About us Login Get email updates
Research
Print

CNN's Blitzer, Keilar don't challenge latest GOP claim that spending bills amount to "$24 billion a day, a billion dollars an hour"

March 11, 2009 7:56 pm ET

Please upgrade your flash player. The video for this item requires a newer version of Flash Player. If you are unable to install flash you can download a QuickTime version of the video.

EMBED

SUMMARY: On The Situation Room, Wolf Blitzer did not challenge a Republican talking point repeated by Rep. Eric Cantor that the cost of the omnibus appropriations bill and the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act amounts to $24 billion a day, a billion dollars an hour." That calculation is based on dividing the costs of the two bills over 50 days. But as Time's Michael Scherer noted, "[t]he omnibus is a spending bill to run the government over the course of an entire year. ... The stimulus will be paid out over several years, with most of the money going out the door over the next 18 months."

15 Comments

During the March 11 edition of CNN's The Situation Room, host Wolf Blitzer did not challenge the claim by Rep. Eric Cantor (R-VA) that the cost of the omnibus appropriations bill and the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act "amounts to $24 billion a day, a billion dollars an hour." The calculation is based on dividing the cost of the two bills over 50 days; but as Time's Michael Scherer noted, "[t]he omnibus is a spending bill to run the government over the course of an entire year. ... The stimulus will be paid out over several years, with most of the money going out the door over the next 18 months."

In a March 11 Politico article, chief political correspondent Mike Allen noted that "[t]he math" behind a similar claim by Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) was "50 days times 24 hours equals 1,200 hours. 1,200 times 1 billion equals 1.2 trillion (a thousand billions is a trillion)." Scherer wrote:

It's true that if you add the stimulus and the omnibus you get about $1.2 trillion. But that money will not be spent in 50 days. The omnibus is a spending bill to run the government over the course of an entire year. (It should have passed last fall, but was delayed for the presidential election and because of partisan infighting.) The stimulus will be paid out over several years, with most of the money going out the door over the next 18 months. So no one is spending a billion dollars an hour. Consider this comparison: If over the course of a one hour board meeting, the head of Mattel decided to produce 1 million new Barbie dolls over the coming year, no one would say that Mattel is making 1 million Barbie dolls an hour. They would say Mattel is making 1 million Barbie dolls a year.

Later in the show, congressional correspondent Brianna Keilar uncritically aired a clip of McConnell stating, "In just 50 days, Congress has voted to spend about $1.2 trillion between the stimulus and the omnibus. To put that in perspective, that's about $24 billion a day."

From the March 11 edition of CNN's The Situation Room:

CANTOR: Well, we in the House, I think, ought to be adopting a moratorium right now to clean up the process. Then we can go about spending the taxpayer dollars in a much more meritorious, much more efficient way. But the system is so broken at this point. We need to take a step back, take a deep breath, do what families and small businesses are doing across this country -- tighten the belt and understand that any expenditure has to be done right.

BLITZER: Because -- listen to Congressman Peter King, Republican of New York. I spoke to him the other day. He strongly defends earmarks. Listen to this.

KING [video clip]: I believe that responsible earmarks are an absolutely essential part of my job as a member of Congress. Because if I don't earmark for my district, some faceless bureaucrat in the administration -- and a Democratic administration -- is going to be deciding how money is spent in the Third Congressional District.

BLITZER: What do you say to that?

CANTOR: Listen, we are in extraordinary times right now. You know, the amount of spending in Washington is overwhelming. Between the stimulus bill and the spending bill that just passed the Senate yesterday, it's 1.2 trillion. Wolf, that amounts to $24 billion a day, a billion dollars an hour. That is coupled with the severity of the economic situation. We've got to take extraordinary measures right now. The system is broken. Let's say --

BLITZER: Because Congressman King and others -- Democrats and Republicans -- say the legislative branch of government is equal to the executive branch, and if the legislative branch doesn't direct money to certain projects, some faceless bureaucrat at the Department of Transportation or elsewhere in the executive branch is going to do that. Do you have a problem, and do you think your constituents in your district would have a problem if they made those decisions as opposed to you?

[...]

BLITZER: Look at this eye-popping number right now: $764 and a half billion. That's how much the deficit has grown to, and it's a record.

The Treasury Department says the federal budget deficit grew almost $193 billion last month alone. That was a record as well. With unprecedented numbers like these, what are lawmakers saying about the notion of yet another economic stimulus plan? Our congressional correspondent Brianna Keilar is standing by with more on this part of the story.

Brianna, what's going on?

KEILAR: Wolf, some rank-and-file Democrats think it's a good idea, but Democratic leadership aides say it's too soon to talk about another stimulus.

[begin video clip]

KEILAR: House Democratic leadership aides deny work is already under way on another economic stimulus package less than a month after Congress threw the economy a $787 billion lifeline.

The pushback comes back after Congressman David Obey, the top Democrat on the House Appropriations Committee, told CNN Tuesday night he's already instructed his staff to start drafting a proposal for another stimulus plan. A Democratic leadership aide tells CNN Obey got ahead of himself.

But House Speaker Nancy Pelosi said Tuesday more stimulus money might be needed.

PELOSI: We have to keep the door open to see how this goes.

KEILAR: Republicans jumped on the talk of another expensive bill, accusing Democrats of out-of-control government spending.

McCONNELL: In just 50 days, Congress has voted to spend about $1.2 trillion between the stimulus and the omnibus. To put that in perspective, that's about $24 billion a day.

