President Donald Trump continues to wage war against the results of the 2020 presidential election. Though it’s been nearly two weeks since every major news organization declared former Vice President Joe Biden the clear winner of the race, Trump’s democracy-degrading attack on that outcome has prevented his successor from officially beginning the transition to power.
While Biden has expressed concerns that Trump’s delays will hamper his administration’s ability to efficiently distribute coming COVID-19 vaccines, Trump’s defenders have excused his decisions on the basis that it’s not actually out of the ordinary for candidates to exhaust every last legal option before acknowledging losses.
In one sense, Trump’s supporters are correct: Recounts are a common occurrence in U.S. politics. Races for House and Senate regularly undergo recounts, sometimes automatically and other times at the request of a campaign. At the presidential level, this has happened a couple times as well. Then-Vice President Al Gore pushed for a recount in the decisive state of Florida in 2000, only to lose the state -- and presidency -- by 537 votes. In 2016, Green Party candidate Jill Stein filed for recounts in Michigan, Wisconsin, and Pennsylvania; only Wisconsin was actually completed.
But neither example proves particularly useful to Trump, as his campaign called the 2016 recounts a “scam” and the 2000 race was much, much closer than this year’s. Additionally, the 9/11 Commission Report found that the delayed presidential transition following the 2000 election slowed President George W. Bush’s ability to get his national security team in place, which may have hampered the response to the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks, making it a poor example for Trump’s supporters to cite.
With examples pulled from modern presidential history failing to provide solid justification for Trump’s fight, pro-Trump media have started pointing to a different politician: Stacey Abrams, the 2018 Democratic candidate for governor of Georgia.
Comparisons to Abrams don’t hold up to scrutiny, but that isn’t stopping conservative media from making them.
“President Trump seems to be taking a page from the Democrat’s playbook, but he doesn’t have the mainstream media on his side,” wrote Fox News’ Brian Flood. “Former Georgia gubernatorial candidate Stacey Abrams was praised by the mainstream media for refusing to concede after her 2018 loss to Republican Brian Kemp, while accusing the GOP of stealing the election.”
Flood is either mistaken about the circumstances of Abrams’ 2018 loss or he’s being disingenuous in his criticism. Either way, it’s worth examining how these situations are different.
Abrams lost in 2018 to then-Georgia Secretary of State Brian Kemp by 54,723 votes. Abrams ended her bid for governor on November 16, 10 days after the election, and she wasn’t too happy about it. In a speech, Abrams acknowledged that Kemp would be the next governor of Georgia while criticizing his role in purging around 670,000 names from the state’s voter rolls in 2017 and roughly 53,000 a month ahead of the election. She said: