As President Donald Trump and Senate Republicans rush to push through a Supreme Court justice appointment following the death of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, their allies in conservative media are attempting to scare audiences into believing the left will respond with violence if a Republican nominee like Trump pick Amy Coney Barrett is confirmed.
In reality, many of these predictions rest almost entirely on a few scattered tweets and distorted interpretations of comments from public figures. For example, conservative media pointed to tweets by writers Reza Aslan and Laura Bassett as evidence that “radical left-wing activists are now planning” to engage in violence. Right-wing media also seized on a comment from CNN anchor Don Lemon that “we're going to have to blow up the entire system” — even though these remarks were made in reference to reforming the Electoral College, and Lemon later clarified his comments. And after Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY) argued that the political moment following Ginsburg’s death should “radicalize” supporters to vote in November’s election, critics assailed her comments as supposedly calling for violence.
Right-wing media figures have also cited Black Lives Matter protests — which have been largely peaceful, ongoing nationwide demonstrations against police brutality and systemic racism — as an example of the type of violence the left will supposedly resort to if the Senate confirms Trump’s nominee.
These scare tactics are not new. Conservative media figures have been hyping potential political violence for weeks, and the battle over the Supreme Court vacancy simply provides another venue for this right-wing fearmongering ahead of Election Day.
- While discussing ongoing racial justice protests on the September 22 edition of Fox News’ America’s Newsroom, former White House press secretary Ari Fleischer claimed, “This is radicalism,” adding: Second point, it’s about to get worse. Just wait till the Supreme Court hearing on whoever President Trump names.” Fleischer continued, “Remember the violence, the radicalism in the halls of the Congress when Brett Kavanaugh was named? This is now going to happen even more so unfolding throughout October as those hearings are underway in the Senate. So we’re into a totally new world with totally new tactics by the far left.”
- The same day, Ohio radio host Bob Frantz claimed that Ocasio-Cortez’s comments following Ginsburg’s death constitute a literal “call for violence in the streets.” Frantz argued that if Democrats “give tacit approval to the violence over the police brutality issue, … what do you think they are going to say about replacing Ginsburg just 40, now what, 43 days or so before the election? They are going to not only give tacit approval, they are going to call for violence in the streets.”