About us Login Get email updates
Research
Print

Wash. Post Beck beat: Paper follows Fox host's lead in tying SEIU to ACORN

October 06, 2009 3:10 pm ET — 12 Comments

On the heels of Washington Post ombudsman Andrew Alexander's September 20 suggestion that the paper "should pay attention" to Fox News, the Post published an October 6 article headlined, "Some Criticize SEIU for Its ACORN Connections." In echoing Glenn Beck's fixation with "connections" between ACORN and SEIU, the Post gave no indication why "connections" between the two organizations would be inappropriate -- or in any way newsworthy.

Post -- echoing Beck -- suggests that ACORN, SEIU "connections" entail newsworthy controversy

From the September 21 edition of Fox News' Glenn Beck:

beckpost

Beck: "ACORN and SEIU ... Same thing. Same people, same street address, same everything." Beck has stated on his radio program: "Forget about ACORN. Think about community organizers. ACORN could change its name and then everybody would be like, 'Oh, problem solved.' No, its not. ACORN has 270 other names. So now the government has ACORN and its 270 other names inside the government with AmeriCorps. They're inside the White House with ACORN and the census and its 270 organizations." He added, "[R]emember, ACORN and SEIU, the union -- same thing. Same thing. Same people, same street address, same everything." [Premiere Radio Networks' The Glenn Beck Program; 7/23/09]

Post echoes Beck: "Some Criticize SEIU for Its ACORN Connections." From the October 6 Washington Post article:

Some Criticize SEIU for Its ACORN Connections

A rapidly growing union that represents nurses, janitors and other low-wage workers is coming under fire from conservatives because of its long-standing financial and leadership ties to ACORN, a liberal organizing group recently embarrassed by videos filmed covertly.

Some Republicans say federal agencies that recently cut ties with ACORN -- the Association of Community Organizations for Reform Now -- should also consider severing their relationship with the Service Employees International Union. The SEIU and ACORN have long worked closely together, with the union paying the association more than $3.6 million in the past three years and sharing some office locations and leaders with the group.

[...]

The SEIU's parent organization has paid ACORN for training, voter registration and other organizing work, and SEIU locals have paid ACORN affiliates for their services, according to union reports. ACORN founder Wade Rathke was a top member of the SEIU's board until last year and founded two SEIU locals -- in Chicago and New Orleans. SEIU President Andy Stern serves on an advisory panel that was supposed to help ACORN fix financial problems after an embezzlement was discovered last year. Other leaders have served both ACORN and the SEIU, including Keith Kelleher, who headed SEIU Local 880 and also held an ACORN staff position, and whose wife ran the ACORN office in Illinois.

Beck: "Two of SEIU's locals are ACORN affiliates." Beck stated on his Fox News program that "SEIU is essentially ACORN. It's just unionized. Two of SEIU's locals are ACORN affiliates." [Glenn Beck (accessed via Nexis), 9/23/09]

Beck: ACORN founder Wade Rathke "is also closely tied to" SEIU. While discussing George Stephanopoulos' interview with President Obama, Beck stated of Obama, "By the way, he's also tied closely to SEIU, which ACORN founder Wade Rathke is also closely tied to. Hmm." [Glenn Beck (accessed via Nexis), 9/21/09]

Post echoes Beck: "ACORN founder Wade Rathke was a top member of the SEIU's board until last year and founded two SEIU locals -- in Chicago and New Orleans."

Beck: Andy Stern is on "ACORN advisory council." After asserting that "SEIU is essentially ACORN. It's just unionized," Beck stated that "there's the Obama connection. Remember, just this weekend, President Obama said, 'I haven't really been following ACORN. I don't even really know what's going on.' ACORN advisory council -- on it, Andy Stern, SEIU. Stern just told the LA Times that he visits the White House about once a week. Wow. Is that surprising?" [Glenn Beck (accessed via Nexis), 9/23/09]

Post echoes Beck: "SEIU President Andy Stern serves on an advisory panel that was supposed to help ACORN fix financial problems after an embezzlement was discovered last year."

