During his Senate confirmation hearing, Trump nominee for secretary of defense and former Fox News host Pete Hegseth falsely claimed that military commanders are forced to “meet quotas to have a certain number of female infantry officers or infantry enlisted.” Hegseth further claimed this “disparages those women who are incredibly capable of meeting that standard.” Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand (D-NY) pushed back on his claim, correctly noting, “Commanders do not have to have a quota for women in the infantry. It does not exist.”
Former Fox host Pete Hegseth repeats right-wing lies about demographic quotas during his Senate confirmation hearing
Written by Chloe Simon
Research contributions from Emma Mae Weber
Published
PETE HEGSETH: I have never disparaged women serving in the military. I respect every single female service member that has put on the uniform, past and present. My critiques, Senator, recently and in the past, and from personal experience, have been instances where I've seen standards lowered.
…
The book that has been referenced multiple times here, The War on Warriors, I spent months talking to active duty service members — men and women, low ranks, high ranks, combat arms and not combat arms — and what each and every one of them told me, and which personal instances have shown me, is that in ways direct, indirect, overt and subtle, standards have been changed inside infantry training units, ranger school, infantry battalions to ensure that commanders meet —
SEN. KIRSTEN GILLIBRAND (D-NY): Give me one example. Please give me an example. I get you’re making these generalized statements.
HEGSETH: Commanders meet quotas to have a certain number of female infantry officers or infantry enlisted, and that disparages those women who are incredibly capable of meeting that standard.
GILLIBRAND: Commanders do not have to have a quota for women in the infantry. That does not exist. It does not exist. And your statements are creating the impression that these exist, because they do not. They are not quotas. We want the most lethal force.
Gender quotas, along with quotas for other demographic groups, do not exist in the military. A Defense official confirmed to USA Today that “there are no such quotas” after the exchange between Hegseth and Gillibrand. In fact, despite right-wing media's frequent false claims otherwise, the use of demographic quotas have fallen out of practice in society since the Supreme Court ruled racial quotas presumptively unconstitutional almost half a century ago.
According to the Congressional Research Service, the Department of Defense does have a “definition of diversity to be used throughout DOD.” However it still does not “outline targets or quotas for the recruitment, retention, or promotion of historically underrepresented demographic groups.” In 2015, when then-President Barack Obama’s Secretary of Defense Ash Carter opened all military roles to women, he wrote in his guidelines that “equal opportunity likely will not mean equal participation by men and women in all specialties, and there will be no quotas.”
Right-wing media have repeatedly attacked nonexistent quotas or diversity efforts, blaming them for alleged problems within education, corporate hiring practices, and for different safety incidents in the country. Right-wing media also previously went after Carter for opening up combat roles to women, with figures suggesting that the military could “have its integrity compromised or safety compromised” as a result, despite gender quotas not being part of the policy.