Sarah Wasko / Media Matters
Welcome to Executive Time, a recurring feature in which Media Matters senior fellow Matt Gertz explores the intersection between President Donald Trump’s Twitter feed and the hours of cable news he reportedly consumes daily, with a special focus on his favorite morning program, Fox & Friends. You can follow Matt’s work on Twitter @mattgertz and see previous installments in this series here.
Days Trump appeared to live-tweet cable news since our last Executive Time update (1/18): Six (two editions of Fox & Friends, three editions of Fox & Friends Weekend, one edition of Fox & Friends First).
Tweets since our last Executive Time update apparently resulting from live-tweeting cable news: 16 (nine from Fox & Friends, six from Fox & Friends Weekend, one from Fox & Friends First).
At the State of the Union Tuesday night, President Donald Trump took a thinly-veiled shot at largely African-American NFL players who have protested racial inequality and police brutality by kneeling during the pre-game national anthem over the course of the football season. This Sunday night, tens of millions of Americans who tune in to watch Super Bowl LII will find out if any of the New England Patriots or the Philadelphia Eagles respond by protesting before the game begins.
Trump lashed out at protesting football players at a September 22 rally for Alabama Republican Senate candidate Luther Strange, urging fans to “leave the stadium” if players knelt during the anthem and calling on NFL owners to fire players who did so. Those remarks created a firestorm that consumed the press for several days, as the president furiously defended his racial demagoguery and more NFL players protested during the anthem in response.
Over the ensuing months, Trump has continued a running war against the NFL which he largely conducts through early-morning tweets attacking the players for protesting and the league for not forcing them to stand. Based on my research, the timing and method of the president’s criticisms are not a coincidence.
The engine of Trump’s ongoing attacks on the NFL is Fox & Friends, his favorite morning show. The president frequently begins his day by live-tweeting that program (often on a tape delay), highlighting its praise for his administration and its slashing criticism of his foes. Reviewing the president’s tweets on the protests, I’ve determined that at least 13 of them on nine separate days appear to be the result of Trump responding to Fox’s coverage.
All three networks devoted a great deal of programming to the protests after Trump’s September 22 comments. But Fox gave significantly more coverage to anthem protests than the other cable news networks, continued to provide regular updates long after the first few days, and generally struck a harshly critical tone in keeping with its virulent response to other protest movements by African-Americans, such as Black Lives Matter.
This created a feedback loop between Fox and Trump: By continuing to provide updates on the state of the protest, the network reminded Trump of his feud with the league and triggered his quick response. Trump’s Fox live-tweets about the NFL often drove additional coverage from other outlets, as puzzled journalists struggled to determine why the president was reigniting a dormant fight.
For this piece, I reviewed Trump’s tweets about the national anthem since his initial comments in Alabama. It quickly became apparent that his tweets over the first few days after his rally speech would be impossible to match to any discrete cause -- they were too many, and the news coverage across all outlets too regular to draw such conclusions.
But beginning with the president’s tweets on September 25 and continuing to as recently as November 28, I found more than a dozen Trump tweets that I believe can be ascribed to him live-tweeting Fox. These tweets were all sent between the hours of 5 a.m. and 9 a.m., came within an hour of a Fox segment on the issue, were often part of a string of tweets that all match Fox programming, and frequently included language or details that seem ripped directly from the network’s coverage.
September 25
Beginning at 6:05 a.m. ET, Fox & Friends aired a segment about how the day before, in Steve Doocy’s words, “More than 200 players took a knee in the largest protest since Colin Kaepernick started the practice a year ago.” The hosts criticized the players for protesting, as Brian Kilmeade put it, “during the national anthem, not just for the military -- for the country.” Later in the segment, Kilmeade said, “What’s interesting is, NASCAR has a different approach. Richard Petty and Richard Childress essentially said if any of my people do not go out and stand for the national anthem, they won’t be on my team anymore.” Kilmeade also reported that NFL fans at games in New England and Buffalo had booed the players. Captions during the segment included “President: It’s About Respect, Not Race,” and “NFL Fans Cry Foul.”