Beck: "[T]hey are in the same building. ACORN and SEIU." Beck stated on his Fox News program: "Here are the power centers of corruption. First, we start down at New Orleans. This is -- they are in the same building. ACORN and SEIU. Who's around the president all the time? ACORN and SEIU." [Glenn Beck (accessed via Nexis), 9/14/09]

Beck: SEIU has "powerful connection" to ACORN because they "share goals and office space." On his Fox News program, Beck similarly said of ACORN and SEIU: "[T]here is one more powerful connection for SEIU. Members of its local chapters share goals and office space with none other than ACORN. SEIU, ACORN, and Obama: branches of the same tree. And that's SEIU in a nutshell." [Glenn Beck; 7/6/09]

Post echoes Beck: "The SEIU and ACORN have long worked closely together, with the union paying the association more than $3.6 million in the past three years and sharing some office locations and leaders with the group."

Post ombudsman previously said Post may not be "pay[ing] sufficient attention to conservative media"

Andrew Alexander: Post "should pay attention" to Fox News. Alexander recently criticized the Post for "tardiness" in covering the Beck-led ACORN videotape controversy, arguing that newspapers should pay more attention to right-wing media outlets and that the Post's purportedly slow reaction to the ACORN story is related to institutional liberal bias. In doing so, Alexander adopted the right-wing argument that the ACORN videos are a major story.

From Alexander's September 20 column:

With ACORN, The Post wrote about it two days after the first of several explosive hidden-camera videos were aired showing the group's employees giving tax advice to young conservative activists posing as a prostitute and her pimp. Three days passed before The Post ran a short Associated Press story about the Senate halting Housing and Urban Development grants to ACORN, which operates in 110 cities. But by that time, the Census Bureau had severed ties with ACORN. State and city investigations had been launched. It wasn't until late in the week that The Post weighed in with two solid pieces.

Why the tardiness?

One explanation may be that traditional news outlets like The Post simply don't pay sufficient attention to conservative media or viewpoints.

It "can't be discounted," said Tom Rosenstiel, director of the Pew Research Center's Project for Excellence in Journalism. "Complaints by conservatives are slower to be picked up by non-ideological media because there are not enough conservatives and too many liberals in most newsrooms."

[...]

The most authoritative recent research into the political leanings of newsrooms (including television, radio, magazines and wire services) shows they are considerably more liberal than the general public. At daily newspapers, those who "lean to the left still far outnumber those who lean to the right," said Indiana University journalism professor David H. Weaver, whose researchers surveyed 1,149 journalists in 2002 and recently conducted a follow-up study of 400.

A recent Pew Research nationwide survey said only 26 percent of those questioned believe news organizations try to protect against political bias, while 60 percent said news organizations are biased.

Beck is more provocateur than newsman. And Fox caters to conservatives. Working in concert, they and other right-leaning media have a large audience. Beck averages 2.25 million viewers.

The Post should follow its own news standards, not theirs. But it should pay attention to what they report. [The Washington Post, 9/20/09]

Parker introduced Beck's ACORN-SEIU attacks to pages of Wash. Post

Parker: ACORN and SEIU "are as tight as Heidi Klum and a new pair of jeans." In a nationally syndicated Washington Post column, Kathleen Parker eariler echoed Beck's witch-hunt efforts to "link" the SEIU and ACORN. Parker further attempted to link SEIU to former Illinois Gov. Rod Blagojevich and suggested that this "dot-connecting" might "stall" health care reform.

From Parker's September 27 Washington Post column:

While everyone in Washington is suddenly pretending they've hardly ever heard of ACORN, they might want to pretend they've never heard of the SEIU, one of the nation's largest unions.

The Association of Community Organizations for Reform Now and the Service Employees International Union are as tight as Heidi Klum and a new pair of jeans.

You don't think about one without the other. [The Washington Post, 9/27/09]

Post follows Wash. Times in echoing Beck's attacks

Wash. Times presents Beck's opinions and attacks as news. In recent weeks, The Washington Times has allowed Beck to dictate its coverage by presenting his attacks on progressives as news: printing an article premised entirely on Beck's opinion that ACORN's internal ethics investigation is "bogus" because its advisory board members are "the worst of the worst"; promoting the Beck-led right-wing attacks on Mark Lloyd, the chief diversity officer at the Federal Communications Commission; and chronicling the Beck-led "hunt for next Van Jones."

