A March 2 report on Sinclair Broadcast Group’s morning news program The National Desk hid the conservative affiliations of a right-wing activist while quoting his opposition to student debt cancellation. The report, which aired on 68 Sinclair-owned or -operated local TV stations around the country, also pushed misleading claims from two conservative organizations about student debt relief while failing to include independent voices in favor of debt cancellation.
Sinclair's misleading attack on student debt cancellation misrepresents a conservative activist as just a concerned college grad
Written by Zachary Pleat
Published
Democrats’ plans for student debt cancellation range from between $10,000 and $50,000 per borrower, and CNBC reported that the lower figure would cancel all student debt for about 33% of federal student loan borrowers and the higher amount would end student debt for 80% of borrowers.
The misleading Sinclair report from correspondent Angela Brown, which was heavily tilted against canceling student debt, aired absurd commentary from a man named Matt Noyes. Noyes called student debt cancellation “unfair” and made light of the burden of student debt -- talking about his “sacrifices” of making his own coffee instead of going “to Starbucks every day. Because if the federal government’s going to pick up the tab, why not.” The Sinclair report failed to mention that millions of Americans put off starting families or buying homes because of their student debt burden.
Brown misleadingly introduced Noyes as only “a graduate of the University of Albany” who has paid off his student loans. But according to his author profile at the libertarian Mises Institute, Noyes works for the Japanese Conservative Union, the Japanese counterpart of the American Conservative Union, which puts on the right-wing Conservative Political Action Conference each year. (Incidentally, the JCU is led by an influential figure in a Japanese cult.)
Brown next cited the conservative National Taxpayer Union to counter Democrats’ statements that student debt cancellation would help the economy. But economists and other experts say student debt relief would be beneficial. A Moody’s Economics vice president, William Foster, told NPR that even partial student debt cancellation would have significant results for the economy, and it would help address rising income inequality. According to Business Insider, a paper from Bard College’s Levy Economic Institute estimated that canceling student debt “would translate to an increase of $86 billion to $108 billion a year, on average, to GDP.” Business Insider and a special CNBC report on student debt cancellation noted many other benefits, as well.
Lastly, Brown turned to the right-wing organization Campus Reform, which is funded by conservative dark money groups and often posts poorly sourced daily articles alleging bias by professors against conservative students or policies. These misinformation-laden posts by Campus Reform -- which has also compiled contact information of college professors to facilitate harassment -- sometimes lead to violent threats against them.
Brown cited this organization to push the claim that canceling student debt would just cause colleges to increase tuition even more, completely ignoring the role a lack of government funding plays in tuition increases. As CNBC reported, a comprehensive report on tuition increases from the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities stated that “limited state funding has contributed to rising college costs.” Michael Mitchell, the lead author of the report, told CNBC that “nearly every state has shifted the responsibility of funding higher education from the state to students over the last 25 years.” Economic Policy Institute’s Josh Bivens also told CNBC: “Policymakers cut back funding for higher education, and these cutbacks were made up with huge increases in tuition costs, forcing people to take on more debt.” Bivens said canceling student debt is “recompense for a string of bad policy failures.”
Citation
From the March 2, 2021, edition of Sinclair Broadcast Group's The National Desk
JAN JEFFCOAT (ANCHOR): Student debt forgiveness -- it is a hot topic with no shortage of opinions. Both the White House and Democrats on Capitol Hill are now pushing to cancel some of the $1.7 trillion in student debt owed by Americans. Question though, is that the right move? Angela Brown joins us right now with the details on that. Angela, what did you find out on this story?
ANGELA BROWN (CORRESPONDENT): Well, Jan, leading Democrats in Congress say up to $50,000 of student debt should be forgiven for every person. President Biden is pushing for roughly closer to $10,000 in forgiveness. But no matter the number, there’s growing concern over how student debt forgiveness could impact our economy and the message it sends to graduates who have already paid off their loans.
(VIDEO BEGINS)
MATT NOYES: I could say it’s unfair, but I guess that would be an understatement.
(VIDEO ENDS)
BROWN: Matt Noyes is a graduate of the University of Albany, and like many students he relied on loans to help pay his way through school. But those loans did not last long. Matt says he made personal sacrifices to keep his expenses down right out of college, allowing him to quickly pay back what he owed. Now, he says, the Democrats’ plan to forgive student debt would put all of those sacrifices in vain.
(VIDEO BEGINS)
NOYES: If I had known my debt was going to be forgiven, I would have made very different choices. For one, instead of brewing coffee at home for 10 cents a cup, you know, I would have gone to Starbucks every day. Because if the federal government’s going to pick up the tab, why not?
(VIDEO ENDS)
BROWN: Congressional Democrats insist canceling student debt would jumpstart an American economy ravaged by the effects of the coronavirus pandemic.
…
BROWN: But Brandon Arnold, the executive vice president of the National Taxpayers Union, says it would do exactly the opposite, adding to the $27 trillion national debt and forcing generations of American taxpayers to foot the bill for other people’s college education.
…
BROWN: Student debt forgiveness also raises questions about the root problem, the ballooning cost of college tuition. Angela Morabito represents the watchdog group Campus Reform. She thinks cancelling student debt would embolden colleges to charge more in the long run, adding fuel to the student debt crisis.