KEILAR: While Democratic leaders sought to tamp down suggestions another stimulus is on the horizon, some rank-and-file House Democrats, like Pennsylvania moderate Joe Sestak, are ready to support one.

Expand All Expand 1st Level Collapse All Add Comment
    • Author by Marker (March 11, 2009 8:06 pm ET)
         
      Blitzer is the perfect lap dog for the media farce called CNN.
      Report Abuse
      • Author by eweston8542983 (March 11, 2009 8:20 pm ET)
           

        And now back to "The Sky is Falling." The much anticipated recursive serial!

        Report Abuse
    • Author by mr. l (March 11, 2009 8:32 pm ET)
         

      The whole bill spent in fifty days?!  What?!?!  As a substitute math teacher, I applaud the fact that Cantor can divide- good for him.  As an adult, I am astounded this person got elected to anything other than 'Most likely to annoy everyone around him'.

      Report Abuse
      • Author by carlileb5935 (March 11, 2009 10:01 pm ET)
           

        I think MMFA missed the bigger lie here-- the Repub are clearly trying to make it look like this bill is going to cost the American people $24 billion a day ad infinitum-- like the way they calculate the national debt.

        Report Abuse
    • Author by jjamele2880 (March 11, 2009 9:41 pm ET)
         

      Sean Hannity gave exactly these calculations, in exactly the same words, only minutes into his radio show this afternoon.

      I never once heard Hannity tell me how much money we were spending hourly in Iraq.  Not once.  I'm sure that's because I'm not a regular listener, though.

      Report Abuse
      • Author by fawltylogic (March 11, 2009 10:43 pm ET)
           

        Yeah, I bet Hannity has spent a lot of time talking about the cost of the occupation of Iraq. Probably in the same breath that he criticized the vast amount of government spending on the military.

        Report Abuse
    • Author by jjamele2880 (March 11, 2009 9:44 pm ET)
         

      Do you realize that two trillion dollars, spent over the course of a single day, amounts to more than a BILLION DOLLARS A MINUTE??

      Of course, no one is talking about spending two trillion dollars in a day. But still, that figure sure is impressive, and since when do we have to stick to the facts when discussing money? 

      A BILLION DOLLARS A MINUTE!!  Just imagine!  What a waste! When are we going to see a story on this?

      Report Abuse
      • Author by steeve (March 11, 2009 10:56 pm ET)
           

        Why don't the republicans just say that the total cost of the bill is 187 quadrillion dollars?

        If Blitzer were told that, a high-voltage spark would jump from the part of his brain saying that number's wrong to the part of his brain saying that challenging it would show liberal bias.  His brain would fuse shut and his head would flop on his desk.

        Report Abuse
    • Author by 1st Republic 14th Star (March 11, 2009 9:45 pm ET)
         

      Like calling Obama a socialist and claiming aiding financial institutions is "nationalizing banks."  Like calling John Kerry a coward.  Like accusing Hillary Clinton of murder.

      The talking points are always the same -- they're obviously developed in a centralized way, and driven from the top down.  They can always be traced back to the Republican National Committee, the offices of the Republican Congressional leaders, or the White House (when it's in GOP hands).

      Then the "liberal" media repeats these talking points and uses them to frame issues just like the actual Republican office holders do.

      The process is so well established that it's now an institution.

      Report Abuse
      • Author by jwcoop715110 (March 11, 2009 10:26 pm ET)
           

        Hey, it's easier to parrot the gop's slop than to fact check it.

        Report Abuse
    • Author by steeve (March 11, 2009 10:44 pm ET)
         

      I've seen a lot of republican lying, but I am floored by this one.  It is so nakedly transparent that the words "nakedly transparent" don't cover it.

      Like with the fake mice, this lie nullifies the entirety of republican criticism over this bill.  Obviously there is nothing at all wrong with it, because if there were, that would be your message.

      Since the debate is over, let's pass this bill.  And let's pass Obama's budget while we're at it, because that debate ended with the "small businesses" crap.

      Report Abuse
      • Author by princeofwheels (March 12, 2009 11:01 am ET)
           

        If you bring this 'correction' to a conversation with a Republicon, they will immediatley begin to complain that the money is still being spent while not admitting that a lie has been told to 'yeastify' (new word)  the story.

        Report Abuse
    • Author by Brabantio (March 12, 2009 8:23 am ET)
         

      I suppose on the day that I bought a used truck, I spent about $333 an hour.  And the day I bought my house I spent about $7900 an hour.  That seems awfully wasteful now that I think about it that way.

      I don't even think the timeline is particularly relevant.  If you're getting something worthwhile for what you're spending, it doesn't matter how much it costs per hour.

      Cantor needs a smack upside the head.  This isn't even as blatantly stupid as his comment about other issues distracting us from the economy, but it's damn close.

      Report Abuse
    • Author by hurricaneyankee52983 (March 12, 2009 12:10 pm ET)
         
      Why is it that none of these clows ever challenge these right wing lies?
      Report Abuse
    • Author by steve52 (March 12, 2009 7:33 pm ET)
         

      All these guys know how to do is lie. Cantor is a Newt wannabe, and Wolfie might as well be on Fox.

      Report Abuse

my.MediaMatters.org

Login  Sign Up

Push Back

Phone calls, emails and letters from the public do make a difference. Remember that to be effective you must be polite, and professional. Express your specific concerns regarding that particular news report or commentary, and indicate what you would like the media outlet to do differently in the future.