Expand All Expand 1st Level Collapse All Add Comment
    • Author by all your eyes (October 06, 2009 3:35 pm ET)
      3  
      How far the mighty have fallen. Who knew that FNC called the shots in the editor's offices at the New York Times and The Washington Post. Aren't these the supposed titans of the vaunted liberal media establishment?
      Report Abuse
    • Author by dexteritas0071418 (October 06, 2009 4:51 pm ET)
      1 1
      MMfA left out where the WashPo transcript was incorrect or misleading.
      Report Abuse
      • Author by dexteritas0071418 (October 06, 2009 4:57 pm ET)
          2
        Which I see may not be the point, but seriously? I guess the BIGGEST deal is that ACORN, until very recently, was getting federal money, and the SEIU is a partisan lobbying organization as well as a union.

        If ACORN is no longer receiving tax dollars, this subject is moot now, though.
        Report Abuse
    • Author by SLRTX (October 06, 2009 5:17 pm ET)
      1  
      Hey, if ACORN has their funds dropped, let's go after ALL of these companies who rip off the US Taxpayer! Surely the "fiscally conservative" Republicans will agree to this, right?

      The text below is from:

      http://www.mccollum.house.gov/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=725&Itemid=92

      Congresswoman Betty McCollum (MN-04) is circulating a ‘Dear Colleague’ encouraging Members of the U.S. House to co-sponsor the Against Corporations Organizing to Rip-off the Nation Act of 2009 (ACORN Act). The bill prohibits corporations with a felony conviction from receiving any federal funding for the five years after the conviction, prohibits corporate felons from making federal campaign contributions for five years, and limits the lobbying the corporation can do during that period. Congresswoman McCollum will formally introduce the ACORN Act on Wednesday, September 30, 2009.
      Report Abuse
    • Author by worrierking (October 06, 2009 7:23 pm ET)
         
      All this time I thought the moon's influence was responsible for the tides. Now I find out it 's Soros.

      Damn you Soros!!!!
      Report Abuse
    • Author by diamonds (October 07, 2009 12:48 am ET)
        1
      I don't get it. So far it looks like Glenn is correct, either (1) show Glenn's facts are wrong, (2) Explain why the facts he presented do not imply the two organizations are related, or (3) Prove that they are not related somehow.

      Simply stating that a conservative commentator said so doesn't make it untrue.

      Even if they were related, what is so bad about that? If the Washington Post is "following the lead" because of Beck or not, how is that a bad thing? Isn't the truth good?
      Report Abuse
    • Author by Welfare-Warfare State (October 07, 2009 11:31 am ET)
         
      When right wing groups petition the state for special favors, advantageous legislation, or subsidies , you guys correctly identify it as special interests feeding at the public trough.
      When left wing organizations not only do the same thing, but collude together to shake down the public, then it's no longer feeding at the public trough. It's enlightened government assisting the citizens in their economic goals. The only reason these groups,or any others, organize together is to try to get by political means what they couldn't earn in a free market by their own merits. They don't like what the free market says their labor is worth, so they attempt to use the power of the state to get it by force. This is the ugly truth behind the term "social justice."
      Report Abuse
      • Author by congero6189599 (October 07, 2009 1:02 pm ET)
           
        I'd like to hear more about these right-wing groups. Which groups and what issues were they petitioning the state for? Until you provide specifics you are just talking to yourself.
        Report Abuse
        • Author by congero6189599 (October 07, 2009 1:08 pm ET)
             
          ...or maybe you're purposely being vague so you could slander what you call left wing organizations. Are you arguing for an abolition of the minimum wage? Just curious.
          Report Abuse
        • Author by Welfare-Warfare State (October 07, 2009 3:05 pm ET)
             
          Anti-abortino groups have petitioned the state for money numerous times. You do understand what petitioning the state means, right. It wasn't a compliment. And yes, I support getting rid of the minimum wage. It resluts in less entrty level jobd beiing created. ACORN advocated an exception to the minimum wage laws for themseles,BTW.
          Report Abuse

my.MediaMatters.org

Login  Sign Up

Push Back

Phone calls, emails and letters from the public do make a difference. Remember that to be effective you must be polite, and professional. Express your specific concerns regarding that particular news report or commentary, and indicate what you would like the media outlet to do differently in the future.

Feed IconRSS Feeds

Get personalized rss or email alerts

Connect & Share

Facebook Twitter Digg YouTube MySpace