Media Matters weekly newsletter, August 23

Welcome back to Media Matters’ weekly newsletter. This week:

  • Right-wing media spent much of the week melting down over the DNC
  • The right's courtship of RFK Jr. could have dire consequences for public health. 
  • Maria Bartiromo’s wild and “kind of racist” election conspiracy theory collapsed immediately.
  • Fox News didn’t air Trump’s comments denigrating Medal of Honor recipients.
  • Numerous Project 2025 groups have claimed abortion is comparable to or worse than the Holocaust.

If you want this delivered straight to your inbox, subscribe here.

This week in stupid 

  • Newsmax host Greg Kelly criticized Democratic presidential nominee Kamala Harris for smiling, saying of her demeanor, “It’s not presidential.”
  • Fox’s Jesse Watters promised to “get the truth” about former President Barack Obama’s birth certificate.
  • Newsmax’s Rob Schmitt said polls showing Kamala Harris in the lead are “almost like election meddling.”

This week in scary

  • Fox contributor Raymond Arroyo said a mobile reproductive health clinic outside the Democratic National Convention “shows a profound distrust and hatred for humanity.”
  • Lara Trump on Project 2025: “There are some ideas in there that are very productive and will be great for this country.”

Excuse me?

  • Jesse Watters speculated that China has a sex tape of Tim Walz.
  • On Newsmax, Rick Santorum claimed Barack Obama “reinstilled racism in this country by his behavior.”
  • Newsmax’s Greg Kelly falsely claimed Michelle Obama “never had a job.”
Maria Bartiromo with a Fox Business logo

Citation Molly Butler / Media Matters

Fox Business host Maria Bartiromo repeatedly used her show to peddle an election fraud conspiracy theory that she claimed originated with the wife of a friend of a friend in Texas and that she made no apparent effort to confirm. When the Texas Department of Public Safety and the local Republican Party investigated her reckless allegation, however, they discovered that none of it was true.

Last Sunday, Bartiromo posted an item on X alleging that “a massive line of immigrants” had been obtaining driver’s licenses and registering to vote at three Department of Motor Vehicles offices in Texas. The next day, Bartiromo brought this wildly flimsy allegation to the Fox airwaves, having apparently done no independent reporting to confirm that claims that she said originated with the wife of a friend of her friend. Of course, this claim was patently false.

Bartiromo has a long history of promoting wild claims about election fraud. During the 2020 election, she hosted Trumpist lawyer Sidney Powell to baselessly allege that Dominion Voting Systems had rigged the vote against Donald Trump. Bartiromo’s Dominion segments were featured in the company’s defamation lawsuit against vote, which resulted in her network paying a record settlement. But they had no apparent impact on her standing at Fox: she retains a weekly Fox News show and a three-hour weekday show on Fox Business.

Media Matters’ Matt Gertz notes that Fox’s response to Bartiromo “peddling thirdhand election fraud falsehoods she didn’t bother to check demonstrates how the network has abandoned anything resembling journalistic standards in its quest to return Donald Trump to the White House.”

Donald Trump striped background

Citation Melissa Joskow / Media Matters

At an August 15 campaign event, Donald Trump claimed that the Presidential Medal of Freedom he awarded to a Republican billionaire is “much better” than the Medal of Honor awarded to service members because those receipts are either injured or dead compared to his “healthy, beautiful” donor. Fox News had not aired Trump’s comments a single time as of 1 p.m. August 19.

For years, Fox has frequently defended or outright ignored Trump’s offensive comments about those who have served in the military. During his 2016 campaign, Trump attacked a Gold Star family and also attacked then-Arizona Sen John McCain, saying, “I like people who weren’t captured.” His chief of staff confirmed reports that Trump called fallen soldiers “suckers” and “losers” and canceled a visit to honor American war dead in 2018.

Meanwhile, Fox has a long history of melting down about perceived slights to the military coming from Democrats. In 2014, Fox freaked out over Barack Obama saluting two Marines while holding a coffee cup. Fox has been smearing Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz’s 24 years of service ever since Kamala Harris named him as her running mate, pushing false claims of “stolen valor.”

The hypocrisy is clear. If a Democrat had said even a tenth of what Trump has said about veterans, Fox personalities would be undergoing a historic meltdown. Instead, they’re merely serving their leader’s ambitions for the presidency.

Project 2025 and abortion

Citation Molly Butler / Media Matters

Numerous Project 2025 groups have claimed over the years that abortion is comparable to or even worse than the Holocaust. Those partners have called abortion the “American Holocaust”; said that “someday, abortion will be viewed historically as a modern-day Holocaust, maybe even worse”; and claimed that “America’s holocaust against the unborn makes Hitler’s holocaust pale in comparison.”

We’ve told you before that Project 2025’s proposals include extreme rollbacks to reproductive rights, including access to surrogacy, IVF, mifepristone, and contraception. Recently we’ve documented that numerous Project 2025 groups have also pushed the false claim that abortions are never medically necessary.

Project 2025 is closely tied to Donald Trump and JD Vance, who wrote the foreword for Project 2025 architect Kevin Roberts’ book.

In case you missed it 

  • Right-wing media are mischaracterizing a Kamala Harris economic plan as “price controls,” denying the existence of price gouging, and calling Harris a communist.
  • Mainstream media have effectively whitewashed Donald Trump’s position on abortion during their DNC coverage.
  • Longtime Trump adviser Roger Stone recently said that Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp is “going to prison” and is the “lowest form of life known to man.”
  • As Rep. James Comer’s (R-KY) Biden impeachment inquiry collapses, Fox News is moving on to his Tim Walz-China smears.
  • Newsmax personalities keep floating baseless rumors that Harris has a “substance abuse problem.”
  • During the opening night of the Democratic National Convention, three women spoke onstage about their experiences with pregnancies, miscarriages, and abortions. Fox News ignored these speeches.
  • Conservative media defended Trump’s corporate tax cuts and made false claims about Harris’ proposed 28% rate.
  • It seems like Turning Point USA founder Charlie Kirk lied to a child about arguing for the repeal of the Civil Rights Act.
  • Fox has mentioned the Inflation Reduction Act more than twice as much as CNN has — and 40% more than MSNBC has — since the bill’s passage two years ago.