Echoing a right-wing blog, Doocy repeatedly claimed Obama's bow was unprecedented
In reporting on the manner in which President Obama greeted Japanese Emperor Akihito, Fox & Friends host Steve Doocy repeatedly claimed that "dating back to the very founding of this Republic, American leaders do not bow to leaders of other countries." In fact, Obama's greeting was far from unprecedented, as several past Presidents have bowed while greeting foreign leaders. Additionally, in reporting on Obama's bow, Fox & Friends repeatedly cited right-wing blog Hot Air in their reports on Obama's greeting.
Doocy repeatedly claimed Obama's greeting is unprecedented
From the November 16 edition of Fox News' Fox & Friends:
DOOCY: Two hundred and thirty-three years of precendent dating back to the very founding of this Republic, American leaders do not bow to leaders of other countries. They are on par. Oops. Take a look, there's the President of the United States bowing to the Emperor of Japan.
[...]
DOOCY: You know this is a long standing precedence going back to the founding of the Republic, American Presidents don't bow to anybody. But the President, there he is, bowing. He bowed to King Abdullah earlier in the year as well. The administration said, look it's just protocol, its one of those things they do. You've been in an administration where a President has faced-look there's Abdullah right there. He's going down-why doesn't the, when you look at this, what do you think?
ROVE: I think it was inappropriate.
In fact, numerous past Presidents have bowed while meeting foreign leaders
Nixon bowed while meeting Japanese Emperor. According to a November 15 post on his ABC News.com blog, Political Punch, Senior White House Correspondent Jake Tapper reported that Obama's bow was not "unprecedented." Tapper cited "an academic with expertise about the Japanese Empire" as noting: "At their 1971 meeting in Alaska, the first visit of a Japanese Emperor to America, President Nixon bowed and referred to Emperor Hirohito and his wife repeatedly as 'Your Imperial Majesties.'... Nixon gets the bow right. Slight arch from the waist hands at his side." Below is the photo to which the Political Punch is referring:

Clinton was criticized for appearing to bow when greeting Akihito in 1994. A June 19, 1994 New York Times article reported of President Bill Clinton's meeting with Akihito: "It wasn't a bow, exactly. But Mr. Clinton came close. He inclined his head and shoulders forward, he pressed his hands together. It lasted no longer than a snapshot, but the image on the South Lawn was indelible: an obsequent President, and the Emperor of Japan." The article added: "But the 'thou need not bow' commandment from the State Department's protocol office maintained a constancy of more than 200 years. Administration officials scurried to insist that the eager-to-please President had not really done the unthinkable. 'It was not a bow-bow, if you know what I mean,' said Ambassador Molly Raiser, the chief of protocol." [New York Times, 6/19/94]
Eisenhower bowed before Charles De Gaulle. A September 2, 1959 Associated Press photo shows President Dwight Eisenhower bowing his head while meeting French President Charles De Gaulle. The caption of the photograph read: "President Dwight Eisenhower bows as he acknowledges speech of greeting by French President Charles De Gaulle on his arrival at Le Bourget near Paris on Sept. 2, 1959. Between the two chief executives is Ludovic Chancel, French Chief of Protocol."

[AP image #5909020306 (registration required), dated 09/02/1959]
Doocy repeatedly cited right-wing blog Hot Air in reports on Obama's bow
Doocy highlighted Hot Air post on images of other world leaders not bowing to Akihito. From the November 16 edition of Fox & Friends:
DOOCY: On Hot Air.com, you know it is interesting, the University of Connecticut College Republicans put together a montage. There were forty-six world leaders who met the Emperor, and only one of them, the President of the United States, actually did any bowing.
Fox & Friends chyron later adopted language from Hot Air post without attribution. Fox & Friends aired on-screen text that stated, "46 Handshakes & 1 Bow," echoing the title of the November 15 Hot Air post, "Video: 46 handshakes, one bow."


















