerns and dreams of millions of Americans and she deserves a lot more appreciation than she sometimes receives."

Sen. Joe Lieberman of Connecticut -- who has taken on increasingly high profile campaign roles on McCain's behalf -- announced Thursday that he was heading a new grass-roots organization, Citizens for McCain, with a direct appeal to Clinton's disappointed supporters.

[...]

In 2004, despite similar anger from supporters of unsuccessful presidential candidate Howard Dean, 8 percent of Democrats supported Bush over Sen. John Kerry.

And on most major issues, McCain's positions are completely at odds with those of the Democratic working class and women voters he's hoping to reach: in favor of the Iraq war and Bush's tax cuts, against abortion rights and health care policies favored by many Democrats.

Obama advisers say they think the passion of the primary season will soon fade, and the party will unite around the senator from Illinois. But they've moved quickly to cement party unity: Last week, a thank you message -- and a plea for visitors to "show your support" for Clinton -- appeared on Obama's Web site.

Expand All Expand 1st Level Collapse All Add Comment
    • Author by pithaughn (June 11, 2008 8:58 pm ET)
         
      You don't suppose Hilary is hedging her bets a little? Just on the off chance old McGramps and his slime machine make off with the election? Ala Rove in 2000? Secretary of Health and Human Services maybe?
      Report Abuse
    • Author by Kyle_Broflovski (June 11, 2008 11:04 pm ET)
         

      Note to MMFA:  It's spelled F-L-A-K!

       

      Love,

      John Sidney McCain III

      Report Abuse
      • Author by wzwriter (June 12, 2008 8:32 am ET)
           
        Not if your first name is Roberta - then it's "F-L-A-C-K".  :-)
        Report Abuse
      • Author by nerzog (June 12, 2008 8:42 am ET)
           
        Actually, they are two different words. FLAK refers to anti-aircraft artillery, apparently an acronym for the German word "Flugabwehrkanone".

        FLACK is a political press agent or publicist.
        Report Abuse
        • Author by wzwriter (June 12, 2008 9:31 am ET)
             

          FLACK is a political press agent or publicist.

          Or the woman who sang "The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face".  :-)

          Report Abuse
    • Author by BottleBlonde (June 12, 2008 12:05 am ET)
         

      And again this is all about furthering the conservative agenda.

      Describing the McCain campaign, McCain himself, and this Goldfarb guy as respectful of Hillary Clinton makes them look better than they deserve to look. Failing to mention their smears of her makes them look better than they deserve to. That forwards the conservative agenda.

      Report Abuse
    • Author by IRONY 101 (June 12, 2008 7:52 am ET)
         
      TRANSLATION: Had Hillary Clinton been the Democratic Party nominee John McCain would be scaring the bejesus out of conservative voters by painting Hillary Clinton as a feminazi bitch, but now that he sees an opportunity to poach some of her supporters McCain expresses his deep affection for the pioneering female former candidate. Typical John McCain...
      Report Abuse
      • Author by nerzog (June 12, 2008 8:48 am ET)
           
        EXACTLY. If you want a glimpse of what the GOP campaign against Hillary would have looked like, just go back and read what Rush Limbaugh and the other Flying Monkey liars were saying about her in the 90s, and during her run for the Senate. All of that crap would have been regurgitated ad nauseum between now and November. Any Hillary supporter thinking about voting for Gramps needs to look at that stuff before making a horrible mistake.
        Report Abuse
      • Author by tommy (June 12, 2008 12:11 pm ET)
           

        And that is exactly why this is much ado about nothing, except standard fare politics. Anyone with half a brain would see this sudden affection for Hillary Clinton by McCain as nothing more than pandering to her voters, it's as obvious as it is expected.  The reason the media outlets don't include his earlier criticisms of her is because it's irrelevant.....it's hardly big news when a politician slaps an opponent one minute and then cozies up to them minutes later.

        Is it news that Obama criticized Clinton earlier and now treats her publicly with affection and deference?  No, it's what they do.  They all do it. 

        Report Abuse
    • Author by dbeden4153 (June 12, 2008 10:12 am ET)
         

      I know this is OT but this topic is pretty boring...

      I had a lapse of mental judgment last night when I turned on MSNBC and listened to Hardball while cleaning the kitchen.  Tucker "Bowtie" Carlson was on the panel and after having listened to him talk about this race, I think I lost several IQ points.  I know MMfA has no aversion to calling out the Tuckster, but they should really, really call him out for last night.  I don't remember the exact quotes, but I have never heard more useless drivel in my life.  As soon as the transcript comes out, I'll definitely post some of my favorite quotes.

      Report Abuse

my.MediaMatters.org

Login  Sign Up

Push Back

Phone calls, emails and letters from the public do make a difference. Remember that to be effective you must be polite, and professional. Express your specific concerns regarding that particular news report or commentary, and indicate what you would like the media outlet to do differently in the future.

  • CNN
    CNN
    One CNN Center, Box 105366, Atlanta, GA 30303-5366
    Phone: 404-827-1500
    Fax: 404-827-1906
  • Los Angeles Times
    Los Angeles Times

    Los Angeles Times
    202 W. 1st St.
    Los Angeles, CA 90012

    (213) 237-5000