Conservatives are baselessly blaming the Black Lives Matter movement after a white man was kidnapped and attacked in Chicago. Four black people were arrested on January 4 after a Facebook Live video surfaced of a young white man with special needs being tied up, assaulted, and threatened. In the video, one of the assailants said, “Fuck Donald Trump, fuck white people.”
Chicago police have filed hate crime and battery charges against the four suspects.
Several conservatives and “alt-right” figures blamed the attack on the Black Lives Matter movement and used the social media hashtag #BLMKidnapping in discussions about the event. Yet the video does not reference Black Lives Matter and thus far, no connection between the assailants and Black Lives Matter has been established. CNN reported “police said they have not been able to make any connection to the Black Lives Matter activist group, contrary to some reports circulating on social media.”
Paul Joseph Watson, editor-at-large for conspiracy theorist and Donald Trump ally Alex Jones’ website Infowars, was among the first to tie the attack to Black Lives Matter, with a Twitter post instructing others, “#BLMKidnapping is the hashtag to get this story trending.” Watson’s own write-up of the story on Infowars, which he linked to in his tweet, makes no mention of Black Lives Matter or a connection between the attack and the movement.
#BLMKidnapping is the hashtag to get this story trending. https://t.co/gNaBrifiLm
— Paul Joseph Watson (@PrisonPlanet) January 5, 2017
Watson later described the victim of the attack as “the BLM torture victim” on Twitter.
Rape apologist and “alt-right” figure Mike Cernovich wrote, “#BlackLivesMatter activists in custody after filming kidnapping video,” then used Watson’s hashtag to write, “#BLMKidnapping suspects are in custody.” He also described one of the suspects as a “#BLMKidnapping ring leader.” On his blog, Cernovich made the same assertion, without evidence to back it up.
Chicago #BlackLivesMatter Supporters Kidnap, Torture Trump Supporter on Facebook Live Videohttps://t.co/laLfjacwCA
— Mike Cernovich ???? (@Cernovich) January 4, 2017
Lee Stranahan, a Breitbart contributor, questioned Cernovich’s assertions, particularly his claim that the attackers were Black Lives Matters supporters. Stranahan also pointed out that mainstream media reports on the attack had not mentioned Cernovich’s claims.
Hey Mike - is there backup from claims of 1) attackers BLM supporters 2) victim drinking toilet water 3) victim voted for Trump @Cernovich
— Lee Stranahan (@stranahan) January 5, 2017
I haven't watched the whole 30 minute video, but not seeing those claims elsewhere in any MSM @Cernovich
— Lee Stranahan (@stranahan) January 5, 2017
In contrast to Stranahan, fellow Breitbart contributor Katie McHugh referenced “the victim of the Chicago #BLMkidnapping.”
Fake news promoter and “alt-right” figure Jack Posobiec recorded a Periscope video about the attack with the #BLMKidnapping hashtag and claimed that the attackers were “members of Black Lives Matter in Chicago.”
Trump supporter Bill Mitchell described the attack as a “#BLM atrocity” that “proves that given enough time, evil always shows its true nature.”
This #BLM atrocity proves that given enough time, evil always shows its true nature.
— Bill Mitchell (@mitchellvii) January 5, 2017
Michael Flynn Jr., son of incoming Trump national security adviser Michael Flynn, also labeled the event with the #BLMKidnapping in several tweets. Flynn was removed from the presidential transition team after it was reported that he helped to spread several fake news stories and conspiracy theories.
Will outgoing @POTUS say anything to condemn #BLMKidnapping ?? my guess is heeeeeeellll nooo...
— Michael Flynn Jr???? (@mflynnJR) January 5, 2017
Not one mention of #BLMKidnapping on front page @nytimes @washingtonpost @USATODAY @WSJ @politico Surprised? I'm not... pic.twitter.com/9P868rIGW5
— Michael Flynn Jr???? (@mflynnJR) January 5, 2017
Gavin McInnes, who has a history of making racist commentary, also used the hashtag.
Really @TwitterMoments ? Bernie's Tweet poster? #BLMKidnapping
— Gavin McInnes (@Gavin_McInnes) January 5, 2017
Conservative Steven Crowder wrote, “#BLMKidnapping and the media's reaction is proof positive that the left doesn't care about racism.”
#BLMKidnapping and the media's reaction is proof positive that the left doesn't care about racism. Only when it's a political tool.
— Steven Crowder (@scrowder) January 5, 2017
Conservatives have frequently, without evidence, blamed the Black Lives Matter movement for violence. Radio host Rush Limbaugh called them “a terrorist group committing hate crimes,” while frequent Fox News guest David Clarke called them a “subversive movement” attempting to “overthrow” the government. Fox host Sean Hannity compared Black Lives Matter to the Ku Klux Klan, Bill O’Reilly compared them to Nazis, and a Fox News graphic described it as a “murder movement.”