About us Login Get email updates
Research
Print

Fox's Carlson aired heavily cropped version of Clinton's comments on Meet the Press, then claimed it "was a major diss against Barack Obama"

September 29, 2008 4:48 pm ET

Please upgrade your flash player. The video for this item requires a newer version of Flash Player. If you are unable to install flash you can download a QuickTime version of the video.

EMBED

SUMMARY: Fox & Friends aired a heavily cropped version of former President Bill Clinton's comments broadcast on the previous day's Meet the Press in which Clinton was asked if Sen. Barack Obama is a "great man." Co-host Gretchen Carlson asserted that the cropped comments were evidence of "a major diss against Barack Obama by Bill Clinton." But Carlson omitted Clinton's assertion in the same interview that he "certainly admire[s] him" and that Obama's "greatness will ... become apparent" when he is elected president.

17 Comments

On the September 29 edition of Fox News' Fox & Friends, co-host Gretchen Carlson aired a heavily cropped version of former President Bill Clinton's comments broadcast on the previous day's edition of NBC's Meet the Press in which Clinton was asked if Sen. Barack Obama is a "great man." Carlson asserted that the cropped comments were evidence of "a major diss against Barack Obama by Bill Clinton," and added: "I mean, he can't come out and just say he's a great man? He's trying to get him elected, ostensibly, but, not really." However, Carlson omitted Clinton's assertion that he "certainly admire[s] him" and that Obama's "greatness will ... become apparent" when he is elected president.

During the segment, Carlson stated of Clinton: "Asked again yesterday by Tom Brokaw on Meet the Press: 'You called John McCain a great man, what about Barack Obama?' He just couldn't get it out. He just couldn't do it." Carlson then aired a video clip of Clinton's comments during a recent CNBC interview with Maria Bartiromo -- comments that Brokaw read to Clinton during the Meet the Press interview -- in which Clinton said: "And as I said, I've never concealed my admiration and affection for Senator McCain. I think he's a great man." That video clip was immediately followed by video of the following exchange between Clinton and Brokaw on Meet the Press:

BROKAW: Would you use the same words for him that you have used for Senator McCain -- that you admire him, and that you think he's a --

CLINTON: I certainly --

BROKAW: -- and that he's a great man?

CLINTON: Well, I don't -- look, I had my first conversation with him in my entire life in Harlem.

Following the clip, co-host Steve Doocy stated, "OK, so that explains that," and Carlson added: "That's a no." Carlson went on to assert: "I think this is a major diss against Barack Obama by Bill Clinton. ... I mean, he can't come out and just say he's a great man? He's trying to get him elected, ostensibly, but, not really."

But in remarks that Carlson did not air in the segment, Clinton said, "I am developing a really good relationship with Senator Obama and I certainly admire him," and also stated: "When he becomes president, he'll be doing things for the American people and for the world and he is -- and the greatness will then become apparent because of the good he'll do. And I think that's what I very much believe is going to happen."

Carlson also omitted Clinton's response to Brokaw's first question on the subject, in which Brokaw stated: "[L]ast week you said, 'I have never concealed my admiration and affection for Senator McCain. I think he's a great man. But I think on the issues that matter to our future, the Obama- [Sen. Joe] Biden team is more right.' " Clinton responded:

I do believe that. And I think Senator Obama has shown a remarkable ability to learn and grow in this campaign. He always was highly intelligent and always a very good politician. He got the change -- the fundamental change in -- in the calendar of this Democratic primary process, of which we were engaged, his energy program kept getting better through the campaign, his health care program kept getting better. I think what you want in a president at a time like this is somebody with good instincts who generally starts in the right position and then just keeps getting better and that's what he's done.

From the September 28 edition of NBC's Meet the Press:

BROKAW: You know, we like to keep track of records here on Meet the Press, as you're well aware. We looked at this interview that Tim [Russert] did with you a year ago at the Clinton Initiative -- Global Initiative, and at that time, you predicted that John McCain would be the Republican nominee at a time when a lot of people thought he was --

CLINTON: He was dead.

BROKAW: -- toast, in political terms. But you said as well, at that time, "I've disagreed with him, but I have admired him." And then to Maria Bartiromo last week, you said, "I have never concealed my admiration and affection for Senator McCain. I think he's a great man. But I think on the issues that matter to our future, the Obama-Biden team is more right."