Roughly 14 minutes after the segment ended, Trump sent the first of three tweets about the protests, which track closely with Fox’s coverage:
So proud of NASCAR and its supporters and fans. They won't put up with disrespecting our Country or our Flag - they said it loud and clear!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) September 25, 2017
Many people booed the players who kneeled yesterday (which was a small percentage of total). These are fans who demand respect for our Flag!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) September 25, 2017
The issue of kneeling has nothing to do with race. It is about respect for our Country, Flag and National Anthem. NFL must respect this!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) September 25, 2017
September 26
The hosts opened the show by discussing how the Dallas Cowboys and the team’s evil, soulless owner, Jerry Jones, had locked arms and taken a knee together before the national anthem played at the game the previous night, but stood during its performance. They played a clip from the game of an announcer saying that “boos can be heard from this sell-out crowd” as the players knelt. Kilmeade quibbled with a report that said that there was a “smattering of boos” during the protest, commenting, “that is loud.” Doocy agreed that there was “a lot of booing from the Dallas Cowboy and the Cardinals fans when they took the knee,” but “a gigantic cheer when the national anthem was played and the flag came.”
The hosts went on to praise the Cowboys for standing up during the anthem, with Kilmeade saying they did “a better job of getting their message out” because it “takes patriotism out of it.” Later in the segment, they reported that the NFL’s ratings had fallen, attributing that to fan anger over the protests. But according to Doocy, “The pregame [ratings] this past weekend were really high because so many people, after the president’s comments, wanted to see whether anybody was going to stand or sit or take a knee.”
The segment ended at 6:10 a.m. Eighteen minutes later, the president started tweeting about the Cowboys game, with his comments again tracking closely with Fox’s coverage:
Ratings for NFL football are way down except before game starts, when people tune in to see whether or not our country will be disrespected!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) September 26, 2017
The booing at the NFL football game last night, when the entire Dallas team dropped to its knees, was loudest I have ever heard. Great anger
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) September 26, 2017
But while Dallas dropped to its knees as a team, they all stood up for our National Anthem. Big progress being made-we all love our country!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) September 26, 2017
October 9
On October 8, Vice President Mike Pence walked out of an Indianapolis Colts game in an obvious political stunt when several players took a knee during the national anthem. The next morning, former Pence press secretary Marc Lotter appeared on Fox & Friends to praise the vice president. Lotter criticized the players, saying they “disrespect the flag, disrespect the national anthem and those who defend it.” He pushed back against the notion that Pence’s appearance was a stunt, calling the trip to the game “long-planned.”
The segment ended at 6:40 a.m. Twenty-five minutes later, the president tweeted:
The trip by @VP Pence was long planned. He is receiving great praise for leaving game after the players showed such disrespect for country!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) October 9, 2017
October 10
Discussing former NFL coach Mike Ditka’s criticism of players who protest during the anthem, co-host Ainsley Earhardt urged the players, “If you have a problem with the country, protest, do whatever you want -- do it peacefully. You can take a knee, just don’t do it during the national anthem, too many people have died for this country."
Moments later, Trump tweeted:
It is about time that Roger Goodell of the NFL is finally demanding that all players STAND for our great National Anthem-RESPECT OUR COUNTRY
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) October 11, 2017
That was one of five consecutive Trump tweets that I previously matched to Fox & Friends segments from that morning, one of which featured Trump praising an author’s book on Twitter roughly 45 minutes after the author appeared on the network and praised the president.
October 11
Fox & Friends ran multiple segments during the 6 a.m. hour highlighting a letter NFL commissioner Roger Goodell sent teams in which he said that “we believe that everyone should stand for the national anthem.”
