About us Login Get email updates
Research
Print

Hour 3: Discussing Heilemann's comments about Limbaugh being leader of GOP, Rush says "[h]e's right"

April 30, 2009 3:37 pm ET

7 Comments

This hour of the Limbaugh Wire brought to you by Rush's "running room" as leader of the GOP
By Simon Maloy

Kicking off the final hour, Rush professed to be shocked that the Associated Press had released two "fact checks" criticizing Obama last night, saying you don't normally see this sort of thing. Really? Because we see them all the time. That darn liberal media strikes again...

Anyway, speaking of the liberal media, Rush turned his attention to Vice President Biden's comments on Today this morning on the swine flu and public transportation, saying that Biden was creating a "panic." Then he noted that Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano appeared on MSNBC a little while later saying that if Biden could say what he said again, he'd amend his comments slightly. Rush said that if you're a Democrat, the mainstream media always gives you a chance to say it again. Noting that Sen. Tom Harkin (D-IA) was not happy about Biden's comments, Limbaugh said it's time to "circle the wagons" around Biden -- Specter, as well, because senior Senate Democrats are reportedly unhappy that Specter will be allowed to retain his seniority on committees. Then Rush aired audio of Chuck Todd, speaking with MSNBC "anchoress" Contessa Brewer, describing the vice president's comments on Today as "Biden being Biden," and that Brewer said Biden may have been echoing what many Americans may be thinking.

Then Rush got around to doing what we'd been waiting for him to do all day -- mocking Obama for, at the press conference last night, encouraging Americans to take specific steps to prevent flu transmission: hand-washing, covering coughs, etc. Rush noted that the president did not specify for how long they should wash their hands, or what soap they should use. As with all the tire gauge foolishness from the campaign, we find it fascinating that conservatives are mocking Obama for suggesting to Americans things they can do that will keep them healthy or save them money. We guess, by their logic, people would be better served by driving on their rims and licking doorknobs.

After the break, Rush took a call from a college professor in central California who said that there are people in her area who try to keep their unemployment benefits going as long as possible, and that there are even college courses that they take that instruct them on how best to do this. Rush was dumbfounded, saying that the real question here is what came first -- the unemployment benefits or the classes on how to maintain benefits. Not quite the cleanest chicken-or-the-egg scenario we've encountered.

After another quick break, Rush wanted to play a sound bite from Charlie Rose's roundtable last night, in which New York magazine's John Heilemann said that Obama should have said at the press conference that he was enchanted by Rush Limbaugh, because the absence of a compelling Republican leader allows Limbaugh to have a lot of room to run around. Rush said: "He's right; wide latitude, lots of running room, nobody with any alternative ideas out there." Remember way back when Rush denied vociferously that he was the leader of the GOP? Guess that's not operative anymore...

Then Rush claimed that Attorney General Eric Holder is in Berlin "begging" the Germans to take Guantánamo detainees. The "dirty little secret" behind this, Rush said, is: "We're just gonna release them under the premise that they've been held unlawfully. We owe these people -- we're just gonna turn them loose in Montana or wherever else. Just turn 'em loose, let 'em go." No, we're not going to "turn them loose in Montana" or anywhere. In fact, Montana has a brand-spankin' new prison facility just sitting up there waiting for them.

After one more break, Rush closed out the program with a call from a gentleman who noted that Obama took a question last night from a "sharp-looking black guy from BET," who asked how the stimulus package will benefit African-Americans. Noting that Obama included Latinos in explaining how the stimulus will benefit minority groups, the caller grew agitated, claiming that the BET reporter only wanted to know what Obama was "doing for the brothers," since they're the ones who "put him there." Rush answered by expanding on his theory on "blue" cities from yesterday, saying that in any blue city run by Democrats, education is a mess, the drop-out rates are high among minorities -- just look at New York. We'll point out again, as we did yesterday, that New York City has not had a Democratic mayor in over 15 years. Anyway, Rush said that Democrats are not trying to fix anything, "[a]nd if you have a statist and authoritarian whose objective is to grow the government as large as possible, I mean, it's the -- a fundamental element of that is having as many people dependent on that government as possible." We'll give you one guess as to who that statist authoritarian is...