remember, it is a socialist, Marxist indoctrination tool.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gdxubYRfwQw
; )
Maybe they mean unpresidential.
hEY! No tongue in Arabia.
Y'all stay classy
Notice how the Japanese guy didn't bow back? THAT is the bigger story here. Also the majority of Japanese people look down on westerners who bow as they know it's not part of our culture. It's almost an insult to them.
Way to go Propeller Beanie Barry! Next just give 'em a Joe Medicine Crow Shout Out and a fist bump...they would probably respect you more.
Re: "Nixon bowed while meeting Japanese Emperor"
While I generally don't mind any American President to show respect of other country's customs, I'm not so sure that the photo you show of Nixon "bowing" to the Emperor of Japan is actually a bow. It looks more like he's leaning over to listen to the Emperor.
You may want to double-check the accuracy of that particular claim.
That being said, there isn't anything wrong with showing respect for the Emperor of Japan, regardless of who you are.
John Adams, who wasn't President at the time, had to bow to the King of England post Revolutionary War. He didn't like it, but he did it, because it was a show of respect.
I agree that it is normal to shake hands as a greeting in most of Europe, but bowing is also a European custom as well.
As for Nixon, it is Political Punch's claim that Nixon was bowing. Probably have to dig into their work for primary source material.
Just an example was the famous photo of Casious Clay (Muhammad Ali) standing over Sonny Liston after a knockdown. The photo implies Clay was taunting Liston, but when seen in regular speed it happened so fast that had it not been for the picture it wouldn't have been a question.
Read it again. Ike "acknowledges speech" of greeting. Did De Gaulle make a speech and everyone was cheering so Ike bowed, or did he bow to the French Pres. as a greeting? In my time in France I don't ever remember anyone bowing but my French friends would kiss you on both cheeks as a hello/goodbye.
I'd still like to see it in film footage. That would set the context better.
I have been to France a couple of times. I did not see anyone bowing either. It has nothing to do with the picture of Ike as we were both unlikely to see any situations regarding protocol or even two heads of state getting together. It is not the same as greeting peers on the street. No?
Do we really have to explain this to these people? I know you want to have an open mind and that is truly admirable. But, how remedial do we have to get in order to explain the obvious to the far-right? Personally, I think maybe we should stop catering to the stupidest amongst us. Let them sit at the kids' table and babble on about bowing and shaking hands and using terms they clearly do not understand (socialism). Then maybe the adults in this country can actually have some tough conversations and get some things done. You know....progress.
"and they kiss both cheeks"
I assume you are speaking of the French. I missed that one.
In all my travels to France, I shook many hands, a couple of cheek-kisses (never business associates - friends only), but never a bow.
Japan? Yes. Always a bow, but at certain angles, depending on who you were.
If Ike did bow, I'm sure it was in jest, because he and De Gaulle were comrades during the war. They were close friends.
W-H-Y ??
Despite what the fact-devoid, teleprompter-reading babblers at FOX NEWS believe (because Roger Ailes tells them what to believe), George Washington preferred a bow to a handshake.
Ooops!
thomas jefferson decided to shake things up and was the one to introduce the handshake when a dignitary presented himself to the president in the united states.
...Yeah, I didn't watch it either. I can't watch Fuchs and Fiends or anything else on ClusterFox. I look to my morning cereal for my daily dose of Fruit Loops.
I'm not going to go so far out on a limb as to claim to know how the entire rest of the world perceived the bow (you know, because I'm not THE WORLD), but I would think the rest of the world finds it refreshing that the U.S. president treats them with respect.
Furthermore, with regard to that weak perception, remember what the election results would have been had the whole world voted:
http://www.economist.com/Vote2008/
I guess that was a year ago; maybe world opinion overwhelmingly changed after the election:
http://www.worldpublicopinion.org/pipa/articles/views_on_countriesregions_bt/618.php
Ahem... well, maybe in Japan where he bowed the view of him is overwhelmingly unfavorable:
http://pewresearch.org/pubs/1409/obama-asia-trip-popular-japan-china-south-korea
oh... um... nevermind.
additionally..
i'm not sure how this "show of weakness" actually plays out. Does it drastically alter the tenor of any subsequent meetings with the Japanese? Does it reveal cracks in the alliance, affect policymakers, and shift balances of power in appreciable ways?
its all speculation, and mostly based on nameless fears
However, I find little fault with Pres.Obama's bow to the Japanese emperor. His actions should speak a lot louder than any symbolic gesture of respect.
At this point in time I call the bow...no harm, no foul.
Think people! Think!
Greybeard
Now that's funny...I don't care who you are.
It's better that everybody just relax and laugh at the indiscretion than to take it seriously.
Although unnecessary it was harmless. No harm no foul.
I see no harm in bowing, but admittedly the extremely formal bow used by Pres. Obama was truly unnecessary. However, all the wingnuts that are making a big deal about this are just grabbing at anything they can to criticize even when criticism is also unnecessary.
Here's the low down:
http://gojapan.about.com/cs/etiquetteinjapan/a/bowing.htm
A simpler bow would've sufficed as a form of greeting.
A couple of things about that;first, some of the people do seem to be giving slight bows, and second, it's all still photographs, when only video can show that someone did not bow when meeting the Emperor.
You sure he isn't aware of American history? And as for American protocol, since he was in Japan, shouldn'ty he be following Japanese protocol?
Ya know, bowing is pretty normal behavior in Japan. People do it all the time to one another. It's a basic courtesy there.
I have no problem with our President showing some cultural sensitivity and being polite on Japanese terms.
This controversy is meant to bamboozle dopes.
Where did that come in. Did any one know of the bush administration trying to have a military trial of terrorists and the democrats stopped him. I don't know how in the world this channel gets away with the stuff they do. I still say the correct name for them is Republican infomerical Channel.
Peg