During the February 20 broadcast of his nationally syndicated radio show, Bill O'Reilly suggested that the United States “hand over everything to the Iraqis as fast as humanly possible” because "[t]here are so many nuts in the country -- so many crazies -- that we can't control them." O'Reilly then claimed that the “big mistake” was actually “the crazy-people underestimation.”

As Media Matters for America has documented, during a November 30, 2005, appearance on NBC's Today, O'Reilly called those advocating immediate withdrawal from Iraq “pinheads” and compared them to Hitler appeasers.

O'Reilly's comments followed his mention of a report regarding Karbala, a province in the Shiite-controlled Iraqi south. O'Reilly falsely claimed that “the mayor of Karbala ... has banned any further government dealings with the American military in his province.” In fact, according to a February 20 Associated Press report, the Karbala governing council suspended contact with U.S. forces “until U.S. forces apologize” for their behavior during a recent visit to the governor's office. The Karbala provincial spokesman complained that “U.S. soldiers brought dogs inside the [governor's office] building,” which was “considered an insult by the council,” and “blocked roads leading to the governor's office, preventing council members and the governor from parking cars outside the building.” While the AP reported the Karbala spokesman's specific complaints, O'Reilly characterized the complaints as “the mayor of Karbala” alleging that U.S. soldiers were “not behaving well.”

From the February 20 broadcast of Westwood One's The Radio Factor with Bill O'Reilly:

O'REILLY: Somewhat of a disturbing report out of Iraq, and it's more important than it first appears. The governor of -- or the mayor of Karbala, which is a town in the south part of Iraq, Shiite-controlled, has banned any further government dealings with the American military in his province, saying that they're not behaving well.

Now, it's a small little thing, but I picked up on it, because here is the essential problem in Iraq. There are so many nuts in the country -- so many crazies -- that we can't control them. And I don't -- we're never gonna be able to control them. So the only solution to this is to hand over everything to the Iraqis as fast as humanly possible. Because we just can't control these crazy people. This is all over the place. And that was the big mistake about America: They didn't -- it was the crazy-people underestimation. We did not know how to deal with them -- still don't. But they're just all over the place.