Well, that does it for today's Wire, and, if you'll permit, I'll slip into the first-person singular in saying that also does it for me for this week. I've been writing this thing every day for the past... jeez, it's been less than two months? That's it? Well, either way, I've earned a long weekend, I think. But just because I won't be here doesn't mean the Limbaugh Wire won't continue, so please tune in tomorrow for a special guest author. Until then, please take a look at Media Matters' continually updated Limbaugh archives, and I'll see you all on Monday.

Highlights from Hour 3

Outrageous comments

Ego on loan from Narcissus

LIMBAUGH: Now, this is -- see this is where they're wrong. They -- and Carville was out there talking about the great Rush Limbaugh's a -- you know, the leader of the Republican Party and so forth, and that -- so there's no real political leadership. And everybody's scared of me in the Republican Party. They're afraid to disagree with me. So it gets him -- but he's right; wide latitude, lots of running room, nobody with any alternative ideas out there.

[...]

LIMBAUGH: See, the dirty little secret is that the more misery among people who are already -- I mean, people who are already miserable are voting Democrat anyway. People in dire educational or economic circumstances are already voting Democrat, and they've been voting Democrat all their lives under the premise it's all going to get better. It doesn't get better, particularly in blue cities, major metro areas.

The conclusion, therefore, has to be one of two things: either they don't know how to fix it, quote-unquote, or they don't want to. And if you have a statist and authoritarian whose objective is to grow the government as large as possible, I mean, it's the -- a fundamental element of that is having as many people dependent on that government as possible.

America's Truth Rejector

Falsely claimed the administration is going to "turn loose" Gitmo detainees in Montana:

LIMBAUGH: They want to close Gitmo January 2010, and they're gonna release people in America. They're just gonna -- and they want to release some in Germany. And they wants -- they want to release some in France. And that Holder, since we're going to do it, is trying to convince them to do it.

We're just gonna release them. We're just going to release them and let them assimilate no differently than if they were illegal immigrants. We're just gonna release them under the premise that they've been held unlawfully. We owe these people -- we're just gonna turn them loose in Montana or wherever else. Just turn 'em loose, let 'em go.

Clips from this hour

Limbaugh on closing Guantánamo: "[T]hey're just going to turn them loose in Montana or wherever else"

Limbaugh discusses assertion that Limbaugh is the head of the GOP

Limbaugh refers to Contessa Brewer as "anchoress"

Limbaugh: "Obama has been able to slither and slide between the lines, been able to say he stands for America's traditions while he trashes them"

Expand All Expand 1st Level Collapse All Add Comment
    • Author by John T. (April 30, 2009 4:00 pm ET)
         

      You listen to the show and you still manage to take Rush out of context and distort his words. He was agreeing with Heilemann that he has a lot of "running room," not that he is the leader of the GOP.

      Report Abuse
      • Author by franky (April 30, 2009 9:56 pm ET)
           

        >>>I didn't hear the show but I take it that Maloy's point is the contrast as to how Limbaugh spoke today about it versus how he previously did so.  He's moved closer to acceptance of the crown.  Here's the pertinent paragraph: 

        Maloy:  After another quick break, Rush wanted to play a sound bite from Charlie Rose's roundtable last night, in which New York magazine's John Heilemann said that Obama should have said at the press conference that he was enchanted by Rush Limbaugh, because the absence of a compelling Republican leader allows Limbaugh to have a lot of room to run around. Rush said: "He's right; wide latitude, lots of running room, nobody with any alternative ideas out there." Remember way back when Rush denied vociferously that he was the leader of the GOP? Guess that's not operative anymore...

