YouTube has reversed its initial ban on a prominent white nationalist site, claiming the site’s channel did not actually violate YouTube policies. Yet a host on the channel has repeatedly used language that was also invoked by the manifestos of multiple mass shooters and has given credence to the conspiracy theory that the Sandy Hook mass shooting was fake.
Earlier this summer, YouTube announced that it would prohibit “videos alleging that a group is superior in order to justify discrimination, segregation or exclusion based on qualities like age, gender, race, caste, religion, sexual orientation or veteran status,” specifically mentioning content that promotes “Nazi ideology.” YouTube also said the new policy would prohibit “denying that well-documented violent events, like the Holocaust or the shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary, took place.” In August, the platform banned a handful of channels that were tied to white nationalism. One of those was VDare, a well-known white nationalist site. But on August 27, YouTube reversed its ban of VDare, emailing the site that the channel “is not in violation of our Terms of Service” and later telling CNN that while the channel featured potentially “offensive” content, “after a re-review of the content, we reinstated” it.
A review of VDare’s channel, VDare TV -- which started posting regularly only late last year -- finds multiple videos that echo white supremacist rhetoric used in the posted manifestos of the alleged Christchurch, New Zealand, and El Paso, Texas, mass shooters, who killed more than 70 people combined. One such video includes a claim that the alleged El Paso shooter’s use of the word “invasion” to describe immigration in his manifesto was “apt,” and other videos push anti-Semitism and invoke Nazi termonology.
- In an August 10 video, VDare host Wilson Hewlett said the alleged El Paso shooter used the “apt term” of “invasion,” adding that because the shooter “is alleged to have cited the unwelcome Hispanic influx into our country, it's now off the table for anyone to mention this phenomenon, even if it's actually happening.” And days after the Christchurch mass shooting, Hewlett said that “the nation-wrecking policies” that are causing “Americans and others” to come “under invasion” are “as much to blame for the Christchurch incident as the shooter himself.” In another video, he mentioned President Donald Trump’s attempt to fund a wall on the southern border via executive order, saying, “With this peaceful opposition to invasion thwarted, it’s no wonder that one Aussie regrettably chose another path. The shooter in Christchurch, New Zealand, let the world know, via manifesto, the reasons for his actions.”