The next spin: These weren’t Trump supporters
Following the insurrection’s failure, however, right-wing media pivoted to new narratives that attempted to cast responsibility with anyone except the obvious perpetrators.
Sean Hannity may have already been hedging his bets. In the same radio broadcast when he said the assault on the Capitol had been “building for a long period of time,” he also cited reports speculating “that groups like antifa, other radical groups … were there to cause trouble.”
Likewise, The Gateway Pundit also alleged on January 6 that “at least one bus load of Antifa goons infiltrated the Trump rally as part of a false flag operation,” even as the site was openly celebrating the Capitol assault itself.
Newsmax anchor Tom Basile also alleged on the air during the riot that “we've seen in the past interference from leftist groups that are prone to violence, who have infiltrated — that oftentimes infiltrate rallies for their own purposes. And, again, we're not entirely sure what is happening here.”
Fox host Laura Ingraham speculated that night that the insurrectionists weren’t really Trump supporters, on the grounds that she had “never seen Trump rally attendees wearing helmets” and other accoutrements such as knee and elbow pads.
Fox Business anchor Maria Bartiromo also claimed on January 19 — during a seemingly normal headline update on security preparations for Biden’s inauguration: “A new report says that some far-right protesters have discussed posing as members of the National Guard to infiltrate the inauguration — the way Democrats infiltrated two weeks ago and put on MAGA clothing.”
Fox News also pounced on the arrest of Utah man John Sullivan, claiming that his past attendance at Black Lives Matters protests indicated that left-wing elements had stoked the assault on the Capitol. In fact, Sullivan had long been ostracized by local leftist movements in Utah — in part due to his brother’s association with the Proud Boys — while viewing him as someone who was essentially seeking out conflict under any ideological banner.
OAN’s Pearson Sharp also claimed in March, “Radical anti-Trump extremists attacked the Capitol on January 6 in an effort to discredit President Trump and his supporters. … History will show it was the Democrats, and not the Republicans, who called for this violence, and no amount of doctored evidence or falsified testimonies will change that.” (Though as noted above, his OAN colleagues had argued at the time that the action by the “protesters” was now justification for Pence to stop the count of the Electoral College votes.)