        Report Abuse
      • Author by creeksneakers2 (April 30, 2009 10:24 pm ET)
           

        Here's the context. It looks to me like Limbaugh agreed both with the running room and his role as the sole source of ideas for the GOP

        RUSH:  See, this is where they're wrong.  Carville was out there saying the great Rush Limbaugh is, you know, the leader of the Republican Party and so forth. So there's no real political leadership, and everybody is scared of me in the Republican Party. They're afraid to disagree with me.  So he's right: wide latitude, lots of running room, nobody with any alternative ideas out there.  "But, Rush, I've heard that the Congress Republicans are proposing alternative budget ideas." Yeah, yeah, yeah, but that's in acceptance of a premise that's already been advanced.  I'm talking about genuine contrast.  I'm talking about standing up and saying, "This budget is a disaster!  Now, we can't stop it right now, but it's a disaster, and somebody's going to have to stop this stuff down the road," and make the case.  

        Report Abuse
        • Author by franky (May 01, 2009 12:05 am ET)
             

          I agree with you he declared himself the GOP's idea man.   "...nobody with any alternative ideas out there."

          I think another key sentence is where he says there is no POLITICAL leadership.  And just previous to that he quotes Carville as saying he is the leader, and importantly it was Limbaugh who brought the subject up unpromted.  I took this as Limbaugh claiming leadership of the GOP by default.

          "Carville was out there saying the great Rush Limbaugh is, you know, the leader of the Republican Party and so forth. So there's no real POLITICAL leadership..." - R.L.

          Report Abuse
    • Author by franky (April 30, 2009 9:40 pm ET)
         

      I'd bet that anyone who reads this part of Media Matters for a week or so as I've just done will come away with an altered attitude of Rush Limbaugh.  And I think that's regardless of your starting point; whether a long time Democrat who only rarely catches any of his show like myself or the staunchest Republican who listens daily to all three hours.  (BTW, if you know a big Limbaugh fan, you might want to test how confident they really are by daring them to read this section for a week.)

      Personally I've had a low regard for him going back decades.  But if asked my opinion many years ago it wouldn't have been as confidently negative as it is now.  I knew he was a heavyweight BS'er but it wasn't until internet sites like this one came along, and put down in black and white his lies and distortions, that a lot of what I had only fuzzily thought was concretely verified for me.

      And this new thing that Media Matters is doing goes a step further in shining a light on this integral component of the GOP.  I think its' additional value, as contrasted to the more in depth but less frequent articles here, is in how it illustrates THE SHEER VOLUME of lies, distortions, scandalizing insults and hate that he propagates WITHIN A SINGLE SHOW, and repeatedly day after day.  It also allows one to see how inconsistent and very often contradictory he is.  It captures the RELENTLESS nature of the noise machine.  Putting it down in print, albeit only partly in transcripts, prevents things from slipping off without notice. The propaganda JUMPS off the screen.  Because this site is very honest I feel very confident in the veracity of the necessarily slightly subjective guiding narrative provided.  And the narrative saves a lot of time.   

      Great idea and execution Media Matters and Mr. Maloy.

      Report Abuse
      • Author by creeksneakers2 (April 30, 2009 10:27 pm ET)
           

        Simon is a great guy and he's really earned his day off.

        I enjoyed reading your post and admire your open mind.

        Report Abuse
    • Author by princeofwheels (April 30, 2009 9:59 pm ET)
         

      May I be the first here to say to you, TOO BAD, Rush has lied soooo often that he doesn't know the truth.

      He is not being taken out of context. If you wish to fall into the Anxiety Hole (the A HOLE) which Rush produces, be my guest.

      Report Abuse

my.MediaMatters.org

Login  Sign Up

Push Back

Phone calls, emails and letters from the public do make a difference. Remember that to be effective you must be polite, and professional. Express your specific concerns regarding that particular news report or commentary, and indicate what you would like the media outlet to do differently in the future.