About us Login Get email updates
Research
Print

Hour 3: Limbaugh Continues To Promote Birther Conspiracy Theories

July 20, 2009 3:44 pm ET

8 Comments

Do you like to yell nonsense about Obama's birth certificate? Then you, too, can be featured on The Rush Limbaugh Show!
By Greg Lewis

Rush got the third hour going by reading a Time magazine article about utility companies "scrambl[ing]" to meet the power needs of electric cars. The stupid environmentalist wackos, declared Rush, don't realize their electric cars do not come from clean energy. We guess it didn't matter to Rush that the article wasn't actually about what he thought it was -- it had nothing to do with energy sources, but rather energy infrastructure to meet the demands of an influx in plug-in electric vehicles in California. In other words, he simply jammed an irrelevant story into his "idiot" environmentalist narrative.

Then Rush pondered what would happen to abortion under "ObamaCare." Rush said the government won't be able to refuse to pay for abortions. Then Rush speculated about medical ethics, wondering what would happen if they could identify the genetic marker for homosexuality. Rush said if this happened, then the gay community would quickly "convert" from being pro-choice to pro-life.

Moving on, Rush followed through on his promise last week to contrast Vice President Joe Biden with former Sen. Bob Torricelli (D-NJ). We won't bore you with the particulars of this inside joke from Limbaugh Land, but what this consisted of was having his audio engineer pair snippets from Biden's speech last week touting the impact of the stimulus on the economy with sound bites of CNBC's Maria Bartiromo announcing dire economic news.

Then Rush went back to wading in the swamp of Birther nonsense. He played an audio clip from a town hall meeting with Rep. Mike Castle (R-DE) featuring a woman yelling about Obama's lack of birth certificate and claiming that he was actually born in Kenya. Rush repeated the woman's claims and noted that "all kinds of stuff is bubbling up out there." That's true, there are "all sorts of stuff" out there, and it's crazy. What makes this bit of lunatic idiocy different from other similarly lunatic bits of idiocy is that this one was broadcast across the nation on The Rush Limbaugh Show without so much as a word in contradiction.

After the break, Rush took a call from a critical care physician who explained to Rush that at the hospital where he works, all patients, who have a wide range of insurance coverage, get what they need. Rush told the caller that we never hear the horror stories of people being denied the health care we need. The caller then announced that he is going to quit medicine if the Obama health care reform passes because it would force him to deny care to old people at the behest of some "high school dropout" bureaucrat in Washington. Rush, as you might have guessed, was quite pleased with the caller's outlook.

Rush took another break, and returned this time to discuss Obama's speech last week at the NAACP -- or the NAALCP as Rush calls the group (the "L" standing for "liberal") -- Centennial Convention. Rush felt as though the speech vindicated his sentiment that Obama was in fact making racism worse: "This guy is out there stoking more hatred among these people. He is not bringing us together. Where's the unity?"

Rush proceeded to critique bits of the speech, explaining that Obama was listing all of the "excuses" the left makes for African-American failure. "Bill Cosby got drummed out of the black race for saying this stuff, right?" When Obama described how he wanted kids to "aspire" to be a Supreme Court justice and president of the United States, Rush said that Obama meant, "unless you're Clarence Thomas," Condoleezza Rice, or Thomas Sowell. Then you can "forget aspirations" because people like Obama will chop you into liver.

Then Rush played another bit from the speech, audio of Obama saying that he "had some breaks" in life. What were the breaks? asked Rush. Meeting communist mentors? While we were contemplating just how much sense that retort made, Rush concluded that the speech "didn't inspire anybody" and "reinforced" the existing attitude that exists in the "race business today."

Rush returned to health care with a caller who asked about health savings accounts. Rush explained to the caller that HSAs would help bring the free market system back to health care, but Congress has killed it.

After one more break, Rush took a caller who stated that Walter Cronkite did more to cost U.S. lives in Vietnam than anyone else, because the will to win went south after Cronkite famously declared that it was clear that the war was lost. Rush said he had recently discussed Cronkite with fellow radio host Mark Levin, who suggested Cronkite was so adored because he looked like Walt Disney. What it came down to, though, was that Walter Cronkite -- the man who arguably did more to shape modern television journalism than any person before or since -- was eulogized on The Rush Limbaugh Show as just another insidious liberal who was responsible for the deaths of American soldiers.

And that brings us to the end of today's edition of the Limbaugh Wire. We hope you had as much of a thrill reading it as we did writing it -- particularly the Birther parts. Those are always fun. As always, we'll be back for another round tomorrow, adding more content to the ever-expanding Limbaugh Wire archives.

Simon Maloy, Zachary Pleat, and Ariana Probinsky contributed to this edition of the Limbaugh Wire.

Highlights from Hour 3

Outrageous comments

LIMBAUGH: Folks, this is the original litmus test. This is the original list of sins. This guy is out there stoking more hatred among these people. He is not bringing us together. Where's the unity?