CLINTON: I do believe that. And I think Senator Obama has shown a remarkable ability to learn and grow in this campaign. He always was highly intelligent and always a very good politician. He got the change -- the fundamental change in -- in the calendar of this Democratic primary process, of which we were engaged, his energy program kept getting better through the campaign, his health care program kept getting better. I think what you want in a president at a time like this is somebody with good instincts who generally starts in the right position and then just keeps getting better and that's what he's done.

BROKAW: Would you use the same words for him that you have used for Senator McCain -- that you admire him, and that you think he's a --

CLINTON: I certainly --

BROKAW: -- and that he's a great man?

CLINTON: Well, I don't -- look, I had my first conversation with him in my entire life in Harlem.

BROKAW: You had never talked to him before that meeting.

CLINTON: Oh, I'd talked to him, but always in passing. I did a fundraiser for him when he ran for the Senate in 2004. I saw him briefly at Senator Kennedy's 75th birthday party. I had always, you know, I was -- Hillary's the one who told me to go help him. She said, "This guy's got real skills. He's got almost unlimited potential."

And I -- she -- so I did and I've always thought he was a really commanding presence. What I mean by saying that about McCain is, you know, most people would've been broken by what he went through. Oh, we would've been happy just to give him an attaboy and a medal and let him wander through life. I think his greatness is that he keeps trying to come back to service without ever asking people to cut him any slack or feel sorry for him or any of that stuff because he was a POW.

But I -- I genuinely, you know, I am developing a really good relationship with Senator Obama and I certainly admire him. And I know he saw and imagined the way this thing could develop, this political year and this economic situation in a way that is left him in a position of leadership he's in now.

And I think that the rest of us should admire that. That's a big part of leadership: being able to sense, as well as see, the future.

BROKAW: But I get the sense that you think that he has the potential for greatness, but he's not yet arrived at that station.

CLINTON: Well, he would probably agree with that. I mean, he was, you know, until -- he was in the state senate until 2005 and then he began a campaign for president, which is, in all probability, will be successful, and those are very great accomplishments. But they're the personal accomplishments.

When he becomes president, he'll be doing things for the American people and for the world and he is -- and the greatness will then become apparent because of the good he'll do. And I think that's what I very much believe is going to happen.

From the September 29 edition of Fox News' Fox & Friends:

CARLSON: We're going to talk about another guy whose name also starts with "B," just like Brian.

BRIAN KILMEADE [co-host]: Which is?

CARLSON: Bill. Bill Clinton. This is fascinating to me, because yesterday he was asked again -- he's called John McCain a "great man" in several different interviews --

KILMEADE: Good friend.

CARLSON: -- good friend, known him for a long time. Asked again yesterday by Tom Brokaw on Meet the Press: "You called John McCain a great man, what about Barack Obama?" He just couldn't get it out. He just couldn't do it.

[begin video clip]

CLINTON: And, as I said, I've never concealed my admiration and affection for Senator McCain. I think he's a great man.

BROKAW: Would you use the same words for him that you have used for Senator McCain, that you admire him, and that you think he's a --

CLINTON: I certainly --

BROKAW: -- and that he's a great man?

CLINTON: Well, I don't -- look, I had my first conversation with him in my entire life in Harlem.

[end video clip]

DOOCY: OK, so that explains that.

KILMEADE: I didn't know that.

CARLSON: That's a no.

DOOCY: Yeah.

KILMEADE: But I didn't know that. That's -- they only talked one time?

DOOCY: He took a pass.

CARLSON: No, no, no -- where they actually saw each other in person. Remember they went to lunch about a month ago? They had had phone conversations up until that point. But, come on, they've seen each other. I think this is a major diss against Barack Obama by Bill Clinton.

DOOCY: Absolutely.

CARLSON: I mean, he can't come out and just say he's a great man? He's trying to get him elected, ostensibly, but, not really.

DOOCY: PUMA. That's all I'm gonna say. You look it up. PUMA.

KILMEADE: He might be a member.

DOOCY: You know what that stands for.

KILMEADE: Guess who's coming up a little bit later?

CARLSON: Party Unity My --

DOOCY: I'm talking about the shoes.

CARLSON: Yeah.

Expand All Expand 1st Level Collapse All Add Comment
    • Author by mefirst (September 29, 2008 4:54 pm ET)
         

      sure, that's fair and balanced, take one line out of an entire interview. 