Fox was the only cable news outlet to cover the story during that hour before Trump appeared to respond to the program on Twitter:
It is about time that Roger Goodell of the NFL is finally demanding that all players STAND for our great National Anthem-RESPECT OUR COUNTRY
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) October 11, 2017
Fox also ran several segments that hour discussing the president’s tax cut plan, which was consistent with two other tweets the president sent that morning.
October 18
At 6:25 a.m., Fox & Friends ran a segment criticizing the NFL for deciding not to force the players to stand during the national anthem or punish players who kneel. The co-hosts and contributor Tomi Lahren condemned the NFL’s decision, with Lahren calling Goodell “spineless” and saying that football fans will revolt because “we love our country.”
About half an hour later, Trump tweeted:
The NFL has decided that it will not force players to stand for the playing of our National Anthem. Total disrespect for our great country!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) October 18, 2017
This was one of four tweets that morning that match Fox & Friends programming.
November 20
Early in the broadcast, the Fox & Friends hosts criticized Oakland Raiders running back Marshawn Lynch for sitting during the U.S. national anthem and standing for the Mexican anthem during a game that weekend in Mexico City. Kilmeade called the story an “international embarrassment” and said the players union needs to “crack down because it’s hurting the league. Nine percent, the attendance is down. Ratings are down.”
No other network covered Lynch’s protest that hour. Less than twenty minutes after the segment ended, Trump tweeted:
Marshawn Lynch of the NFL’s Oakland Raiders stands for the Mexican Anthem and sits down to boos for our National Anthem. Great disrespect! Next time NFL should suspend him for remainder of season. Attendance and ratings way down.
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) November 20, 2017
Later that hour, Trump tweeted about a different Fox & Friends segment, tagging the program and Fox Business host Stuart Varney in the tweet.
November 22
During the 5 a.m. hour of Fox & Friends First, co-host Rob Schmitt reported a “possible game-changer to the NFL anthem policy: the league owners have a new proposal to keep the players in the locker room.” Co-host Jillian Mele responded, “Is that really the solution? Social media says not so much” and termed the idea “a Band-Aid.” Fox’s Carley Shimkus then said the proposal “could cause more controversy for the NFL,” reiterating that owners are considering “keeping teams in the locker room during the national anthem next season” and airing a series of tweets from critical fans.
Roughly half an hour later, Trump tweeted:
The NFL is now thinking about a new idea - keeping teams in the Locker Room during the National Anthem next season. That’s almost as bad as kneeling! When will the highly paid Commissioner finally get tough and smart? This issue is killing your league!.....
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) November 22, 2017
November 28
During the 7 a.m. hour, Earhardt reported that “the NFL continues to struggle as protest against the anthem rages on. 23 players choosing to protest the performance during Sunday’s game.” Kilmeade linked the protests to weak attendance and ratings at games. The program then hosted “The Daily Rants Guy” Graham Allen and comedian and blogger Chad Prather to criticize the players and the league.
About 20 minutes after the segment, Trump tweeted:
At least 24 players kneeling this weekend at NFL stadiums that are now having a very hard time filling up. The American public is fed up with the disrespect the NFL is paying to our Country, our Flag and our National Anthem. Weak and out of control!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) November 28, 2017
This was one of two apparent Trump live-tweets that morning.
The president is live-tweeting
Here are the Trump tweets since our last update which I am reasonably confident are the result of the president directly responding to cable news programs he had been watching.
January 18. Six Fox & Friends live-tweets.
Left, Fox & Friends, 6:07 am
Kilmeade says, “It sounded to me like Gen. Kelly was compromising a little bit on the wall last night in the interview with Bret Baier, getting wobbly on the wall.”
Right, Trump, 6:15 am pic.twitter.com/E9sjRmAXpI— Matthew Gertz (@MattGertz) January 19, 2018
My guess is the next tweet is about a segment at the top of the 7:00 am hour.