Expand All Expand 1st Level Collapse All Add Comment
    • Author by newzhound (July 20, 2009 5:03 pm ET)
      1  
      Two points on the "birthier" matter that I have shamelessly cribbed from others:

      #1. Mr. Obama is now President of the United States. It is now up to those who contest his status for that office to prove it. It isn't up to him to prove anything. He won.

      #2. To all the idiots who claim "He just has too..." He doesn't just have to do anything (Please see #1, above}. Additionally, his supporters don't need to see any more documentation and his enemies won't believe anything they are shown.

      It's tempting to suggest we just ignore these children as they play poorly in the sandbox. But then folks such as Major Stefan Frederick Cook appear and we realize that these lies do, indeed, make a difference in the lives of real people. And not for the better, either...

      Report Abuse
      • Author by Liarliarpantsonfire (July 21, 2009 2:11 pm ET)
          1
        All actions and policies to the contrary, Obama was not elected a dictator. He was elected President, an office that should, and by law is required to address the concerns of ALL of the people of the U.S., not just his followers. Yes, he must respond to the people. It would take him 2 minutes on any one of his TV stations to put this issue to rest and those that push this "issue" to shame.
        I don't even believe the 'birth certificate' issue - if one could call it that - but I find it strange that he continues to ignore information that is clearly spreading and growing in popularity. Something that he could stop with a simple, official release. In fact, the only reason I have given any thought to this is because of his refusal to answer to a growing number of people.
        Report Abuse
    • Author by creeksneakers2 (July 20, 2009 7:07 pm ET)
      2 1
      Rush is such a sneak. He's trying to promote birther mass psychosis while trying to make it look like he's not taking sides. Lots of things are "bubbling up." Some of them are calls to violence. The right wing extremists can get more and more wild and Rush will just egg them on. Rush makes lots of money that way.
      Report Abuse
    • Author by Big D (July 20, 2009 11:51 pm ET)
        1
      Why can't we end all this dogma and hyperbole by reestablishing “The Fairness Doctrine”? Equal time for "All" points of view. Believe it or not, there are more than 2 points of view. Can you just imagine Rush or Beck waiting their turn to speak? It might bring back civility and dialog. Citizens might actually get information they can use to make “good” decisions for the country and fulfill our mandate to the Constitution.

      I can't believe the President hasn’t thought of this and that speaks volumes.
      Report Abuse
      • Author by wzwriter (July 21, 2009 12:55 pm ET)
        1 1
        Even better - how about a "Truth In Broadcasting Doctrine"?

        Anyone who hosts a talk show who willfully broadcasts misleading or false information (or wacko theories that cannot be proven) will be subject to a fine of $1,000 per occurrence. And any station that carries his or her program would be subject to a similar fine.

        The result would be the death of right-wing talk radio, and a return to civility.
        Report Abuse
    • Author by Korsa (July 21, 2009 2:55 am ET)
      1 1
      Wow, what a very nice thing for them to say about a man who has recently passed away. I think if they had any sense of decorum they would leave him out of their lies for at least a little while. Then again...look who I'm talking about.

      "These people" eh? Well, that kind of tends to cause people of one group to shy away from another group. To call them, "these people" as if they are not the same. If he thinks unity should happen so fast, then maybe he should look at himself and other Republican radio hosts that spit out the lies and twist up the facts and truth that they seem to like doing so much.

      Maybe they should look at themselves and change the way they treat people, and the way they act. Would it really kill them so much to tell the truth once in a while? The whole, honest truth? It's like water to the Wicked Witch of the West to them, apparently.
      Report Abuse
    • Author by liberalbob (July 21, 2009 8:21 am ET)
        1
      I sure hope the person who listens and writes this blog every day gets paid a lot of money. It takes me only a minute or two before I have to change the radio station.
      Report Abuse
      • Author by Don Hussein Fabuloso (July 21, 2009 2:00 pm ET)
        1  
        But people adore them because they're Dopey and Goofy. Make your own decision as to which is which.

        This Birfer BS seems to be a religion. I just looked at another thread, and there are still the "sensible" impartial posters (wink wink) wondering why (even though they personally don't think Obama ia a usurper) he just won't produce his birth certificate rather than spending millions to fight court cases.

        This is on threads where it's already been shown that the BC has been established, and several "concerned citizens" have been asked to support their claims that Obama is spending millions to hide something, none of them providing anything.

        Amazing what the human mind can be talked into believing, how emotion can just blow rational thought outta the water when people like the Birfers are being told what they want to hear..
        Report Abuse
The Fox Effect
Media Matters Connect

Push Back

Phone calls, emails and letters from the public do make a difference. Remember that to be effective you must be polite, and professional. Express your specific concerns regarding that particular news report or commentary, and indicate what you would like the media outlet to do differently in the future.