NRA Host: Guns Overly Blamed For Violence Because They're Louder Than “Quiet” Knives
Colion Noir Previously Told Parents Of Slain Journalists Not To “Become So Emotional”
Written by Timothy Johnson
Published
National Rifle Association (NRA) web series host Colion Noir cited the “theatrics” and the loud sound guns make as the reason people want to restrict firearms after a high-profile shooting occurs. Noir made the comment during an appearance on a conservative news show where he also defended his recent, controversial advice to the parents of two murdered Virginia journalists.
Noir, who has been helping the NRA's efforts to attract a younger audience to its media platforms, made headlines recently for warning the parents of Virginia journalists Alison Park and Adam Ward to not “become so emotional” in response to their childrens' fatal shooting that they misdirect their “grief-inspired advocacy.” Parker's father, who has said he will make it his “mission in life” to pass stronger gun laws, called Noir's claim “insulting and disingenuous.”
Noir discussed the Virginia shooting and his comments during a September 2 appearance with conservative radio host Dana Loesch on her show, Dana, which appears on Glenn Beck's network The Blaze.
After Loesch brought up an Indiana stabbing that occurred the same day of the August 26 shooting, Noir said, “What the gun suffers from, unfortunately, is its inherent theatrics. With a gun, it's loud, it explodes, it's very theatrical in nature. So it's easy to prop it up on a screen when somebody gets shot with a gun and say, 'Oh my god these things are so dangerous.' With a knife it's quiet, it's very swift, it's unknown, and so there is really not much to show.”
According to Noir, unlike knives, guns are treated as “the most dangerous thing in the world”:
LOESCH: The same day that this Virginia story came out, Colin [sic], there was a story in Indianapolis where a guy car jacked a lady, stabbed her, ran over six people, it's almost -- it doesn't matter the tool, I mean you can't legislate away free will and evil.
NOIR: Yeah, absolutely. What the gun suffers from, unfortunately, is its inherent theatrics. With a gun, it's loud, it explodes, it's very theatrical in nature. So it's easy to prop it up on a screen when somebody gets shot with a gun and say, “Oh my god these things are so dangerous.” With a knife it's quiet, it's very swift, it's unknown, and so there is really not much to show. But when you have a gun it's like, “Oh my god here it is,” -- look you see it, you hear it -- “Oh my god it's the most dangerous thing in the world.” That's when the more irrational aspects of our mentality start to kick in and we're like “Oh we just got to get rid of the gun, we just got to get rid of the gun.” Not realizing, no, the real actor is the person who is utilizing a gun. Because the same way that gun can kill is the same way it can defend.
There are a few obvious reasons guns are more dangerous than knives. Guns are used in 68 percent of murders while knives are used in only 12.2 percent. This is because guns are more effective at killing people. One-third of people who are shot die, compared to 7.7 percent of stabbing victims who do. Guns are also ubiquitous in episodes of mass violence. Of 279 mass killings documented by USA Today since 2006, 211 were committed with firearms, compared to 33 where a knife was used.