Left, Fox & Friends, 7:03 am
Earhardt: "The president is going to be speaking in Pennsylvania today talking about the economy
Right, Trump, 7:53 am pic.twitter.com/sjp32aMZGY— Matthew Gertz (@MattGertz) January 19, 2018
Left, Fox & Friends, 7:09 am
More wall talk and airing a comment from Kelly last night.
Right, Trump, 8:16 am pic.twitter.com/41B8iBxyYI— Matthew Gertz (@MattGertz) January 19, 2018
Then the infamous CHIP tweet. I think it's a reaction to this comment.
Left, Fox & Friends, 7:17 am
Right, Trump, 8:37 am pic.twitter.com/pSYdewv3Do— Matthew Gertz (@MattGertz) January 19, 2018
And finally.
Left, Fox & Friends, 7:35 am
GINGRICH: How do they go home and explain that they care so much for people who are here illegally that they are willing to shut down the American military?
Right, Trump, 8:49 am pic.twitter.com/BzF68dNytc— Matthew Gertz (@MattGertz) January 19, 2018
January 20. Four Fox & Friends Weekend live-tweets.
Left, Fox & Friends Saturday, 6:06 am
Hegseth: “What Democrats care most about is making illegal immigrants legal. That's what it's all about.”
Campos-Duffy: “And if you wanted a deal for DACA, the deal is there! The deal has been spelled out by the pres.”
Right, Trump, 6:17 am pic.twitter.com/wQuhbnvQxt— Matthew Gertz (@MattGertz) January 20, 2018
Left, Fox & Friends Saturday, 6:17 am
Right, Trump, 6:33 am pic.twitter.com/XZ4PtnXItg— Matthew Gertz (@MattGertz) January 20, 2018
Left, Fox & Friends Saturday, 6:26 am
Right, Trump, 6:44 am pic.twitter.com/D61yfEqqrz— Matthew Gertz (@MattGertz) January 20, 2018
— Matthew Gertz (@MattGertz) January 20, 2018
January 23. Three Fox & Friends live-tweets.
Hmmmm
Left, Fox & Friends, 6:08 am
Right, Trump, 6:55 am pic.twitter.com/TC7F9CvwNf— Matthew Gertz (@MattGertz) January 23, 2018
Left, Fox & Friends, 8:41 am
Sanders says Vanity Fair report is “fake news”
Right, Trump, 9:16 am pic.twitter.com/IB1x6iTLNG— Matthew Gertz (@MattGertz) January 23, 2018
Working backwards assuming that half-hour gap is consistent, we get:
Left, Fox & Friends, 8:06 am
Right, Trump, 8:34 am pic.twitter.com/7NQaAtxrZr— Matthew Gertz (@MattGertz) January 23, 2018
January 27. One Fox & Friends Weekend live-tweet.
The president returned last night from Davos (where he likely didn't have access to Fox) and this morning is live-tweeting Fox & Friends.
Left, Fox & Friends, 6:17 am
Right, Trump, 6:55 am pic.twitter.com/HZ5EBrhlAl— Matthew Gertz (@MattGertz) January 27, 2018
January 28. One Fox & Friends Weekend live-tweet.
He might be pretty close to live.
Left, Fox & Friends, 8:12 am
Hegseth: “Rapper Jay-Z now the latest celebrity to slam President Trump.”
Right, Trump, 8:18 am pic.twitter.com/MtwL9kg3kk— Matthew Gertz (@MattGertz) January 28, 2018
February 1. One Fox & Friends First live-tweet.
Wait.
Left, Fox & Friends First, 5:36 am
“Donald Trump reaching 45.6 M Americans in his first state of the union speech ... Fox News taking top spot for viewers during the address, beating every other network for the first time ever, w a total of 11.7 M.”
Right, Trump, 7:02 am pic.twitter.com/9rT1wKNF5E— Matthew Gertz (@MattGertz) February 1, 2018
Shelby Jamerson contributed research.