      Report Abuse
    • Author by peebs755 (September 29, 2008 5:13 pm ET)
         
      oh yah, sure! you betcha!
      Report Abuse
    • Author by jeter2 (September 29, 2008 5:15 pm ET)
         

      I'm not sure if this effort to make it appear that Bill Clinton is unenthused about Obama is going to work with any voters. This alleged "diss" is being presented, not just at FOX, but over at MSNBC as well. And probably by other news outlets I haven't seen.

      Report Abuse
      • Author by tommy (September 29, 2008 5:27 pm ET)
           

        J, I don't think the voters give a damn, actually. Whether or not Clinton campaigns for Obama, or even mentions him, is most likely irrelevant to most........it's just he is so self absorbed and egomaniacal that it's comical to watch him try and get some attention, and he loves this media obsession with him and his every word. 

        Report Abuse
        • Author by Appleboy (September 29, 2008 5:49 pm ET)
             

          Boy, if only we had more self-absorbed people like Bill Clinton around this world would be a much better place to live.

          Report Abuse
        • Author by mefirst (September 29, 2008 7:31 pm ET)
             

          the thing that matters is that there will be some voters who think clinton was dissing obama.  he wasn't.

          Report Abuse
        • Author by my4cents (September 29, 2008 8:49 pm ET)
             

          Though I am not J, I am tempted to ask, your personal feelings aside, is Bill Clinton trying to accomplish anything positive for America/world after his Presidency?

          Or, is everything he does is to get attention?

          Thanks.

          Report Abuse
      • Author by DorisRussell (September 29, 2008 10:16 pm ET)
           

        Jeter

        It most likely will not work, but it is also untrue. I do not know what else Clinton has to say, should he start traveling with him every day?  I am not suprised the media types at FOX and MSNBC and others will keep attempting to bring this non event into the news cycle. It is quite simple. President Clinton supports Obama and the media can not stand it so they invent things.

        Report Abuse
    • Author by congero6189599 (September 29, 2008 5:32 pm ET)
         

      Steeve DOOFY!! nuff said!!

      Report Abuse
      • Author by djasper2761 (September 29, 2008 6:32 pm ET)
           

        That is not a nice thing to say about someone still in the closet. I see him at times on the billybob o'really show and he just gushes when billybob scolds him. He is soooooooooooo flaming at times. One can find more truth in a 3 stooges show than on fake news.

        Report Abuse
    • Author by wesley (September 29, 2008 5:49 pm ET)
         

      This was a really tortured exercise by Brokaw in trying to drag out a ringing endorsement of Obama by Clinton...and it failed...as Clinton was barely able to utter the words great and Obama in the same sentence.

      But the really comical part is Brokaw trying to conjure up visions of greatness for a junior senator...a man who has accomplished very little in his life except getting elected to public office.

      What a joke.

      Greatness? Neither of these men have done anything to deserve the descriptive title of great...sweet fancy moses...what a crock.

      Report Abuse
      • Author by pete592 (September 29, 2008 6:14 pm ET)
           

        Please elaborate. 

        What is your definition of greatness?  And who do you believe personifies it?

        What is the standard by which you measure accomplishment?

        Report Abuse
        • Author by cArn (September 29, 2008 7:21 pm ET)
             

          I don't see how calling Obama or McCain "great men" is a real stretch. Clearly we're not talking about the levels of greatness that Presidents like Jefferson, Lincoln, and FDR have attained. Obama doesn't even come CLOSE to them, but that's because there are different categories.

          Report Abuse
    • Author by snoopy (September 29, 2008 6:02 pm ET)
         

      Well, Fox sure can't say they don't know what taking something out of context means. They have that part down pretty well.

      Report Abuse
    • Author by Limit Corp. Ownership (September 29, 2008 6:50 pm ET)
         
      Trying to stir up a little phony outrage... This garbage now passes for "the media" in the United States of America. Pretty sad.
      Report Abuse
    • Author by wolf kotenberg (September 29, 2008 7:58 pm ET)
         
      I was on FOXland today to keep up with their tidbits and some president wanna be from the past ( I did not recognise the name 0 was spouting off today's 777 point of the DJIA as " just a little tick ". Right on cue talking point of the day. Cavuto get ready to resurface your 10000 point DOW banner because it is getting close to 10K again, albeit the other way.
      Report Abuse

my.MediaMatters.org

Login  Sign Up

Push Back

Phone calls, emails and letters from the public do make a difference. Remember that to be effective you must be polite, and professional. Express your specific concerns regarding that particular news report or commentary, and indicate what you would like the media outlet to do differently in the future.