In State of the Union coverage, media adopted term “personal accounts”
Written by Gabe Wildau, Nicole Casta, Katie Barge, Jeremy Cluchey & Andrew Seifter
Published
The media coverage and analysis of President Bush's February 2 State of the Union address and the Democratic response indicated that the Bush administration's pressure on reporters -- to use the term “personal accounts” rather than “private accounts” in discussing Bush's social security privatization plan -- is working. As Media Matters for America has noted, polling shows that the public responds less favorably to the term “private accounts,” a term that Bush himself has used in the past.
A Media Matters analysis found that 18 media hosts, correspondents, and commentators used the White House-approved term “personal accounts,” while 13 referred to “private accounts.”
On the network news broadcasts, only one correspondent used the term “private accounts,” while 8 hosts, correspondents, and commentators adopted Bush's preferred term, “personal accounts.” On the cables, 10 used the term “personal accounts,” while 12 used the term “private accounts.”
Media Matters monitored all discussion of Bush's address and the Democrats' response on FOX News, CNN, and MSNBC from 5 p.m. February 2 until 12 a.m. February 3, as well as ABC World News Tonight, CBS Evening News, and NBC Nightly News on February 2, and ABC's Good Morning America, CBS' Early Show, and NBC's Today on February 3. Post-speech and Democratic response coverage on the networks, which ran from 10:30 p.m. to 11 p.m., was also included.
“private accounts,” “privatize,” or “privatization” | Used both terms | “personal accounts” | |
FOX News | Democratic strategist Bob Beckel FOX News co-host Sean Hannity FOX host John Gibson FOX News co-host Alan Colmes |
NPR senior correspondent Juan Williams NPR national political correspondent Mara Liasson Roll Call executive editor Morton M. Kondracke FOX News managing editor and anchor Brit Hume FOX News correspondent Brian Wilson |
FOX News chief White House correspondent Carl Cameron FOX News TV and radio host Tony Snow FOX News White House correspondent Wendell Goler Former Speaker of the House Newt Gingrich |
CNN | CNN host Wolf Blitzer CNN host Paula Zahn CNN White House correspondent Dana Bash Former presidential adviser David Gergen |
CNN senior White House correspondent John King | CNN host Judy Woodruff |
MSNBC | Democratic strategist Hilary Rosen Newsweek managing editor Jon Meacham NBC News correspondent David Shuster Wall Street Journal political editor John Harwood |
NBC News Mike Viqueira NBC host Tim Russert MSNBC political analyst Ron Reagan Jr. NBC News political analyst Howard Fineman MSNBC host Keith Olbermann |
MSNBC host Chris Matthews (referred to “personal” accounts 12 times, “private” accounts twice) NBC News White House correspondent David Gregory Actor and conservative activist Ron Silver NBC White House correspondent Norah O'Donnell MSNBC host and former Representative Joe Scarborough (R-FL) |
ABC | ABC News chief White House correspondent Terry Moran | ABC This Week host George Stephanopoulos ABC World News Tonight anchor Peter Jennings ABC News congressional correspondent Linda Douglass |
ABC News congressional correspondent Linda Douglass ABC News White House Correspondent Kate Snow ABC Good Morning America co-anchor Charlie Gibson |
CBS | CBS News national correspondent Thalia Assuras CBS News business correspondent Anthony Mason CBS News chief White House correspondent John Roberts CBS News White House Correspondent Bill Plante |
||
NBC | NBC host Tim Russert NBC Nightly News anchor Brian Williams NBC News Senior White House correspondent David Gregory Former House majority leader Dick Armey (R-TX) |
Former Senate majority leader George Mitchell (D-ME) |